User Panel
Originally Posted By PeepEater: May have been state sales taxes that are not paid as well. View Quote Neither the PD or Grant would have been paying state sales tax. The PD does not because they are a government entity and Grant would not because he is buying it for resale and would charge sales tax when he sells it. What he would avoid paying is the 11% excise tax that is added to the cost of ammo for sale to civilians. When a PD buys ammo for duty use they do not pay that. My guess is that is what he was avoiding. What is so hard to understand about misrepresentation for the purposes of tax evasion??? |
|
|
Originally Posted By JeepersCreepers: I don't get it either. The distributor agreed to sell a product for X price, and they received X price for the product. Business transaction, done deal. Should the distributor blacklist him and the police dept. and refuse to sell anything to them ever again? Absolutely. His LE friend did the transaction, all he did was go pick it up after it was already paid for. Am I committing stolen valor if I (non-military) get my military friend to order something from Lowe's with his 10% discount and then I go pick it up? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By JeepersCreepers: Originally Posted By 42ATK: How is that a crime to get LE pricing? I don't get it either. The distributor agreed to sell a product for X price, and they received X price for the product. Business transaction, done deal. Should the distributor blacklist him and the police dept. and refuse to sell anything to them ever again? Absolutely. Originally Posted By AlabamaFan64: Fraud. Representative himself as LE. His LE friend did the transaction, all he did was go pick it up after it was already paid for. Am I committing stolen valor if I (non-military) get my military friend to order something from Lowe's with his 10% discount and then I go pick it up? Yes. And if you were doing it in volume for resale, a fraud and a criminal. |
|
GD- "It's kind of like wading through through slimy lake bed with your feet to find clams below the surface".
- gtfoxy |
Why the fuck is that a felony?
|
|
I'm not always a dick, just kidding, go fuck yourself.
|
What did The Chart™ say he should have been sentenced to?
|
|
|
Looks like no one bothered reading or understanding the article link. Grant was convicted of a state telecom fraud 1st degree misdemeanor.
The fraud was representing the ammo was for PD sales not retail sales. I asked if the feds could still go after him for not paying the 11% federal excise tax. I think it’s possible. |
|
|
|
lol
Hope he gets his ass kicked in jail. |
|
You're not the board darling you think you are.
|
So now getting too good of a deal on ammo is a felony
|
|
|
Originally Posted By JeepersCreepers: I don't get it either. The distributor agreed to sell a product for X price, and they received X price for the product. Business transaction, done deal. Should the distributor blacklist him and the police dept. and refuse to sell anything to them ever again? Absolutely. His LE friend did the transaction, all he did was go pick it up after it was already paid for. Am I committing stolen valor if I (non-military) get my military friend to order something from Lowe's with his 10% discount and then I go pick it up? View Quote There is a significant difference between avoiding paying taxes using fraud and using the discount of a private company. The government is going to allow skipping out on taxes to slide. The government missed out on their tax money as the LEO and Grant fraudulently represented what the ammo would be used for. It's no different than you claiming you have dependents you don't have on your taxes. |
|
|
Hopefully he is forced out of business over this. Dude has always been a piece of shit.
|
|
|
You're not the board darling you think you are.
|
|
Originally Posted By osprey21: is right... read post #5 above - RIF View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By osprey21: Originally Posted By Millennial: So now getting too good of a deal on ammo is a felony C'mon, who hasn't helped their friends or family buy a blue label Glock or get a big mil/responder discount on a high-dollar Vortex scope or checked out for them at Lowes? |
|
|
Discounts for me but not for thee.
|
|
|
Originally Posted By C-4: Why not suspend the sentence if they pay the police supply company back the difference in price? $1,000 fine seems pointless. Why not make restitution part of the deal to drop some of the charges? The cop got fucked hard with the felony conviction but this guy skates with only 90 days in jail and a misdemeanor? Did he testify against the cop? View Quote Police agencies don't pay federal excise tax 10-11%. |
|
|
Didn't even know an excise tax existed on ammo for civilians!
|
|
|
If they hadn’t been lazy and dumb about it, they’d still getting away with it.
|
|
http://www.guntechtips.com
|
Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: Neither the PD or Grant would have been paying state sales tax. The PD does not because they are a government entity and Grant would not because he is buying it for resale and would charge sales tax when he sells it. What he would avoid paying is the 11% excise tax that is added to the cost of ammo for sale to civilians. When a PD buys ammo for duty use they do not pay that. My guess is that is what he was avoiding. What is so hard to understand about misrepresentation for the purposes of tax evasion??? View Quote Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Millennial: Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Millennial: Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: Neither the PD or Grant would have been paying state sales tax. The PD does not because they are a government entity and Grant would not because he is buying it for resale and would charge sales tax when he sells it. What he would avoid paying is the 11% excise tax that is added to the cost of ammo for sale to civilians. When a PD buys ammo for duty use they do not pay that. My guess is that is what he was avoiding. What is so hard to understand about misrepresentation for the purposes of tax evasion??? Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. Considering his history of trying to do price fixing with other forum vendors. He certainly was just padding his profits while charging his customers the most he could get them to pay. This dude is a piece of shit. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Millennial: Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Millennial: Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: Neither the PD or Grant would have been paying state sales tax. The PD does not because they are a government entity and Grant would not because he is buying it for resale and would charge sales tax when he sells it. What he would avoid paying is the 11% excise tax that is added to the cost of ammo for sale to civilians. When a PD buys ammo for duty use they do not pay that. My guess is that is what he was avoiding. What is so hard to understand about misrepresentation for the purposes of tax evasion??? Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. Bullshit. Timberlake is an asshole, has always been an asshole, and speaking of, I hope his asshole gets stretched a bit in jail. |
|
|
Tattoo'd and Voted #1 in blind taste tests.
TX, USA
|
|
(_@___]]~~ It is better to smoke here, than here after. Grab a cigar.
http://www.marinebattleherk.com |
Originally Posted By dog_dad: Didn't even know an excise tax existed on ammo for civilians! View Quote only for the last 100+ years. Attached File https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IF12173.pdf |
|
|
Originally Posted By Millennial: Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Millennial: Excise Taxes on constitutionally protected firearms and ammunition are bullshit. AFA I'm concerned, he was doing the Lord's work redistributing the king's ammo. The constitution gives congress that bullshit power: https://constitution.congress.gov/browse/essay/artI-S8-C1-1-3/ALDE_00013389/ Article I, Section 8, Clause 1: The Congress shall have Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for the common Defence and general Welfare of the United States; but all Duties, Imposts and Excises shall be uniform throughout the United States; . . . Article I, Section 8, Clause 1 of the Constitution authorizes Congress to lay and collect duties, imposts, or excise taxes—collectively referred to as indirect taxes—and requires that they be uniform throughout the United States.1 The Supreme Court has held that an indirect tax satisfies the Uniformity Clause only when the tax ‘operates with the same force and effect in every place where the subject of it is found.2 In general, an indirect tax does not violate the Uniformity Clause where the subject of the indirect tax is described in non-geographical terms.3 If Congress uses geographical terms to describe the subject of the indirect tax, then the Supreme Court will examine the classification closely to see if there is actual geographic discrimination.4 more at the link A basic idea of the constitution is that, unless explicitly stated, no part of the constitution supersedes other parts of the constitution. |
|
|
Originally Posted By dskeet: Considering his history of trying to do price fixing with other forum vendors. He certainly was just padding his profits while charging his customers the most he could get them to pay. This dude is a piece of shit. View Quote I am glad some of us have been around long enough to remember him and his antics. All those of you defending him like the idea of him screwing Uncle Sam out of taxes but I guarantee he was screwing his customers at the same time. He conspired with other vendors to fix pricing on hard to get items so that the members of ARFCOM (his primary customer base at the time) got screwed with higher prices. The only reason he got found out was one of the other vendors he was bullying complained about it and he was exposed and then booted from ARFCOM. |
|
|
Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: I am glad some of us have been around long enough to remember him and his antics. All those of you defending him like the idea of him screwing Uncle Sam out of taxes but I guarantee he was screwing his customers at the same time. He conspired with other vendors to fix pricing on hard to get items so that the members of ARFCOM (his primary customer base at the time) got screwed with higher prices. The only reason he got found out was one of the other vendors he was bullying complained about it and he was exposed and then booted from ARFCOM. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: Originally Posted By dskeet: Considering his history of trying to do price fixing with other forum vendors. He certainly was just padding his profits while charging his customers the most he could get them to pay. This dude is a piece of shit. I am glad some of us have been around long enough to remember him and his antics. All those of you defending him like the idea of him screwing Uncle Sam out of taxes but I guarantee he was screwing his customers at the same time. He conspired with other vendors to fix pricing on hard to get items so that the members of ARFCOM (his primary customer base at the time) got screwed with higher prices. The only reason he got found out was one of the other vendors he was bullying complained about it and he was exposed and then booted from ARFCOM. Was there more to what he did than expecting all other vendors to stick to MAP? I get we all are supposed to hate MAP, but it is legal and is not considered price fixing. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Kihn: Its utter contempt for his customers. You became aware of it when you spoke with him on the phone. Like a televangelist. Without the charisma. And much more crude. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Kihn: Originally Posted By Steviesegal: I bought something from him once, an SB tatical brace it never came in a box. It was a brace just wrapped in bubble wrap. He actually goes by William Timberlake on facebook hes in the groups there selling, every time I see him post I laugh. Its utter contempt for his customers. You became aware of it when you spoke with him on the phone. Like a televangelist. Without the charisma. And much more crude. That's all I got. I think I still occasionally get an email from the business all these years later. |
|
“Liberalism, the noble annihilator, has hollowed out every institution, every binding force, every social failsafe and backstop, and its agents feign surprise when the liberating infanticide it promotes is taken to its next logical step.”
|
Originally Posted By Aimless: https://www.wjer.com/news/gun-shop-owner-sentenced-for-ammo-resale-scheme/ Timberlake, of G and R Tactical, and a police officer accomplice ordered ammunition through the police dept to get a reduced rate. Timberlake somehow paid for it. Timberlake made the mistake of picking up the ammo and the ammo distributor smelled a rat, probably because some small PD made a huge order for ammo and the ammo was picked up by some random non policeman. Both Timberlake and the officer were charged with felonies and plead to misdemeanors. Oops the cop plead to a felony Timberlake was sentenced to 90 days in jail and 90 days house arrest. I'm surprised he got jail time. The police supply company said they were out about $18k on the police discount price v if they sold the ammo at full price but they didn't ask for restitution. edit unrelated but the Timberlakes sold their interest in the m4carbine website. View Quote Fuck that guy |
|
Life member of CRPA. FPC contributor.
|
Life member of CRPA. FPC contributor.
|
Life member of CRPA. FPC contributor.
|
Originally Posted By spmx7777: Was there more to what he did than expecting all other vendors to stick to MAP? I get we all are supposed to hate MAP, but it is legal and is not considered price fixing. View Quote This is at least 10 years ago maybe more. If was way before MAP even became a common thing. In any case he was trying to get all the dealers to agree to sell at MSRP or above so it would not have mattered. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Aimless: Timberlake was sentenced to 90 days in jail and 90 days house arrest. I'm surprised he got jail time. The police supply company said they were out about $18k on the police discount price v if they sold the ammo at full price but they didn't ask for restitution. View Quote Lucky guy, I'd rather spend 90 days in jail for a misdemeanor than pay the $100K + in legal fees and increased insurance premiums from to my bullshit lawsuit. |
|
I'm no good at telling people what they want to hear when I dont believe it myself :)
|
Criminals cut from the dame cloth .no matter what.
|
|
Live your life as you would wish to have lived, when you come to die. Confucius
When words lose their meaning, a people can move neither hand nor foot. Confucius |
Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: I am glad some of us have been around long enough to remember him and his antics. All those of you defending him like the idea of him screwing Uncle Sam out of taxes but I guarantee he was screwing his customers at the same time. He conspired with other vendors to fix pricing on hard to get items so that the members of ARFCOM (his primary customer base at the time) got screwed with higher prices. The only reason he got found out was one of the other vendors he was bullying complained about it and he was exposed and then booted from ARFCOM. View Quote I found out as this was ongoing. Right after I ordered something from him. OTS, people would ask about a certain firearm item and he always chimed in that he had it in stock and posted a link to his website. Scammy fuck. |
|
peach fuzz
|
Originally Posted By Jack_Of_Some_Trades: only for the last 100+ years. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/8695/Screenshot_2024-04-16_104058_png-3189565.JPG https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IF12173.pdf View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Jack_Of_Some_Trades: Originally Posted By dog_dad: Didn't even know an excise tax existed on ammo for civilians! only for the last 100+ years. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/8695/Screenshot_2024-04-16_104058_png-3189565.JPG https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IF12173.pdf |
|
“Liberalism, the noble annihilator, has hollowed out every institution, every binding force, every social failsafe and backstop, and its agents feign surprise when the liberating infanticide it promotes is taken to its next logical step.”
|
Extorris, because he's a heartless cunt. The purity of his apathy is laboratory grade, and I sleep well knowing that he's out there somewhere,
not giving a shit about anyone or anything. |
Originally Posted By ZitiForBreakfast: If a legal defense fund gets set up for the guy who pushes his shit in, I would probably donate. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By ZitiForBreakfast: Originally Posted By Pair_of_ACES: Bullshit. Timberlake is an asshole, has always been an asshole, and speaking of, I hope his asshole gets stretched a bit in jail. If a legal defense fund gets set up for the guy who pushes his shit in, I would probably donate. Highly doubtful anything like that is going to happen. He'll do a few months then get released on probation and have to do community service. Especially if it's some small town jail. |
|
Fuck Cancer. Love you Pop.
|
Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: I am glad some of us have been around long enough to remember him and his antics. All those of you defending him like the idea of him screwing Uncle Sam out of taxes but I guarantee he was screwing his customers at the same time. He conspired with other vendors to fix pricing on hard to get items so that the members of ARFCOM (his primary customer base at the time) got screwed with higher prices. The only reason he got found out was one of the other vendors he was bullying complained about it and he was exposed and then booted from ARFCOM. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: Originally Posted By dskeet: Considering his history of trying to do price fixing with other forum vendors. He certainly was just padding his profits while charging his customers the most he could get them to pay. This dude is a piece of shit. I am glad some of us have been around long enough to remember him and his antics. All those of you defending him like the idea of him screwing Uncle Sam out of taxes but I guarantee he was screwing his customers at the same time. He conspired with other vendors to fix pricing on hard to get items so that the members of ARFCOM (his primary customer base at the time) got screwed with higher prices. The only reason he got found out was one of the other vendors he was bullying complained about it and he was exposed and then booted from ARFCOM. I remember that. The only time I tried to order anything from him, he advertised on the EE, and when I called to order, Roxanne told me that he didn't sell them because he didn't like the brand. I don't even remember wtf it was that I was trying to order, but I do remember that it gave me the impression that the guy's a fucking turd. |
|
|
Let's get after it.
For the glory of the empire, so say we all. |
Roxanne is an amazing lady, I truly feel sorry for her.
|
|
A socialist may indeed be academically superior.
And yet, they are most certainly emotionally retarded. Public education is the opiate of the masses. |
IIRC he was a pompous ass when he was on this site
|
|
|
Bought my 1301 from them years ago. Gen 2 $999
Other than that I know nothing about the company. I wish I could buy discount ammo |
|
|
Well, I guess big boy rules weren't enough.
|
|
In memory of my son Sean James, born 6/25/97. Died 9/16/13.
We will be reunited in heaven. |
|
|
In memory of my son Sean James, born 6/25/97. Died 9/16/13.
We will be reunited in heaven. |
|
So G&R Tactical is now OK to talk (post) about.
|
|
If the truth makes you uncomfortable, don't blame the truth. Blame the lie that made you comfortable. -James Ng Uni
|
Originally Posted By SteelonSteel: I thought the price difference was chiefly the Pittman Robertson tax. Government doesn’t pay it so they get an adjusted price plus what ever they get as a special deal. I don’t know at what point the tax is laid on the product or if the distributer has to fill out forms for tax credit. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By SteelonSteel: Originally Posted By Aimless: https://www.wjer.com/news/gun-shop-owner-sentenced-for-ammo-resale-scheme/ Timberlake, of G and R Tactical, and a police officer accomplice ordered ammunition through the police dept to get a reduced rate. Timberlake somehow paid for it. Timberlake made the mistake of picking up the ammo and the ammo distributor smelled a rat, probably because some small PD made a huge order for ammo and the ammo was picked up by some random non policeman. Both Timberlake and the officer were charged with felonies and plead to misdemeanors. Oops the cop plead to a felony Timberlake was sentenced to 90 days in jail and 90 days house arrest. I'm surprised he got jail time. The police supply company said they were out about $18k on the police discount price v if they sold the ammo at full price but they didn't ask for restitution. edit unrelated but the Timberlakes sold their interest in the m4carbine website. I thought the price difference was chiefly the Pittman Robertson tax. Government doesn’t pay it so they get an adjusted price plus what ever they get as a special deal. I don’t know at what point the tax is laid on the product or if the distributer has to fill out forms for tax credit. Well I am guessing that might be where they came up with an actual crime out of this- false filling out of the FET form (federal excise tax/Pittman Robertson 11% tax). As otherwise getting a discount improperly might be more of a civil matter for the gun shop, and a disciplinary matter for the LEO. Basically, LE pricing is more constant than retail- if there is a run on ammo, and prices spike, the LE price is often locked in at the bid rate given for the year. And part of those bids sometimes is allowing other agencies to order on the same pricing. We basically had the state bid price, and any agency could order at that price, or try to negotiate their own, but getting a better rate than the state bid was unlikely. Now when times were tough, you might get cheaper ammo, but it might take 6-12 months to get. On the other hand, bid price could also be quite a bit above the price you might get with any type of sale pricing, even realizing that you were paying the 11% FET. I bought Speer Gold Dot .223 for SWAT issue from PSA on a p-card at retail (sale) pricing, because it was a lot cheaper than bid pricing, and because the ammo would arrive in less than a week. Did the same with various practice ammo types during ammo gluts as well. Hell I know of bid pricing where individual LEO’s were allowed to order smaller amounts (like a case or 2) at agency pricing with the full knowledge of the vendor, though I assume they had to pay FET. (Was gonna say I never had that option, but now that I think of it- I may have bought some 12 gauge cheap way back in the day for myself that exact way when I was picking up an agency order.) |
|
a loaded gun won’t set you free, so they say…
|
Originally Posted By Bama-Shooter: The cop price is without the .gov taxes. The ammo supplier didn't lose a penny. View Quote They may have actually made more of a profit . Govt bid pricing is quite often well above what a decent sale price is. Have seen it often- why are we paying $300/k for X, when it is $280 retail- which includes the tax? Etc.. It is all about availability and constant pricing. A smart agency can order it cheap when ammo is scarce and they are using locked in pricing, and can also order it from retail vendors cheap when prices drop. |
|
a loaded gun won’t set you free, so they say…
|
Originally Posted By spmx7777: Looks like no one bothered reading or understanding the article link. Grant was convicted of a state telecom fraud 1st degree misdemeanor. The fraud was representing the ammo was for PD sales not retail sales. I asked if the feds could still go after him for not paying the 11% federal excise tax. I think it’s possible. View Quote Seeing that further down the thread, but nobody has explained what the hell that actually means… Did he lie over the telephone? Lie to a telecom company? Lie about exemption to the FET tax, over the telephone? Kind of vague so far! |
|
a loaded gun won’t set you free, so they say…
|
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood from His workmanship, so that men are without excuse.
|
Originally Posted By SemperGumbi: Neither the PD or Grant would have been paying state sales tax. The PD does not because they are a government entity and Grant would not because he is buying it for resale and would charge sales tax when he sells it. What he would avoid paying is the 11% excise tax that is added to the cost of ammo for sale to civilians. When a PD buys ammo for duty use they do not pay that. My guess is that is what he was avoiding. What is so hard to understand about misrepresentation for the purposes of tax evasion??? View Quote From Grants perspective ammo was in short supply...he found a way to get some to provide for his customers he choose poorly. |
|
For since the creation of the world God’s invisible qualities, His eternal power and divine nature, have been clearly seen, being understood from His workmanship, so that men are without excuse.
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.