User Panel
Posted: 2/23/2024 9:48:42 PM EDT
I commute 100 miles a day (mainly highway) and the Subaru is getting long in the tooth. I’ve never owned a “luxury” car, our Tahoe is the closest I’ve come. At my age I’m getting the hankering for a nicer vehicle and have narrowed it down to liking the looks of the Audi Q8. Mercedes, BMW, Volvo don’t have much I like (or can afford). The Prestige model Q8 a year or 2 old is in my price range.
Thoughts of you guys who have owned or currently have Audi’s? Might go drive one tomorrow as I’ve never even sat in one. I’m not a snob but just wanting to see what they offer for comfort and performance. Thanks |
|
Lexus 450 hybrid.
We own 3. 225k is our highest mileage car. Hassle free C/S, 100% reliable, comfortable ride, 28-34 MPG, very high safety factor. 18Z50. |
|
The Q8 is based on the same platform as the VW Touareg (Which is also shared with the Bentley Bentayga and Lamborghini Urus). Very robust.
If you have a decent extended warranty, Audi is great up to about 100,000 miles. Then things get really, really pricy. Try and avoid the air suspension option if possible. I have a soft spot for Audi interiors. |
|
I've had a couple (old S4, 2016 SQ5, now a 2024 S3)
Great interior, decent handling, very good tech. Probably not the most reliable thing on the planet. Some horror stories of the older Audis requiring an engine-out service to replace turbos. Dealers are very proud of their shop rates and parts. CPO would be the way to go, IMO. I was pretty impressed by a loaner Q7 I had (my 3 week old S3 was in the shop for a parking sensor failure and bluetooth module failure....). The Q7 handled VERY good for a heavy SUV, yet soaked up the RR track crossings, and potholes way better than I expected. Seats were firm, but very comfortable. Extremely quiet inside, too. Q8 really looks cool, too. |
|
They share many, many parts with VW. I had a VW CC and I loved it. When I got rid of it with 144K miles, it still ran, shifted and road nearly as nicely as when I bought it with 6K miles. But, EVERYTHING was expensive to fix. window switches, headlights, etc... and everything used weird tools or tool sizes to remove, so doing it yourself was kind of annoying. But, there were plenty of videos. Oil changes were expensive, and premium fuel is annoying to buy.
At any rate, I had a great experience, and I loved my CC and would have bought another one if it was 10% larger. I suspect Audi's would be even better to ride, and more expensive to maintain. If I were going to buy one, I would go onto cars.com and put in Audi and look within 100 miles and look at vehicles under 15K and less than 2 years old. That's probably the only way to get a "reasonable" price, but even now with used prices so high, it will still probably suck to pay. |
|
A higher end car is nice. I have a Mercedes but not sure I'd use it for a daily commuter. I'd probably go look at a nicely equipped Mazda at that point.
That said, a high end Euro car is about as good as it gets. Going from my AMG to my mom's 'all the options' Mazda makes me miss my AMG. It's worth looking at a nice Euro car. Shit, even my Lincoln was really nice. Don't discount the American cars (Lincoln and Cadillac). |
|
Do you change your own oil?
Because if you buy an Audi you won't for long. Plastic belly pans with fasteners every 6 inches, awkward filter positions, pain in the ass to wipe everything up after the change. If you're not a DIYer the above doesn't apply. Be selective where you get your service done and it will be a good car. A maintained Audi is nice-but so is a Cadillac(for the 6 weeks before the plastics go to shit). |
|
Quoted: Do you change your own oil? Because if you buy an Audi you won't for long. Plastic belly pans with fasteners every 6 inches, awkward filter positions, pain in the ass to wipe everything up after the change. View Quote The late model Q8 has a suction tube to suck the oil from the top with a fluid extractor from Amazon(Like most modern Audis), and the oil filter is also located under the air filter housing right on top of the engine. You don't even have to use a floor jack. |
|
Quoted: The Q8 has a suction tube to suck the oil from the top with a fluid extractor from Amazon(Like most modern Audis), and the oil filter is also located under the air filter housing right on top of the engine. You don't even have to use a floor jack. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Do you change your own oil? Because if you buy an Audi you won't for long. Plastic belly pans with fasteners every 6 inches, awkward filter positions, pain in the ass to wipe everything up after the change. The Q8 has a suction tube to suck the oil from the top with a fluid extractor from Amazon(Like most modern Audis), and the oil filter is also located under the air filter housing right on top of the engine. You don't even have to use a floor jack. Is that one of the no dipstick models? Maybe I'm too old but I just can't bring myself to trust a sensor to tell my oil level. |
|
Those things are meant to be leased new and dumped before they run out of warranty, imo.
|
|
|
Wife and I both drive new Q7s. They don’t have the same luxury feel as a Mercedes but we both love ours. The 3.0 engine is great and you can do a software only stage 1 tune that adds 70-80 HP to really wake them up. Unless these burn us in the next couple of years we’ll buy again.
If you DIY your own oil changes they are super easy, get an oil extractor from Amazon and you can change your oil in dress clothes, no mess no fuss. I do second what a couple others have said, I wouldn’t own one past year 4 or 5. |
|
Have owned two S3 sedans (2.0L turbo).
Can get 35-40mpg on highway, which is great for long commute. Fun car to drive. Zero issues. Dealerships will rape you on scheduled maintenance. Also owned an SQ5 suv (3.0L V6 turbo). Eats tires and brakes. Mileage not great. Feels noticeably larger/heaver on the road compared to the S3. |
|
Quoted: Is that one of the no dipstick models? Maybe I'm too old but I just can't bring myself to trust a sensor to tell my oil level. View Quote The sensors are VERY accurate. I've been wrenching on Euro for 20 years and I don't remember the last time I changed a faulty oil level sensor. Ever had a dip stick break off in the tube? I run into that a lot more than I run into faulty oil level sensors. With that said, I still prefer a dipstick. |
|
Quoted: The sensors are VERY accurate. I've been wrenching on Euro for 20 years and I don't remember the last time I changed a faulty oil level sensor. Ever had a dip stick break off in the tube? I run into that a lot more than I run into faulty oil level sensors. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Is that one of the no dipstick models? Maybe I'm too old but I just can't bring myself to trust a sensor to tell my oil level. The sensors are VERY accurate. I've been wrenching on Euro for 20 years and I don't remember the last time I changed a faulty oil level sensor. Ever had a dip stick break off in the tube? I run into that a lot more than I run into faulty oil level sensors. Only on Ford and Chrysler. I don't drive those either. Glad to hear the sensors are reliable. |
|
My dad had 2 A6's and a couple Q5's
2004 2.7T-sline 2012 3.0T Prestige(I think) 2015 Q5 2018 Q5 The only one he had trouble with was the 2004, but the others he got out of after a couple years. I really liked the 2012 A6, it was a really nice place to sit and drive. |
|
Quoted: When I bought mine even the salesman told me not to keep it long term. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Those things are meant to be leased new and dumped before they run out of warranty, imo. When I bought mine even the salesman told me not to keep it long term. They're just so crazy complicated, man. The packaging is horrendous. At best you have to loosen/move the core support to move the front bumper/radiator/etc. into "service mode" to get your hands in there to change a belt or a hose or something. At worst most major repairs require removing the engine. I think they're too complicated and labor intensive for the average owner to do his/her own work on beyond basic maintenance and services, and you generally need someone qualified who knows the cars and gives a shit to repair them correctly otherwise. Dudes that like don't exactly grow off trees, and they don't work for cheap. |
|
Even though they’re owned by Trader Joe’s they don’t have nearly the same quality or selection
|
|
I LOVE my Audi. I DD a 2003 A4 Avant with a 6MT and the 3.0AVK. It has 208k miles and has been exceptionally reliable. Nothing has prevented it from getting me where I want to go.
I have had PCV issues with it. Bad seals. I saw it as a honking and oil consumption. The dual lass flywheel started vibrating around 170k. Put a SMF in it. I think it's a TTV. It's from the UK. Had a CV boot barf. Had a fuel pump get weak around 170k. That was a quick fix. I've done brakes on it once. One clutch. Getting ready for a second timing belt. Basically do plugs, coils and oil and it goes. My folks have a 2010 A4 2.0T. ~270k miles. It got rings and pistons from auto around 100k due to oil consumption. It's been fine since. 1 brake job, original clutch. The interior is nowhere as nice as my 03. Doesn't handle as good as my 03 but my 03 is on sport suspension being it's basically an UltraSport. I'd happily buy another Audi if I could get an AWD Avant with a manual again. If you want to do your own work get the Ross Tech VCDS. Worth the $200 price tag in what it saves you taking it to a shop who will just use the same hardware. |
|
|
Quoted: Do you change your own oil? Because if you buy an Audi you won't for long. Plastic belly pans with fasteners every 6 inches, awkward filter positions, pain in the ass to wipe everything up after the change. If you're not a DIYer the above doesn't apply. Be selective where you get your service done and it will be a good car. A maintained Audi is nice-but so is a Cadillac(for the 6 weeks before the plastics go to shit). View Quote I drive a 2021 SQ5 and I don't have to use a jack to change the oil. Filter is on top, and a port to vacuum the oil out of the pan is on top. OP I've had 8 Audi's dating back to a 1999 2.8L 6 cylinder A4 with a 6 speed. 4 A4's, 3 S4's, and my current '21 SQ5. You'll really like them if you drive distances. I absolutely adore the air/sports suspension on my current SQ5. |
|
A friend was a line mechanic at an Audi dealer. Holy shit, the absurd and complex procedures for even the simplest repairs were completely horrifying. Ok, if money is no object for you in maintaining an Audi, they are really cool cars. But, for mere mortals... run Forest, run!
|
|
Quoted: They're amazing cars, especially the S-cars. Beautiful interiors, all wheel drive, tons of power, everything's all chicken and waffles on the first date. They're just so crazy complicated, man. The packaging is horrendous. At best you have to loosen/move the core support to move the front bumper/radiator/etc. into "service mode" to get your hands in there to change a belt or a hose or something. At worst most major repairs require removing the engine. I think they're too complicated and labor intensive for the average owner to do his/her own work on beyond basic maintenance and services, and you generally need someone qualified who knows the cars and gives a shit to repair them correctly otherwise. Dudes that like don't exactly grow off trees, and they don't work for cheap. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Those things are meant to be leased new and dumped before they run out of warranty, imo. When I bought mine even the salesman told me not to keep it long term. They're just so crazy complicated, man. The packaging is horrendous. At best you have to loosen/move the core support to move the front bumper/radiator/etc. into "service mode" to get your hands in there to change a belt or a hose or something. At worst most major repairs require removing the engine. I think they're too complicated and labor intensive for the average owner to do his/her own work on beyond basic maintenance and services, and you generally need someone qualified who knows the cars and gives a shit to repair them correctly otherwise. Dudes that like don't exactly grow off trees, and they don't work for cheap. Thats what I’ve heard. My plan would be to buy CPO and trade/dump when warranty is up. I do my own oil changes so good to know about the ease of those. Nearest dealer is about 80 miles away. |
|
We have two now and have been fine. My little 2015 A4 S-Line commuter has 115k on it and just regular maintenance. I do most of my own work so parts costs aren’t crazy, like timing chain set and wheel bearings type stuff.
My wife’s 2019 Q5 has been fine too. I think she’s on 60k miles or so and just maintenance so far. If you don’t wrench get rid of them at or before 100k miles though. I find them to be easy to work on and awesome drivers. |
|
Quoted: They share many, many parts with VW. I had a VW CC and I loved it. View Quote My mom's got the VW CC rline. 4cyl with the turbo. My room mate had a GLI, also a 4cyl with a turbo. From what I've seen from those, 130k miles is about the point when every piece on them breaks. My buddy always took his in and let the VW place fix it. For my moms, I'm the one fixing it. Every piece I replace, I am cussing at VW for the way they built the car. They are designed pretty retardedly. I would not buy a VW or audi and expect it to last much further than that 130k mile mark unless you plan on replacing half the car, 1 piece at a time. Whether that be you doing the work or you paying somebody else to do the work. |
|
Quoted: Define "long in the tooth". View Quote Hah I love Subarus, don’t get me wrong. It will go a long ways still but just kinda tired of the bumps and wind noise and tinny doors. It’s a great second car but looking for a bit more comfort and power on my commute while I dread going to work. |
|
I have an impeccably maintained 2013 Audi S5
No matter how much work you do, surprise…another leak. If you don’t mind that, excellent comfort and performance for not a lot of money. |
|
Quoted: When I bought mine even the salesman told me not to keep it long term. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Those things are meant to be leased new and dumped before they run out of warranty, imo. When I bought mine even the salesman told me not to keep it long term. Was that before or after you signed the paperwork? |
|
|
Your post mentions that you’re the kind of vehicle owner to put quite a few miles more than average on a vehicle per day and you prefer to keep your vehicle for long periods of time. Notice how everyone keeps saying things like “I own one and love it! But they turn into trash at 100k miles…”? That should lead you to the correct answer.
If you want an Audi-level luxury vehicle that will last forever and be bombproof reliable, your options are Lexus, Acura, and Infiniti, in that order |
|
We had a 2018 Q5 and still have the 2018 A5 sportback...excellent engineered driving machines...like them better than my BMW 335xi.....I will say the greatest disappointment is the resale value is complete shit...we paid 55K for the 2018 A5 S line premium plus sportback. Car has 45K miles in MINT condition and best we have been offered towards a trade in is 17K car is garaged with new brakes, tires, snow tires and rims, in MINT condition....we will never buy another one due to the horrific resale value....
|
|
When I’m done with my raptor I’m for sure getting a sq7 if they still make them.
|
|
Quoted: We had a 2018 Q5 and still have the 2018 A5 sportback...excellent engineered driving machines...like them better than my BMW 335xi.....I will say the greatest disappointment is the resale value is complete shit...we paid 55K for the 2018 A5 S line premium plus sportback. Car has 45K miles in MINT condition and best we have been offered towards a trade in is 17K car is garaged with new brakes, tires, snow tires and rims, in MINT condition....we will never buy another one due to the horrific resale value.... View Quote That’s because everyone knows at 45k miles it’s already on its last legs |
|
Quoted: I drive a 2021 SQ5 and I don't have to use a jack to change the oil. Filter is on top, and a port to vacuum the oil out of the pan is on top. OP I've had 8 Audi's dating back to a 1999 2.8L 6 cylinder A4 with a 6 speed. 4 A4's, 3 S4's, and my current '21 SQ5. You'll really like them if you drive distances. I absolutely adore the air/sports suspension on my current SQ5. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Do you change your own oil? Because if you buy an Audi you won't for long. Plastic belly pans with fasteners every 6 inches, awkward filter positions, pain in the ass to wipe everything up after the change. If you're not a DIYer the above doesn't apply. Be selective where you get your service done and it will be a good car. A maintained Audi is nice-but so is a Cadillac(for the 6 weeks before the plastics go to shit). I drive a 2021 SQ5 and I don't have to use a jack to change the oil. Filter is on top, and a port to vacuum the oil out of the pan is on top. OP I've had 8 Audi's dating back to a 1999 2.8L 6 cylinder A4 with a 6 speed. 4 A4's, 3 S4's, and my current '21 SQ5. You'll really like them if you drive distances. I absolutely adore the air/sports suspension on my current SQ5. Most Audis I have worked on have had a cartridge filter in a plastic cup, positioned in a way that it should be removed from below, but you can only get to it from above-so you get to reach down the side of a hot block and bend your arm where it doesn't have joints. |
|
Daily a ‘21 SQ8.
Great car so far, still in warranty though. |
|
|
|
175K my 2009 A4.
Been a great car but I do my own maintenance and change the oil every 5K. It’s not a Toyota but mine has done really well. |
|
Not my favorite, kind of a hybrid VW, with an even worse reliability reputation. They are nice cars, right up until they are not anymore.
|
|
Dude if you're going to be churning out the miles get a soul less aisain car. They have it down pat. Low maintenance and bomb proof reliability. And some of the Camary, and Accords in sport trim look pretty sharp.
|
|
2022 RS6 Avant is my daily. It's a POS and I'll never buy another Audi. At least it's fast.
|
|
Quoted: Most Audis I have worked on have had a cartridge filter in a plastic cup, positioned in a way that it should be removed from below, but you can only get to it from above-so you get to reach down the side of a hot block and bend your arm where it doesn't have joints. View Quote My A4 has a filter on the bottom. Gotta pull the skid plate. It's 3 bolts for my aluminum skid plate but the car is 4" off the dirt so it's something I lift the car for. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.