Flying, in general, takes less reflex speed than driving. The sky is really big and it's not extremely to difficult to keep from hitting the ground unintentionally. Very little traffic or obstacles up there compared to racing or even normal commuting. Maybe test pilots, and the teaching emergency maneuvers (eg. full down autorotations) could qualify. It IS difficult to let students make mistakes whilst trying to survive the manoeuver...
My vote, no particular order;
High level auto/motorcycle racing.
Ball (puck?) sports where mechanical advantage is used to acceleration ball. (Racket sports, goal tending in hockey, lacrosse etc.)
Video gamers / Drone racers. (Drone racing is unique due to the fact that they have to react extremely fast to visual sense only and there is noticeable latency in the video feed (around 15 ms) . It's bad enough that pros don't use digital video, despite its far superior resolution, because it is 10ms or so slower than analog video. Latency exists in the RC link as well, but less so...