User Panel
It sounds like the average shooter would be better served having you drop it in and make a basic adjustment as opposed to screwing around with settings they were not familiar with.
|
|
I'll have to check with Mr. Geissele, but I think the trigger comes well tuned out of the bag. Just drop it in and go. If you want to start adjusting, do so after you read the directions and have determined "what" part of the trigger you want to adjust. |
|
|
wow...us poor dumb gunfighters can't adjust match triggers! That's why they go tits up in classes!
I never knew! |
|
What does this trigger cost?
Great informative posts on triggers...thanks!! |
|
I notice you posted this HERE, rather than 10-8. |
||
|
I have never heard of a KAC needing to be stoned or filed. What all does this trigger offer that KAC does not? I noticed its ad said it sets the trigger 1/8" further forward to reduce cramping of the trigger finger. That seems nice but I cannot imagine a trigger that is more crisp than my KAC. The KAC costs more, so this may be a future consideration for me but I would like to see the overtrvel adjustment and hear your long term test. Do you have a KAC to comapre it to over this long term test?
|
|
I know those guys..they always placed last in department quals....but knew more than I would ever know about guns and shooting... I've been shooting for 25 years and I'm still learning.. |
||||
|
And knowing is half the battle! |
|
|
Well, you got the second part of that right, anyway. Have fun. Out.... |
|||||
|
I'm sorry..do you know me...nope..go back to 10-8 and hang out with them...I'm sure they will kiss your ass.. Sorry bigbore that your post got sidetracked.... |
||||||
|
Me either, but it is written in the instructions.
Availability, customer service, Over travel adjustment, a much faster lock time.
The overtravel screw is nothing more than a screw through the front of the trigger which protrudes out to contact the receiver, eliminating over travel. I just replaced the KAC in my AR-10. And from a "precision rifle" standpoint, the difference is night and day. I also have a KAC in my carbine which has several thousand rounds through it - including a 3 day Pat Rogers class, with not a single issue or malfunction, i.e. going tits up. |
|||
|
What a coincidence. I was going to ask you your opinion about these. How do they compare to the McCormick units?
|
|
June 1995
I have never played with a McCormick, but a friend in Southern OH, has one with several thousand rounds through without any complaints. Thie trigger is more for the do it all carbine. If you have a Match Grade barrel and a $2K ShortDot, that 8lb. stock trigger is going to be a crutch. |
||
|
Interesting How a topic about $300 triggers had to include a slam on the 10-8 Forums because the majority of posters with real world experience and years of Mil and LEO experience who see literally Hundreds and hundreds of guns that get run hard continually offer the advice based on what they see that on the average After market triggers no matter how good, have a tendency to be unreliable in situations where your life or the life's of other's is at stake. Yea, I always take advice from the professionals who conduct themselves so well here.... |
|
|
Whoa.......thanx bigbore for your efforts and the 2-stage trigger.
for $279.00 I can almost have another upper if not another 511 Eotech, great work though. Just out of my price range, I will love my mil-spec single stage trigger a little longer. |
|
This seems to be the prevalent theme when it comes to aftermarket triggers, but I've never heard any specific details, only generalities. Tell me, from your experience and from what you've gleaned from the professionals, what happens to aftermarket triggers that makes them go down during classes: Do parts break? Do adjustment screws back out rendering them inoperable? Or at that point do they just become high priced single stage triggers? Does something happen whereby the start doubling and are no longer safe? Are these flaws limted to just certain makes or do all aftermarket triggers share these tendencies? |
||
|
Or 1000rds of practice ammo. |
|
|
Steve,
Bill did indeed design a fine trigger. At the AMU we found the second stage weight had to be adjusted every 1,500 rounds or so, so he changed the way the adjustment screws lock (with the nylon inserts), so that's fixed as well. For those who like the KAC it's a good, combat-proven trigger (we use them in our M16A4 Designated Marksman Rifle). At the AMU we also give them a detailed check at 3,500 rounds (on combat weapons, combat meaning real war and not competition) when we replace the barrels on Mark 11s/SR25s and SPRs because we often have to junk them and replace the whole trigger. Fairly expensive proposition, but it's your tax dollars when we're talking about guns going into the two-way shooting gallery. The KAC also has a slow lock time compared to a Milazzo and the Geissele. The Geissele has a faster lock time than the Milazzo. Bill has a trigger tester that has cycled the trigger several hundred thousand times. We've found that the longer you shoot them the more polished they become (very little detectable wear due to the alloy and heat-treatment). AMU Geissele applications have been the AR-10T XM110 Semi-Automatic Sniper Rifle System prototype and M4A1 Designated Marksman Carbines (mid-lengths with 16 and 18-inch barrels). They may replace the Milazzos as we wear them out if we can't get repair parts. |
|
It is unwise to use an AR... the bolt has many more parts than an AK. The extractor can become jammed etc. The failure rate of AR ejectors is far higher than AK ejectors. For this reason I reccomend you stay away from the AR.
Can you see how silly the arguement is? If you maintain an AR bolt it will be fine. If you maintain a quality AR trigger it will be fine. The problem is knuckleheads who dont know what they are doing misadjusting it or not locktiting them. You can group yourself with the lowest intellectual denominator if you want, but I will use what is reliable and of higher quality. I can use some critical thinking and brain cells to keep my trigger running more reliably and with better pull than the factory unit. |
|
How have you earned their trust? You know who Harv is referring to, and you know his qualifications. Is he now in the category of e-commando? |
||
|
Quote from Bigbore
Oh, my bad, I guess I missed the "professionalism" in this statement When you have not one but literally all the top Instructors in their field, guys whos experience totals well over 100 years of combined experience, guys who have seen thousands of weapons and millions of rds and who have kept running logs of failures of aftermarket triggers. triggers that due to thier complex makeup and small set screws that even in spite of lock tite will and can work free from excessive heat and vibration in a field environment causing the weapon to stop fuctioning, after all that I should heed the advice of a self proclaimed "Hobby shooter" A guy who's not afraid to Hurt some Fragile Ego's.......... You may want to do a Ego check on yourself.... I believe your comment about the caliber of Posters and their experience on another forum speaks volumes of your Intergrity in order to sell a product that has a limited number of units in the field which renders it's statistically unreliable just by that fact alone. And if anyone thinks a $300 trigger is going to make then a better "Gunfighter" .... well... good luck with that.. hope it works for you I'm done with this thread |
|
|
You know who I am and what I'm about. I think maybe if you were to listen a little better to what the people over at 10-8 say you can see their logic. I have had a STOCK trigger go tit's up several times, once at school (with Pat, no less). So until you can: 1) Tell me why I need set screws. 2) Tell me what makes you more qualified than the 200 years of experience that called you out at 10-8 you needn't worry about advising Harv, modog and I. I have no doubt that this trigger could tick along fine. Or it could break. What I'd like to see is an EDM'd stock trigger group with engagement surfaces polished before hardening. I like the lighter hammer too. But I DO NOT WANT set screws because EVERYTHING BREAKS. Stock triggers break, bolts break, even barrels occasionally blow out at the seams. Why on earth would I want to add more complexity to the system because a guy that other guys trusted said it was OK? This is kind of like how Noveske barrel aren't worth the money and KFH's are actually suppressors. Having seen both in action, and having met a lot of guys who liked them, I believe them, and yet I am supposed to trust your word because a lot of guys hvae learned to trust you? I'm sorry to shit on this trigger, because it is a new and promising unit for some applications. But it needs a more credible cheerleader. |
||
|
I love it how people readily admit they cant think for themselves as if its something to be proud of...
|
|
Some of you folks with fragile egos need to make a reality check.
Soldiers screwing with gadgets have given us heavy barrels, vertical fore grips, free-float rail systems, flashlights on long and handguns, and optics. 15 to 20 years ago some of the same guys cheerleading custom barrels, rails, and gas systems were poo-pooing gadgets on weapons. Some folks should take what information is given (from ANY forum) with a grain of salt, then come back to us when you've worn out 2 or 3 standard-issue rifle or carbine barrels in CQC sustainment instead of just regurgitating electrons you've read or eavesdropped on. |
|
...
Sometimes it sure looks like the shooting community is it's own worst enemy. |
|
sadly, +1 |
|
|
I have some black stuff coming out of my KAC trigger screws. Certainly appears to be melted nylon. Is it? Is this why KAC failures due to moving screws are rare? Does the nylon on the GA trigger screws make the locktite work less effetively in any way? Can you tell the difference in length of pull with the trigger installed? What real world benefits does a faster lock time provide? How much faster is the lock time than the KAC in thousandths of a second or whatever figure you would use to measure it? Will GA offer a full auto version?
Combat Jack, How many match triggers and what types have you run? What were the failures you experienced in those trigger related to? |
|
I'm not sure, I've never had any trouble with my KAC, or noticed any black stuff?
Time will tell, and right now the ony triggers getting extended use are with Sinisters crew. If stuff starts falling apart, I'm sure he'll let us know.
Yes, I can.
Less time to screw up a shot between when you pull the trigger and when the hammer strikes the firing pin. What's your real world? Mine is poking holes in paper at long distances, in as tight a group as I can get.
Taken from a post by Bill Geissele >>>>>>>>>>>> My trigger’s lock time has been decreased with a lightened hammer that has a unique “IBeam” profile that decreases hammer mass while retaining strength. A standard hammer has a lock time of about15ms. In comparison, lock time with my trigger has been calculated at 8ms. >>>>>>>>>>>>>> I do not know in comparison to the KAC, or how this is calculated.
taken from another post by Bill - We are not licensed (yet) to do any select fire design or manufacture. When the request comes in from Uncle Sam we will approach this. |
||||||
|
Sir: Are the Geissele triggers being used at all in combat weapons to your knowledge -- or are they only for the competition firearms? Thank you. |
|
|
We've deployed only one with a Special Forces Group to Afghanistan in an AR-10T. They liked it. We haven't put them in any other combat guns yet (we want to try and break a few first -- we've fired them a BUNCH, so we're waiting like the Maytag repairman).
On our combat (people-killing) guns we use loctite to make sure those screws don't go anywhere. And we DO do some hand-tuning on KACs. We asked Bill for a version that would support select-fire, but with the KAC version already available (and Bill doesn't have an NFA manufacturing license) we did not pursue it further. I would imagine it would be a fairly simple proposition of adding an automatic fire disconnect tail to the hammer, but will add some additional weight to the hammer mass. |
|
I posted similar questions the page back. I would love to know what these failures are and whether or not they're limited to a specific model mfg's trigger or if they occur across the board. I've seen tons of threads of "My (fill in the blank) broke on my AR...." Often these threads are accompanied by pics and a decent writeup of what actually happened. But all I ever hear about triggers is that they "went down" -- no details, no pics, not even a clear explanatiuon if the triger became inoperative vs it just lost a stage. I'm really curious how much of the "only use stock triggers" mantra is based on sound judgment and/or first hand experience vs how much of of it is conventional wisdom repeated over and over that hasn't been challenged and revalidated. |
|
|
If, or when, you all decide to field them in greater numbers to the "people-killing" weapons, could you give us an update?? Thanks a ton in advance. |
|
|
Between my brother and I, we've had two RRA triggers turn into long, creepy single stages and a few failures to fire, and several stock triggers fire on the reset. In fact, about 50% of the triggers I have run have had problems. Colts have always run fine. Sinister, I understand that DMR type weapons REQUIRE a precision trigger unit. And I think this trigger looks pretty cool. And I have read that you like what you see, after using these trigges extensively. I don't feel that it is necessary for a regular carbine. The increase in accuracy is not worth the increase in chance of failure. Like I said, everything breaks. We can only minimize the time between failures. In a DMR, the mission requires accepting a higher risk of failure. You won't see me running a nice trigger in a CQB specific AR- although manufacturers like RRA are including them on such weapons. |
|
|
I wasn't being sarcastic. I liked your reply. It was better than anything else on the first page. |
|
|
To clarify, my experience with RRA's is that they lose a stage and get mushy (and I've seen them run WAY too light, for some reason), while stock triggers give it up by firing on the reset. |
||
|
It's not a fragile ego. I've been shooting these things for 5 years, and have had an admitedly small amount of experience. Harv, modog and I have met a few of the same people, in the real world, and done some high round count training. My last training package involved 24 shooters firing about 1800 rounds in 5 days, followed by a 5 day class in which 9 shooters each fired about 1300 rounds. Most failures were off brand parts. There was at least 1 poorly staked carrier key, a couple of brand new "match quality" AR's from high cost manufacturers but surprising few problems with the M16A2's, A4's and M4's, which all ran like clocks.
I may not have worn that many barrels out (I tend to trade rifles every couple thousand rounds), but I have used a lot of what is on the market. I jumped into RRA triggers, SIR's, M900's, TAO1NSN's, Knight's 300M BUIS and other things when they were cool and found myself trading them in later. I don't like to jump into things. So I ask people who run a lot of rounds downrange. Then I get something and run some rounds through it. If I get a Geissle trigger, it will be because of your words, Sinister, because I know who you are, and what you do. I also know who most of the other posters are in this thread, and where they are coming from. So I try to take all of this into account before making a purchase. As for my own history, I make no secret of the fact that I am a young civilian with no combat experience. If you want to know anything about me, where I've been, what I've done, etc., drop me an IM, and I will tell you. |
||
|
Bigbore, thanks for posting this, I'm sure this is a well designed trigger, but I have a few comments/questions. Please dont take this as an attack on the product or yourslef, it is NOT!!
1. What type of shooter are you trying to market this for? 2. Why such a high price? $279, JP triggers are half this and Chip Mccormicks are about $180. 3. Dirt pounders cant tell that your pic is just oily and poor light, looks to the amateur eye as rusty 4. What makes this better than the KAC(which sounds like cock in british), CMmCormick, JP, Rock river? 5. Availability? this is killing the Mccormick trigger more than anything. 6. and for whoever wants to know why this was posted here rather than 10-8, well 500 people are there, patting each other on the back because they have a badge, versus 7000+ people here online right now!!! simple math. I'd like to see the trigger first hand before I'd drop $279. |
|
I'm not sure what the basis of this argument is? Use what works for you and your operating parameters.
Information exchange is a two way street. "Gun Fighters" can learn from competition shooters, and competition shooters can learn from "gun fighters." Every class I attend I learn something, and I'm sure students more on the "gun fighter" side of things learn a thing or two from me. Likewise when my LE or Military friends attend matches I am sure they learn something, and if people pay attention something can be learned from them as well. This exchange of information can make us all better shooters regardless of how we employ or equipment or skills. It can also lead to enhancements of equipment over time, which as Sinister said is not hard to track at all over the past 15-20 years. |
|
1. What type of shooter are you trying to market this for? Anyone who wants another trigger option. There is a trnd right now for "do it all" carbines. If you're going to run match ammo, match barrel, and maxnified optics, another option in the triger dept is a good thing. This trigger was chosen by the USAMU for proof of concept on the XM110 Semi-Auto Sniper System. 2. Why such a high price? $279, JP triggers are half this and Chip Mccormicks are about $180. Why is a Rolex more than a Timex? All other triggers to my knowledge have milled sears which require stoning. These sears are cut with a wire EDM then hardened. The EDM produces a perfect finish....not too smooth so that the trigger is 'gummy' and rough enough so that lubricant is trapped in the little microscopic valleys of the sear surface. RRA: Decent, but not adjustable and there are quality issues. Can be made to perform with fitting. This triger has individual adjustments for each trigger parameter. If you want more 2nd stage...put it in.....the sear does not change. More overtravel....just turn the screw...the weight will not change. 3. Dirt pounders cant tell that your pic is just oily and poor light, looks to the amateur eye as rusty my bad 4. What makes this better than the KAC(which sounds like cock in british), CMmCormick, JP, Rock river? KAC - the adjustments do more that one thing at a time i.e: one screw adjusts the overtravel and at the same time trigger weight. The other screwadjusts sear engagement and weight. With a system like this you will always have to make a compromise. The hammer is heavy with weight concentrated near the end....slower locktime. 5. Availability? this is killing the Mccormick trigger more than anything. Now, with real customer service. |
|
The GA seems to be a product improved Milazzo. Fortunately I have 4 of the Milazzo's and have never ever had an issue with them. I have over the years used - some only VERY briefly the CLE, Jewell, Armalite (Gen I, II & III) None have come close to supplanting the Milazzo's. All of mine have gone through multiple bbls and upper rebuilds - the only maintenance I have ever done and it is more PMCS than anything and that is to replace the hammer spring and the trigger spring every other year. Combined these 4 triggers have seen in excess 80,000 rds. I have NEVER had to mess with a set screw - yes they are loctited - no worries there.
I am curious of a few things: - What is the the lock time difference between a GA & a Milazzo? - What the hell is up with Milazzo? - Is Charlie out of the business? I think that some of the debate from other posters needs to be measured when comparing low end triggers like the Bushy CLE clones, the CLE as well and some others. The failure to specifically note that the playing field is exceedingly sloped gives false witness that we are comparing filet mignon to MRE's. The design differences, manufacturing processes and function are worlds apart in some of these triggers. For example - having been in the big sand box for almost 15 months - I would never ever take a CLE, Bushy or a Jewell. NO WAY NO HOW. I would have zero pause taking a Milazzo and based on conversations with Sinister a KAC as well. Well informed insiders have said the GA is better than the Milazzo - that is a strong statement. One of these was Sinister and he knows as does the shop crew. $279 - pricey yeah, but you get what you pay for. my .02 1SGA |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.