Quoted:
Which one would you choose and why? I know there's some debate about the german/interarms/S&W walthers but I'm only looking at a S&W version as that's what they have locally. The ppk has the bond cool factor, but besides that, is there much difference or reason to pick one over the other?
No experience with the PPK's, but I have had a P232 as a main carry gun for the last 10 years and like it quite a bit. Pocket pistol it is not, but it's small enough to have a "real gun" on a summer day IWB.
What I like about it: It is a simple "pull it out and pull the trigger" gun to operate under stress, takes down easily, it is light, has a great SA trigger and very good sights. There is something about Sig's trigger and sights that I have always shot well on other people's guns but the grips are freaking huge on the double stacks they make. The P232 is as accurate as any handgun I have, 100 yard shots 2 out of three times on a silhouette are no problem.
What I don't like:
Mags are expensive, and the plastic floorplates break when you drop the gun. They don't sell the backplates separately either.
It's only a .380.... I always thought it would be enough gun until I the one day I needed it, then it felt awfully small in my hands. Really gave me pause for thought after everything cooled down.
I wish the grip were a little thinner, but I have to admit it fills my hand well.
It's easy to lose the slide stop spring if you aren't careful when disassembling the gun if you bump the stop, it shoots off for parts unknown.
Overall the P232 is a fine choice for carry-I've never had a single problem with mine