Quote History Originally Posted By Gamma762:The best weather alert radio by far is the Reecom brand, the basic model is the
R-1630.
It does things that no other alert radio does and some things that only a few let you do.
It has selectable county or multiple counties for warning areas.
It has selectable types of alerts. You can turn off amber alerts and other annoyances.
It is the only one (AFAIK) that properly responds to the "End Of Message" data burst, so it turns off after the alert is played. Every other one just continues playing for 5 minutes or whatever.
It has AA batteries for backup in case of power outage, and the batteries last a long time. The Midlands I had would run batteries down very rapidly if the power was out, which isn't all that uncommon during severe weather events out in the country.
The signal reception is pretty good, noticeably better than the Midlands I had.
View Quote
I have been running this side by side with my Midland WR400 and its getting a workout today in N. Texas.
So far I can confirm that:
- Both the radios play the main alert once, then stop at the EOM and dont drone on for long time.
- Both are plenty loud with alerting
- Both have eye catching visual alerts, Reecom uses very bright multicolored LED and WR400 uses bright multi color flashing word indicators
- Both have select-able alerts types for your county (SAME/FIPS) and I was able to turn off the audible alerts for most everything except for the few warnings I wanted to know about like Severe TStorm or Tornado Warnings but still get a visual alert for the silenced ones.
- The Reecom does seem to alert a few seconds prior to the Midland most of the time but I dont know if thats just where its located in the house or what. Maybe this is indicative of better reception? Not sure.
- Both arent hard to setup but the UI on either could be better for sure. Once you get the hang of how they work its pretty easy just not always intuitive.
I still need to test the battery backup but have no problems believing the Reecom is better, I was never impressed with the WR400 battery performance.
The Reecom doesnt have a battery life indicator, which annoys me, but its not the end of the world. The WR400 has a battery indicator and its almost always at 1 bar even with fresh batteries.
The Reecom 1630 appears to do everything the Midland WR400 does (minus AM/FM radio) for nearly half the price.
I dont think it does anything that the WR400 doesnt but it is a good performer and a better value than the WR400 if you dont mind not having the integrated AM/FM radio.