The only negative I see with this is the insufficient illumination. I don't do sporting competition so this matters little to me since dim illumination is what I want for low light shooting.
Maybe not my favorite reticle but useful. Good compact size/weight. Very good glass, decent eye box. I haven't even mounted it let alone shot with it so I can't make a final judgement. Upon initial inspection, this isn't my favorite but is the best quality/$ I've ever gotten on an lpvo and I've gotten in on some pretty good deals ($600 Bushnell 1-6.5 pro, used $350 viper pst2, $400 1-5 weaver tac, $500 swfa 1-6HD).
I would have gotten 2 but I really didn't even need this which is why it's still not mounted to anything. I thought about replacing my first lpvo, the original Burris xtr14, on my stg58 but I don't find that lacking on that gun. I'll probably just put it in a qd to use as daytime for my thermal AR.