User Panel
Posted: 3/8/2024 8:25:45 PM EDT
I might be buying an old 12x36 lathe very cheap. I would like to power its 3 phase 3 hp motor with a VFD. 220 single phase to 220 3 phase.
On a lathe, should I oversize the VFD or buy one rated for 3hp? |
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
Oversize by 2, is the rule of thumb.
|
|
|
If its rated for a single phase input and comes from a reputable company I wouldn't oversize.
|
|
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
I have three machines on VFDs. Never used a phase converter. My 2X rule of thumb statement comes from other machinist’s. Suit yourself. A 6HP or even 10HP VFD is cheap as chips.
Originally Posted By batmanacw: We are not talking phase converter. I'm looking at a vfd. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By batmanacw: Originally Posted By d4xycrq: Oversize by 2, is the rule of thumb. We are not talking phase converter. I'm looking at a vfd. |
|
|
Originally Posted By d4xycrq: I have three machines on VFDs. Never used a phase converter. My 2X rule of thumb statement comes from other machinist’s. Suit yourself. A 6HP or even 10HP VFD is cheap as chips. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By d4xycrq: I have three machines on VFDs. Never used a phase converter. My 2X rule of thumb statement comes from other machinist’s. Suit yourself. A 6HP or even 10HP VFD is cheap as chips. Originally Posted By batmanacw: Originally Posted By d4xycrq: Oversize by 2, is the rule of thumb. We are not talking phase converter. I'm looking at a vfd. My research is pointing to using a 3hp rated vfd is fine if it is designed to run off single phase or 3 phase. If you run a 3 phase to 3 phase vfd off single phase you need to oversize it by double. I'm deciding if I want to oversize to a 4hp or 5hp rated vfd for extra safety margin. The difference in price does matter right now as I wasn't planning on a project right now. |
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
I'm running VFDs on two mills. I oversized one by 2 and matched the other one. I like the performance of the oversized one better. It can change directions much faster.
|
|
Vidi Vici Veni
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
No, I can ramp up and down faster on the oversized one.
|
|
Vidi Vici Veni
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
I think I'm going with a 5hp rated vfd just for a bit of safety margin. It will not draw more than 16-18 peak amps so I'm running 12-2 for the supply on a 20 amp breaker.
|
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
Just found this on vfd dot org.
Variable frequency drives also optimize motor starting characteristics. Variable frequency drives bring motors up to full speed quickly and by drawing only 100% to 150% of full load amps (FLAs). This ability to start at normal FLA is very important if the power supply cannot withstand the normally six times FLA across-the-line starting draw, or even the 350% FLA soft-start device current. Variable frequency drives do this by managing the magnetic flux of an induction motor. Magnetic flux is directly proportional to the voltage and inversely proportional to the frequency. By keeping the flux constant, the inrush current does not exceed the FLA rating of the motor, and full torque is maintained. This is a significant improvement on a soft-start, which has significant voltage drop problems and cannot start under full load. |
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
Originally Posted By batmanacw: Just found this on vfd dot org. Variable frequency drives also optimize motor starting characteristics. Variable frequency drives bring motors up to full speed quickly and by drawing only 100% to 150% of full load amps (FLAs). This ability to start at normal FLA is very important if the power supply cannot withstand the normally six times FLA across-the-line starting draw, or even the 350% FLA soft-start device current. Variable frequency drives do this by managing the magnetic flux of an induction motor. Magnetic flux is directly proportional to the voltage and inversely proportional to the frequency. By keeping the flux constant, the inrush current does not exceed the FLA rating of the motor, and full torque is maintained. This is a significant improvement on a soft-start, which has significant voltage drop problems and cannot start under full load. View Quote That brings up a good point. Is your new lathe powered by an induction motor? |
|
A firearm is like a parachute, if you need one but don't have one, you'll probably never need one again. IG @jimstagramguns
|
Where the sheepdog is banned the wolves feast.
|
A firearm is like a parachute, if you need one but don't have one, you'll probably never need one again. IG @jimstagramguns
|
I asked the electricians at work this very question. He told me that a VFD should be close in size but never under. VFDs can be oversized but it can cause problems of you aren't careful. It depends on how you set them up and the features you use.
If you ran a 5 hp VFD on a 3hp motor, you still set the the same nameplate current on the smaller motor. So the VFD will still do its job and protect the motor from over current. The probelm is you can set a higher current, and if you fuse for the VFD size you do not have adequate circuit protection for the wiring in the smaller motor. I set this guy up on my South Bend. Brand new old stock on ebay for $50 VFDs are dirt cheap these days. Attached File Attached File |
|
How do you do?
|
Originally Posted By batmanacw: I might be buying an old 12x36 lathe very cheap. I would like to power its 3 phase 3 hp motor with a VFD. 220 single phase to 220 3 phase. On a lathe, should I oversize the VFD or buy one rated for 3hp? View Quote Given that most VFDs will tolerate a short overcurrent situation, I would (and have) go size for size at this HP rating. I don't think the additional current from the 5hp will provide any gain for the added cost. If you need to up-size down the line then select a unit to fit that combo. If it's a clutch lathe, that's great, use the clutch to ease into things. If it's clutchless, like an SB, then set your spindle ramp to keep startup current moderate. I don't use the VFDs for decel on any of my manual machines, so I can't speak to tuning that. I also don't vary the Freq, set it at 60hz and let it roll. Yes, it will allow you to get a perfect SFM but in reality that's moot at this level of work. Most machines were designed with speed selections to cover the bases of their capacities from 60hz. |
|
Originally Posted By JLPettimoreIII:
bruh. 87% of Gee Dee couldn't get laid in a Thai brothel with a black AMEX and a kilo of the finest blow on the planet. |
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.