User Panel
LMT MLC - MSRP $2,499, street price unknown
https://lmtdefense.com/firearms/mlc -Enhanced Handguard +1 -Enhanced Muzzle device 0 -Enhanced barrel +1 -Enhanced Gas System 0 -Enhanced BCG 0 -Enhanced Bolt 0 -Enhanced BCG Coating 0 -Enhanced trigger 0 -Enhanced Buffer / buffer spring 0 -Self lubricating / anti corrosion coatings 0 -Ambi Bolt Catch +1 -Ambi Bolt release +1 -Ambi safety +1 -45-degree safety selector 0 -Ambi charging handle +1 -Coating / Finish on weapon 0 -Additional novel features +2 (Monolithic Upper, Quick Change Barrel) Score= +8 enhancement points Daniel Defense DDM4V7 -$1346 / UPC 815604018487 https://danieldefense.com/firearms/gas-system/mid-length/daniel-defense-m4-carbine-v7tm.html -Enhanced Handguard +1 -Enhanced Muzzle device 0 -Enhanced barrel +1 -Enhanced Gas System 0 -Enhanced BCG 0 -Enhanced Bolt 0 -Enhanced BCG Coating 0 -Enhanced trigger 0 -Enhanced Buffer / buffer spring 0 -Self lubricating / anti corrosion coatings 0 -Ambi Bolt Catch 0 -Ambi Bolt release 0 -Ambi safety +1 -45-degree safety selector 0 -Ambi charging handle 0 -Coating / Finish on weapon 0 -Additional novel features +1 (6.2lbs - light for a 16" midlength) Score = +4 enhancement points Robar Polymar-15SC - $1895 https://robarguns.com/polymar-15/ -Enhanced Handguard +1 -Enhanced Muzzle device +1 -Enhanced barrel +1 -Enhanced Gas System 0 -Enhanced BCG 0 -Enhanced Bolt 0 -Enhanced BCG Coating +1 -Enhanced trigger +1 -Enhanced Buffer / buffer spring 0 -Self lubricating / anti corrosion coatings +1 -Ambi Bolt Catch 0 -Ambi Bolt release 0 -Ambi safety 0 -45-degree safety selector 0 -Ambi charging handle 0 -Coating / Finish on weapon +1 -Additional novel features +2 (5.5lbs, Sub MOA guarantee) Score = +9 enhancement points |
|
Quoted:
Now just run the point system with other Top Tier AR's, and you have a pretty easy grading rubric. View Quote Your grading system is as failed as common core math. And you’re trying to throw plastic rifles into the “hi-end” mix?.......ROFL |
|
It's like asking would you rather have a car built by a master mechanic who has been building top quality cars for 30+ Years (who also studied under another master mechanic) or would you rather have one built by someone fresh out of technical school? They have the same features so they're going to be equal right? I think not. That system has some merit, but nowhere near what I think he believes.
|
|
|
Quoted:
You seem awful defensive there bub. What about my post touched you in the wrong way exactly? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes |
|
Quoted:
LMT MLC - MSRP $2,499, street price unknown https://lmtdefense.com/firearms/mlc -Enhanced Handguard +1 -Enhanced Muzzle device 0 -Enhanced barrel +1 -Enhanced Gas System 0 -Enhanced BCG 0 -Enhanced Bolt 0 -Enhanced BCG Coating 0 -Enhanced trigger 0 -Enhanced Buffer / buffer spring 0 -Self lubricating / anti corrosion coatings 0 -Ambi Bolt Catch +1 -Ambi Bolt release +1 -Ambi safety +1 -45-degree safety selector 0 -Ambi charging handle +1 -Coating / Finish on weapon 0 -Additional novel features +2 (Monolithic Upper, Quick Change Barrel) Score= +8 enhancement points Daniel Defense DDM4V7 -$1346 / UPC 815604018487 https://danieldefense.com/firearms/gas-system/mid-length/daniel-defense-m4-carbine-v7tm.html -Enhanced Handguard +1 -Enhanced Muzzle device 0 -Enhanced barrel +1 -Enhanced Gas System 0 -Enhanced BCG 0 -Enhanced Bolt 0 -Enhanced BCG Coating 0 -Enhanced trigger 0 -Enhanced Buffer / buffer spring 0 -Self lubricating / anti corrosion coatings 0 -Ambi Bolt Catch 0 -Ambi Bolt release 0 -Ambi safety +1 -45-degree safety selector 0 -Ambi charging handle 0 -Coating / Finish on weapon 0 -Additional novel features +1 (6.2lbs - light for a 16" midlength) Score = +4 enhancement points Robar Polymar-15SC - $1895 https://robarguns.com/polymar-15/ -Enhanced Handguard +1 -Enhanced Muzzle device +1 -Enhanced barrel +1 -Enhanced Gas System 0 -Enhanced BCG 0 -Enhanced Bolt 0 -Enhanced BCG Coating +1 -Enhanced trigger +1 -Enhanced Buffer / buffer spring 0 -Self lubricating / anti corrosion coatings +1 -Ambi Bolt Catch 0 -Ambi Bolt release 0 -Ambi safety 0 -45-degree safety selector 0 -Ambi charging handle 0 -Coating / Finish on weapon +1 -Additional novel features +2 (5.5lbs, Sub MOA guarantee) Score = +9 enhancement points View Quote |
|
|
Quoted:
Huh? Do you mean gas block? I can understand not wanting an exposed gas tube but not really seeing a problem with an exposed gas block. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes |
|
Quoted: The same BS hogwash could be used to compare a Kia to a Mercedes. Features and shiny shit has little to so with reliability and quality. Your grading system is as failed as common core math. View Quote The correct analogy would be a "would you rather have a Corvette made by Audi, BMW, Mercedes, or Porshe..." "Reliability and quality" are not quantifiable metrics. And it's not 2005, where even premium manufacturers were still figuring out how to make a reliable carbine. All of the manufacturers in the high end (KAC, LMT, LWRC, DD, Larue, Noveske, etc) make "reliable, quality" AR's. What meaningfully separates them is the features the manufacturers have added to take them to "the next level." What makes a KAC SR15 the state of the art is not "reliability and quality." It's the Intermediate Gas System, E3 Bolt, and Ambi Lower. If you have a better grading rubric please feel free the share. |
|
|
Quoted: The difference being, these are all the same car. And none of them are made by the original manufacturer of the car (ArmaLite/Colt) View Quote |
|
Sorry man.....you're wrong. CMT ambi lowers have ambi mag release and bolt catch. Throw on a BAD ambi safety, and you're FULL ambi. And billet to boot.....For cheaper than the LWRC. Again, all you're gaining is mall ninja spiral fluting on the LWRC. You get a more accurate rifle with a better trigger with the Larue UU and a CMT ambi lower.
Proof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsRafRNPCjo Quoted:
You aren't getting a full ambi design with the CMT and instead merely getting an ambi release. The LWRC lower is a far better purchase than the CMT. Responses in red. View Quote |
|
It'd be nice if that spiral fluted barrel actually shot groups like the Larue does.
As far as an ambi catch.....I don't care. Maybe some people do. The ambi parts that are needed while actually running the gun are there (mag release and bolt release). Quoted: The CMT Ambi Lower actually just has the Ambi Release, it does not have the Ambi Catch (which is pretty handy for locking the bolt back to show/clear a malfunction.) The catch is actually the most valuable part of the Ambi lower, at least for a right handed shooter. https://www.cmttac.com/image/cache/data/AMBI%20LWR%20ONLY%20RS-800x800.jpg No one is hating on the Larue UU, but that's not really a "factory rifle" - its a bunch of very nice components in a box that need to be assembled, and then another lower receiver from a different manufacturer must be purchased. As for the "mall ninja spiral fluting," that shaves 20% of the barrel weight down, allowing the LWRC to have a HBAR barrel that weighs as much as a midweight. The Larue Stealth 16" barrel weighs 37oz/2.31lbs, which is pretty heavy. Some gay ass mall ninja shit spiraling could cut that weight to 29.6oz - saving 0.46lbs of weight. That's the weight of an Aimpoint Pro - in useless barrel weight. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
Sorry man.....you're wrong. CMT ambi lowers have ambi mag release and bolt catch. Throw on a BAD ambi safety, and you're FULL ambi. And billet to boot.....For cheaper than the LWRC. Again, all you're gaining is mall ninja spiral fluting on the LWRC. You get a more accurate rifle with a better trigger with the Larue UU and a CMT ambi lower. Proof: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GsRafRNPCjo View Quote And the ambi catch is extremely useful in a class environment and when working with any malfunction drills, as locking the bolt back without changing your grip to work the magazine/bolt/inspect is viable. Sorry that your love for your setup leads you to make compromising decisions but the LWRC/LMT spec ambi lowers are superior to the CMT |
|
You're right. Ambi bolt release and mag release only on the CMT. Not an ambi bolt catch. Again, everything needed to run the rifle is ambi. If you really need an ambi catch.....well.....I'm going to stop there.
Still.....whooptido. I don't personally care about an ambi catch. I wouldn't hinge a rifle purchase on that feature whatsoever. You get a better barrel and trigger with the Larue for cheaper. The only way I think the LWRC is better for someone is if they can't assemble an AR properly. Quoted: Your video proves you to be wrong, it's as I said an ambi release. And the ambi catch is extremely useful in a class environment and when working with any malfunction drills, as locking the bolt back without changing your grip to work the magazine/bolt/inspect is viable. Sorry that your love for your setup leads you to make compromising decisions but the LWRC/LMT spec ambi lowers are superior to the CMT View Quote |
|
Quoted:
You're right. Ambi bolt release and mag release only on the CMT. Not an ambi bolt catch. Again, everything needed to run the rifle is ambi. If you really need an ambi catch.....well.....I'm going to stop there. Still.....whooptido. I don't personally care about an ambi catch. I wouldn't hinge a rifle purchase on that feature whatsoever. You get a better barrel and trigger with the Larue for cheaper. The only way I think the LWRC is better for someone is if they can't assemble an AR properly. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
You're right. Ambi bolt release and mag release only on the CMT. Not an ambi bolt catch. Again, everything needed to run the rifle is ambi. If you really need an ambi catch.....well.....I'm going to stop there. Still.....whooptido. I don't personally care about an ambi catch. I wouldn't hinge a rifle purchase on that feature whatsoever. You get a better barrel and trigger with the Larue for cheaper. The only way I think the LWRC is better for someone is if they can't assemble an AR properly. Quoted: Your video proves you to be wrong, it's as I said an ambi release. And the ambi catch is extremely useful in a class environment and when working with any malfunction drills, as locking the bolt back without changing your grip to work the magazine/bolt/inspect is viable. Sorry that your love for your setup leads you to make compromising decisions but the LWRC/LMT spec ambi lowers are superior to the CMT Also careful on your responses man, they appear to be very GD quality and not suited for a technical discussion, at least in regards to your last statement. Let's keep this constructive and not GD level of posts. |
|
Yeah I agree, let’s keep this thread realistic and constructive. Good debate so far
Look, I’m a huge Larue fanboy and use their products wherever I can. Along with Geissele. When I did my 16” RECCE inspired build last year it was a no brainer to go with the Stealth barrel. It’s very accurate and runs fine suppressed. For ultimate precision, I’m all in with Larue. But as stated, I’m looking for a new designated HD rifle. I took a couple carbine courses recently and it was eye opening. I am a believer in ambi bolt catches now. But forget a BAD lever, I’ve tried one and under stress it just confuses me. Ive seen great things in Larue rifles but there have been a few things lately that at least have me considering other options. One is the fitment with lowers. Look at the pics of the UU kit with even Larue lowers. Not the best. Is it 99% cosmetic, probably so. But what does that do to your confidence at that point. There is also the fact that most Stealth barrels are a little over gassed. I only run 5.56 ammo. Either XM193, TAP 62, or MK262 77 gr. So I don’t really see the need for a larger gas port. Larue Stealth is still more of a precision rifle than a 0-200 yard Carbine IMO. It’s whats in their DNA...precision. I don’t see how anyone could have something negative to say about the LWRC other than the trigger. Again, I just wish it came with a 14.5” barrel. If I went Larue UU kit, I do have a Joe Bobs billet lower that I could try first. It’s a very nice piece, just not ambi. |
|
This whole thread is dildos
Top Tier=Price. Got it I had an LWRC that was horrifically inaccurate, even had them replace my barrel. I have a KAC right now that is a picky eater. You have a lot to learn. |
|
Quoted:
It'd be nice if that spiral fluted barrel actually shot groups like the Larue does. As far as an ambi catch.....I don't care. Maybe some people do. The ambi parts that are needed while actually running the gun are there (mag release and bolt release). View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
It'd be nice if that spiral fluted barrel actually shot groups like the Larue does. As far as an ambi catch.....I don't care. Maybe some people do. The ambi parts that are needed while actually running the gun are there (mag release and bolt release). Quoted: The CMT Ambi Lower actually just has the Ambi Release, it does not have the Ambi Catch (which is pretty handy for locking the bolt back to show/clear a malfunction.) The catch is actually the most valuable part of the Ambi lower, at least for a right handed shooter. https://www.cmttac.com/image/cache/data/AMBI%20LWR%20ONLY%20RS-800x800.jpg No one is hating on the Larue UU, but that's not really a "factory rifle" - its a bunch of very nice components in a box that need to be assembled, and then another lower receiver from a different manufacturer must be purchased. As for the "mall ninja spiral fluting," that shaves 20% of the barrel weight down, allowing the LWRC to have a HBAR barrel that weighs as much as a midweight. The Larue Stealth 16" barrel weighs 37oz/2.31lbs, which is pretty heavy. Some gay ass mall ninja shit spiraling could cut that weight to 29.6oz - saving 0.46lbs of weight. That's the weight of an Aimpoint Pro - in useless barrel weight. I think they put out a few stellar barrels and a few average. No different than other barrel makers at the same price point. And don't quote the moa challenge as gospel. The top three larue claims were made by liars. One of those tards claimed sub half moa with ADI 69gr. He got called on his bullshit and promptly disappeared. The number 1 claim is made by a business owner with questionable integrity and a known bullshitter. That list went from being an awesome idea, to shot full of bullshit from internet commandos. |
|
|
|
Quoted:
What is your definition of "Top Tier"? Highest level of expense? If you want to spend money just get a LaRue, KAC, or even better build a V7 yourself with all their highest price parts. View Quote |
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted: At what point has ANYONE said price alone defines top tier? Go shit in someone’s else’s thread. The KAC/LMT rifles actually push the platform though, not just doing the same thing over and over. The E3 bolt + carrier modifications from KAC and the LMT Enhanced BCG are two of the most thought out upgrades to come to the platform. Yes, they are expensive but R&D comes at a cost. And no offense but you commenting on KAC issues doesn't hold much water when countless members here have had no issues in competitions and classes. |
|
Quoted: No one has said Colt isn't a good rifle, on the contrary many have stated it's the standard milspec rifle. The KAC/LMT rifles actually push the platform though, not just doing the same thing over and over. The E3 bolt + carrier modifications from KAC and the LMT Enhanced BCG are two of the most thought out upgrades to come to the platform. Yes, they are expensive but R&D comes at a cost. And no offense but you commenting on KAC issues doesn't hold much water when countless members here have had no issues in competitions and classes. View Quote |
|
Quoted:
There are 2 in this thread alone. It just seems like the way OP is talking like he/she/shman/it is discrediting all the "lower tier" guns. When in reality, OP should just ask what cost the most because OP wants to spend a lot of money but make sure OP buys a something OP gets approval from the hive first. View Quote Zerlak don’t waste your time. A quick look at his other posts and you’ll quickly pickup on his M.O. |
|
Quoted: You are a clown man, lol. Zerlak don’t waste your time. A quick look at his other posts and you’ll quickly pickup on his M.O. View Quote What makes the Colt not top tier? The price? |
|
Quoted:
*Mods please lock* Got what we needed from this thread. View Quote I want to know what makes Colt, DD, BCM less tier. Why don't you say it? |
|
Of all the top shelp top tier AR-15 companies listed, which of these offers light weight carbine size firearms? I must admit my old Bushmaster modular optic carbine is heavy - 10 pounds with out a 30 round Magpul magazine. Then when I weighed my Armalite AR-180 it weighed only 7.5 pounds without a magazine. I would love something that had a free float barrel and full length hand guard. At least 16 inch barrel. Seems like the piston AR-15 carbines would be the route. Please chime in and give me some idea on what I should be looking for. BTW, I want to buy right off the rack without needing to piece something together. Thanks.
|
|
Quoted:
Of all the top shelp top tier AR-15 companies listed, which of these offers light weight carbine size firearms? I must admit my old Bushmaster modular optic carbine is heavy - 10 pounds with out a 30 round Magpul magazine. Then when I weighed my Armalite AR-180 it weighed only 7.5 pounds without a magazine. I would love something that had a free float barrel and full length hand guard. At least 16 inch barrel. Seems like the piston AR-15 carbines would be the route. Please chime in and give me some idea on what I should be looking for. BTW, I want to buy right off the rack without needing to piece something together. Thanks. View Quote If you want something a bit more on the wild side, the Kaiser X7 Monarch is 4.5lbs. |
|
Quoted:
Of all the top shelp top tier AR-15 companies listed, which of these offers light weight carbine size firearms? I must admit my old Bushmaster modular optic carbine is heavy - 10 pounds with out a 30 round Magpul magazine. Then when I weighed my Armalite AR-180 it weighed only 7.5 pounds without a magazine. I would love something that had a free float barrel and full length hand guard. At least 16 inch barrel. Seems like the piston AR-15 carbines would be the route. Please chime in and give me some idea on what I should be looking for. BTW, I want to buy right off the rack without needing to piece something together. Thanks. View Quote |
|
Looks like I have a new Larue 6.5 Grendel on the way with matching lower, Looking for a long range steel plunker
|
|
Quoted:
Why can't you answer any of my questions? Instead you call me a 16'er on a slow ass edit then you call me a clown. What makes the Colt not top tier? The price? View Quote I like Colt, I think it's a dependable rifle and I'll start my son out on one if I have one, but it's not a tier which isn't a knock against it. Top tier shouldn't leave you wanting, nor should I have to buy parts to get it the way most modern rifles are sold. Colts don't come with light ff rails, , low profile gas blocks, solid triggers, better hardware, or any new innovation that actually advances the platform and isn't just for looks. You can argue none of that is needed, but top tier is more than just the basics. Even the military adds most of these things to the basic Colt setup. I don't see them changing the kac rifles at all. |
|
Quoted:
I don’t know who said what but anyone that thinks Larue is a boutique AR obviously is not in the know or hasn’t handled one. Seriously can’t think of a no frills AR more than Larue. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted: LaRue a boutique AR? Keep dreaming. You've owned a shot one a lot, right? Thank you, Colt. |
|
JP Enterprises
Centurion I love LMT, but unless you are talking MWS, I wouldn't put them in the same league as the others. |
|
Id like one of them Geissele rifles, but you have to win those.
|
|
Quoted: I don't mind answering that question. I like Colt, I think it's a dependable rifle and I'll start my son out on one if I have one, but it's not a tier which isn't a knock against it. Top tier shouldn't leave you wanting, nor should I have to buy parts to get it the way most modern rifles are sold. Colts don't come with light ff rails, , low profile gas blocks, solid triggers, better hardware, or any new innovation that actually advances the platform and isn't just for looks. You can argue none of that is needed, but top tier is more than just the basics. Even the military adds most of these things to the basic Colt setup. I don't see them changing the kac rifles at all. View Quote |
|
High-end is a pretty useless term. High end of what? It can be interpreted to mean price, innovation, quality, durability, features or accuracy.
|
|
Quoted:
Why can't you answer any of my questions? Instead you call me a 16'er on a slow ass edit then you call me a clown. What makes the Colt not top tier? The price? View Quote |
|
Quoted: Thirty years from now my Colt LE6920 with the LEO Only Rollmark will be worth more than any of these so called "Top Tier" AR brands. I doubt most of these brands will even be in business. A decade ago I remember when Noveske was the pinnacle of manufacturers here on arfcom. View Quote |
|
Quoted: Thirty years from now my Colt LE6920 with the LEO Only Rollmark will be worth more than any of these so called "Top Tier" AR brands. I doubt most of these brands will even be in business. A decade ago I remember when Noveske was the pinnacle of manufacturers here on arfcom. View Quote Lewis Machine and Tool has been around since 1980. They aren't going anywhere. Knight's Armament Company has been around since 1982. They aren't going anywhere. Hell, Stoner himself worked for them. LWRC has been around since the late 1990s. I doubt they are going anywhere either. JP Enterprises has been around since the mid 1990s. I doubt they are going anywhere either. How many times has Colt gone bankrupt and only saved because of the tit from Uncle Sam? |
|
What are your $.02 regarding the following rifles please:
https://lmtdefense.com/firearms/spm16 https://pof-usa.com/firearms/the-constable/ https://www.spikestactical.com/collections/complete-rifles/products/complete-rifle-midlength-le-16?variant=34463261644 I am in the market for my first AR15. I am looking to put $1,500 for the rifle alone at most. Thanks! |
|
Quoted: I own a Colt 6920. I'm probably going to sell it eventually as I don't care for it all that much. The quality and fit and finish are poor. To get it up to spec, I would have to throw more money into it with an upgraded trigger, stock, free float rail...etc. Lewis Machine and Tool has been around since 1980. They aren't going anywhere. Knight's Armament Company has been around since 1982. They aren't going anywhere. Hell, Stoner himself worked for them. LWRC has been around since the late 1990s. I doubt they are going anywhere either. JP Enterprises has been around since the mid 1990s. I doubt they are going anywhere either. How many times has Colt gone bankrupt and only saved because of the tit from Uncle Sam? View Quote But what it comes down to is yes Colt is too big for its britches sometimes. I would prefer to deal with smaller or call it “Boutique” if you want companies. QC is a going to be an issue at times with a company of its size. If I bought another Colt I would have to upgrade....barrel, gas block, gas tube, rail, trigger, and stock |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.