User Panel
Originally Posted By woozman:
wasn't there a guy in another thread who was telling everyone how silencers need to be expensive because there is so much overhead costs to producing one? View Quote Yup. Overhead (US standard of living) and greed are prob the biggest reasons they are as expensive as they are. You could prob spin the same thing out, on the same cnc machines, to the same tolerances, in china, for a 1/10th of the cost. The limited market and legal bs is the same in both cases so cancels out. It's not really a legitimate factor, just a worn out excuse for the markup. |
|
|
Originally Posted By Freudianslip:
A repair... A little ship of theseus here. View Quote Form 1 cans (by current ATF interpretation) must be sent to an SOT for repair that add/replace "suppressor parts." For example, if I have an endcap strike on my Form 1 can, that pulls the threads out of the tube, I can cut the tube a little shorter, rethread and reinstall the endcap myself. If I have a catastrophic failure that requires replacing a baffle, I'm supposed to send it to an SOT to do it. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
Instagram @fimbulvetrknifeworks, making knives and stuff Voting NRA members: Stephen Stamboulieh - Nolo Adam Kraut - Supermoose Sean Maloney - SeanOHNRA NO on bylaws |
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
Instagram @fimbulvetrknifeworks, making knives and stuff Voting NRA members: Stephen Stamboulieh - Nolo Adam Kraut - Supermoose Sean Maloney - SeanOHNRA NO on bylaws |
Originally Posted By woozman:
wasn't there a guy in another thread who was telling everyone how silencers need to be expensive because there is so much overhead costs to producing one? View Quote Probably, there's also guys in every silencer thread with moronic hyperbolic assertions that there's no reason they aren't given out free and made from smelted pop cans or other bullshit. A lot of industry expense is dedicated towards building a silencer that not only performs well, but lasts forever, figuratively speaking. Comparing the OP's ABS plastic .22 can to something with Inconel baffles meant to withstand repeated full auto fire from short barreled centerfire rifles over thousands of rounds is like comparing a soapbox race car to a Ford GT because "they both roll on wheels." It also ignores that the OP needed a 3d printer, a lathe, and 3d modeling software to produce it. Don't get me wrong. A lot of suppressor pricing is pure margin, they aren't that hard to make. I've made 3 that are essentially copies various expensive commercial cans, for material cost as little as 10% of what a commercial can costs. Even with the cool guy features like ratchet lock QD mounts. But I am a machinist and have the equipment to do it. Freeze plugs and Maglite tubes are still most peoples best option to F1 at home, and while they are effective, they are not going to have the longevity of something purpose designed and made. I'm in no way trying to disparage what the OP did here. It's fucking cool as hell. But how does the ABS react to heat? How does POI shift as that reaction occurs? What is the lifespan of the joint between the brass nut and plastic shell? What kind of baffle erosion? The answer to all of those is poor. The OP knows that. The people who take his example as proof everyone who bought a commercial can got scammed apparently don't. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
Instagram @fimbulvetrknifeworks, making knives and stuff Voting NRA members: Stephen Stamboulieh - Nolo Adam Kraut - Supermoose Sean Maloney - SeanOHNRA NO on bylaws |
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
Instagram @fimbulvetrknifeworks, making knives and stuff Voting NRA members: Stephen Stamboulieh - Nolo Adam Kraut - Supermoose Sean Maloney - SeanOHNRA NO on bylaws |
Originally Posted By Kuraki:
No. He's not kidding. It's why you won't see any of the solid models of my cans here or anywhere, anymore. View Quote I know he's not kidding. But it's also not an ITAR violation to share a drawing of a gun with an American citizen. Your post is pretty much exactly what I expected to happen when dept of State came out with that regulatory fiat about ITAR and the internet, too. Chilling of free speech like a motherfucker. |
|
Congratulations. Your post made so little sense I could simply delete most of it without losing the essence of it.
-Zhukov |
You may find me one day dead in a ditch somewhere. But by God, you\'ll find me in a pile of brass- Tpr. M. Padgett
|
Originally Posted By 1Andy2:
I know he's not kidding. But it's also not an ITAR violation to share a drawing of a gun with an American citizen. View Quote I understand, but once the drawing is outside of his control, how much responsibility does he have for that design then getting into someone elses hands? How much will it cost to prove that he complied with ITAR? If this administration changes the makeup of the Justice and State department, and puts some logic back into the enforcement of ITAR, I'll fill your inbox with every novel and reverse engineered solid model I've ever created. Not before that happens though. |
|
https://www.nraila.org/donate/
Instagram @fimbulvetrknifeworks, making knives and stuff Voting NRA members: Stephen Stamboulieh - Nolo Adam Kraut - Supermoose Sean Maloney - SeanOHNRA NO on bylaws |
Good job OP.
ABS has roughly a 1.05% shrink, so figure that into your design if it's needed. ABS might be too brittle to withstand much usage, especially in harsher temps. Be careful nothing snaps inside and obstructs your barrel..... Try it with Polycarbonate. I've got the material. Would it be legal for me to print the components for you and mail them as separate pieces? That way you could try PC if that junky makerbot doesn't print PC. |
|
John_Wayne777:
If this shit keeps up it might contain so many massive egos in one place that the sheer density of self importance might collapse in on itself and end all of humanity. |
Always blame autocorrect.
|
Always blame autocorrect.
|
Neat! Hopefully someday soon, anyone will be able to buy a plastic blister pack of 5 similar things off of a rack for $30 at any sporting goods store.
|
|
Originally Posted By triburst1:
I just assumed it was an FBI or ATF surveillance op. Now I'm worried that it might be site staff. |
America FUCK YEAH
|
Originally Posted By Kuraki:
I understand, but once the drawing is outside of his control, how much responsibility does he have for that design then getting into someone elses hands? How much will it cost to prove that he complied with ITAR? If this administration changes the makeup of the Justice and State department, and puts some logic back into the enforcement of ITAR, I'll fill your inbox with every novel and reverse engineered solid model I've ever created. Not before that happens though. View Quote Uh, probably about as much liability as all the people who actually sell real, physical ITAR-controlled items like night vision goggles and firearms. Which is to say, zero. My body, uh, inbox is ready. I mean, I could redo from scratch what he's done in my Rhinocad program going from those pictures he posted. But there's only so many hours in a day. |
|
Congratulations. Your post made so little sense I could simply delete most of it without losing the essence of it.
-Zhukov |
Nice work.
|
|
"They're telling us they'd rather die than come out and surrender....so.. They're gonna die..."
|
|
|
UNPOSSIBLE
I heard you needed a PhD in mechanical engineering and had to get a 25 year internship, then become a genius, and buy a $500,000 warhouse with $87,000,000 in equipment to be able to make ANYTHING firearm related! And oh, the overhead costs! They're so much guyz! Everyone needs an $87,000 salary even if the only thing they do is hold a dial gauge all day long and then wipe up some scrap metal with a broom! Its an extremely cognitively challenging career, only a fucking master entrepreneur could do this stuff. With luck. OP's post is photo shopped |
|
|
Originally Posted By Leisure_Shoot:
So, make a metal tube, with printed insert View Quote I guess you could and when and if the insert craps out then send it to an SOT that can print another insert. Wondering if such as insert could be viewed as a disposable part like a wipe and be replaced by he end user. Knowing the ATF the answer would be NO, but interesting times but just do not see the upside of the 3d if it has a metal tube. . |
|
|
|
Originally Posted By swede1986:
Couldn't he just destroy this one and then make a new one with the same serial number? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By swede1986:
Originally Posted By David0858:
And $200 and a long wait down the drain when it's disposed of. Couldn't he just destroy this one and then make a new one with the same serial number? Not legally. |
|
Veracity - The thing is, the press are like the Dodo bird. They've evolved with no natural predators.
Trump just walks up to them and clubs them to death. |
Originally Posted By Leisure_Shoot:
So, make a metal tube, with printed insert View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Leisure_Shoot:
Originally Posted By CTM1:
No longer allowed, the tube must be the serialized part. |
|
"Some of the greatest dads I've ever seen weren't so much perfect as they were willing to work hard to overcome their failings. Does that make sense?"
Yes. Yes it does. |
Originally Posted By mygreenkaw:
Where do we get these FREE 3D printers? View Quote In all fairness, you can get a newer version of the OP's printer for $650 on ebay. If the suppressor held up well, you pretty much pay for it with 2-3 cans. Heck, just print monocores for a plain tube, I wonder if it would be better or worse than a freeze plug f1? |
|
|
Originally Posted By CTM1:
I guess you could and when and if the insert craps out then send it to an SOT that can print another insert. Wondering if such as insert could be viewed as a disposable part like a wipe and be replaced by he end user. Knowing the ATF the answer would be NO, but interesting times but just do not see the upside of the 3d if it has a metal tube. . View Quote Metal tube is pretty much just a serial number holder. I doubt it's even legit to put the serial on a plastic part. Let's be realistic here. There will be no atf or sot involved when it wears out, and they don't even care. They are cool with that. But, at no fkn time are you to get on the fkn web machine and show off your new fkn parts. They still will not care that you made your own parts, but they will get shitty bent that you let others know that you did so without their blessing. Muh powerz!! |
|
|
Larue Tactical - Reading Armament
|
Originally Posted By Redarts:
In all fairness, you can get a newer version of the OP's printer for $650 on ebay. If the suppressor held up well, you pretty much pay for it with 2-3 cans. Heck, just print monocores for a plain tube, I wonder if it would be better or worse than a freeze plug f1? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Redarts:
Originally Posted By mygreenkaw:
Where do we get these FREE 3D printers? In all fairness, you can get a newer version of the OP's printer for $650 on ebay. If the suppressor held up well, you pretty much pay for it with 2-3 cans. Heck, just print monocores for a plain tube, I wonder if it would be better or worse than a freeze plug f1? You can get ones that would print this just fine for less than $200 nowadays. Even less if you want to build yourself, but I would not recommend this to somebody just getting into it. I bought mine on a whim because of a thread here, and wtf $250. Buddies kid uses the fancy expensive ones at school, but prefers to use mine because it prints better. It took a bit of work to get it that way, but you are waayy better off learning as you go and making things stronger as you notice weaknesses. You get something that is marketed as push button easy and you will never learn to spot problems, what may be the cause, or how to fix it. Anybody that buys one of these expecting it to be push button easy is in for a rude awakening. No such thing in this hobby. |
|
|
"He should have killed me. I would have killed me."
For God and Country: Geronimo! Geronimo! Geronimo! Michael Moore: Trump’s election is going to be the biggest Fuck You ever recorded in human history….And it will feel good. |
|
|
|
Originally Posted By oetkbyetdia:
You can get ones that would print this just fine for less than $200 nowadays. Even less if you want to build yourself, but I would not recommend this to somebody just getting into it. I bought mine on a whim because of a thread here, and wtf $250. Buddies kid uses the fancy expensive ones at school, but prefers to use mine because it prints better. It took a bit of work to get it that way, but you are waayy better off learning as you go and making things stronger as you notice weaknesses. You get something that is marketed as push button easy and you will never learn to spot problems, or what may be the cause. And anybody that bought one of these expecting it to be push button easy was in for a rude awakening. No such thing in this hobby. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By oetkbyetdia:
Originally Posted By Redarts:
Originally Posted By mygreenkaw:
Where do we get these FREE 3D printers? In all fairness, you can get a newer version of the OP's printer for $650 on ebay. If the suppressor held up well, you pretty much pay for it with 2-3 cans. Heck, just print monocores for a plain tube, I wonder if it would be better or worse than a freeze plug f1? You can get ones that would print this just fine for less than $200 nowadays. Even less if you want to build yourself, but I would not recommend this to somebody just getting into it. I bought mine on a whim because of a thread here, and wtf $250. Buddies kid uses the fancy expensive ones at school, but prefers to use mine because it prints better. It took a bit of work to get it that way, but you are waayy better off learning as you go and making things stronger as you notice weaknesses. You get something that is marketed as push button easy and you will never learn to spot problems, or what may be the cause. And anybody that bought one of these expecting it to be push button easy was in for a rude awakening. No such thing in this hobby. I use 3D printers professionally. While I agree it's not exactly a plug and play situation yet, it's getting there quickly. The Airwolf3D Axiom series is affordable and fairly automated. The difficulty is still in the design process. |
|
John_Wayne777:
If this shit keeps up it might contain so many massive egos in one place that the sheer density of self importance might collapse in on itself and end all of humanity. |
The ATF will when they come to stomp on the OPs dick after they find an old one in the trash
|
|
|
nice!
|
|
|
You may find me one day dead in a ditch somewhere. But by God, you\'ll find me in a pile of brass- Tpr. M. Padgett
|
|
|
|
Place in canvas bag.
Smash repeatedly with Mallet. Distribute into multiple Walmart bags. Place each Walmart bag in various gas station trash cans while fueling. Bonus points for emptying cig buts into said bag first at each fill up. |
|
"Some of the greatest dads I've ever seen weren't so much perfect as they were willing to work hard to overcome their failings. Does that make sense?"
Yes. Yes it does. |
Originally Posted By mp9fan:
I use 3D printers professionally. While I agree it's not exactly a plug and play situation yet, it's getting there quickly. The Airwolf3D Axiom series is affordable and fairly automated. The difficulty is still in the design process. View Quote $4k is pretty crazy when you could prob build that same thing easily for ~$500 if you started at the bottom and learned your way up. And that guy is going to be pulling his hair out and done (put a fork in it, done) when the offset for the autolevel changes. Autolevel is the devil as far as I am concerned. I see so many people buy that shit thinking its gonna be push button easy. It takes 30sec to level the bed and rarely needs to be done. Even quicker/less often and can do it by eye/feel after about 2 wks. The poor guy that bought the autolevel because it says "auto" has to 1st learn how to setup and use the autolevel. This is way, way, waayy more fkn difficult than just leveling the bed manually and getting to actually learn wtf is going on. I'd say the slicers would be the toughest part. So many knobs and switches in there to fk up |
|
|
Originally Posted By Kuraki:
Probably, there's also guys in every silencer thread with moronic hyperbolic assertions that there's no reason they aren't given out free and made from smelted pop cans or other bullshit. A lot of industry expense is dedicated towards building a silencer that not only performs well, but lasts forever, figuratively speaking. Comparing the OP's ABS plastic .22 can to something with Inconel baffles meant to withstand repeated full auto fire from short barreled centerfire rifles over thousands of rounds is like comparing a soapbox race car to a Ford GT because "they both roll on wheels." It also ignores that the OP needed a 3d printer, a lathe, and 3d modeling software to produce it. Don't get me wrong. A lot of suppressor pricing is pure margin, they aren't that hard to make. I've made 3 that are essentially copies various expensive commercial cans, for material cost as little as 10% of what a commercial can costs. Even with the cool guy features like ratchet lock QD mounts. But I am a machinist and have the equipment to do it. Freeze plugs and Maglite tubes are still most peoples best option to F1 at home, and while they are effective, they are not going to have the longevity of something purpose designed and made. I'm in no way trying to disparage what the OP did here. It's fucking cool as hell. But how does the ABS react to heat? How does POI shift as that reaction occurs? What is the lifespan of the joint between the brass nut and plastic shell? What kind of baffle erosion? The answer to all of those is poor. The OP knows that. The people who take his example as proof everyone who bought a commercial can got scammed apparently don't. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By Kuraki:
Originally Posted By woozman:
wasn't there a guy in another thread who was telling everyone how silencers need to be expensive because there is so much overhead costs to producing one? Probably, there's also guys in every silencer thread with moronic hyperbolic assertions that there's no reason they aren't given out free and made from smelted pop cans or other bullshit. A lot of industry expense is dedicated towards building a silencer that not only performs well, but lasts forever, figuratively speaking. Comparing the OP's ABS plastic .22 can to something with Inconel baffles meant to withstand repeated full auto fire from short barreled centerfire rifles over thousands of rounds is like comparing a soapbox race car to a Ford GT because "they both roll on wheels." It also ignores that the OP needed a 3d printer, a lathe, and 3d modeling software to produce it. Don't get me wrong. A lot of suppressor pricing is pure margin, they aren't that hard to make. I've made 3 that are essentially copies various expensive commercial cans, for material cost as little as 10% of what a commercial can costs. Even with the cool guy features like ratchet lock QD mounts. But I am a machinist and have the equipment to do it. Freeze plugs and Maglite tubes are still most peoples best option to F1 at home, and while they are effective, they are not going to have the longevity of something purpose designed and made. I'm in no way trying to disparage what the OP did here. It's fucking cool as hell. But how does the ABS react to heat? How does POI shift as that reaction occurs? What is the lifespan of the joint between the brass nut and plastic shell? What kind of baffle erosion? The answer to all of those is poor. The OP knows that. The people who take his example as proof everyone who bought a commercial can got scammed apparently don't. All valid points. But do I care about longevity when I can make another for a couple bucks? |
|
|
Originally Posted By Fidel_Cashflow:
My sentiments exactly. I have been kicking around the idea of purchasing a 3D printer for some time now. I have been collecting plans for various items of interest for some time as well. View Quote They are fkn awesome and a ton of fun, for the right person. For the wrong person, they can be your worst fkn nightmare Here is a quick test. You buy ar15 and it short strokes when you take it out. Do you fix the thing, or send it back? If you answered fix the thing, awesome and a ton of fun. If you answered send it back, your worst fkn nightmare. |
|
|
I see your 'mouse holes' are 180 degrees apart.
All the info I have read says they should be lined up for best performance. |
|
|
Support the Foundation to Cure LeadFoot-itis
AR, USA
|
|
We are fast approaching the stage of the ultimate inversion: the stage where the government is free to do anything it pleases, while the citizens may act only by permission...- Ayn Rand
|
There's a dick joke in there somewhere.
|
Originally Posted By oetkbyetdia:
$4k is pretty crazy when you could prob build that same thing easily for ~$500 if you started at the bottom and learned your way up. And that guy is going to be pulling his hair out and done (put a fork in it, done) when the offset for the autolevel changes. Autolevel is the devil as far as I am concerned. I see so many people buy that shit thinking its gonna be push button easy. It takes 30sec to level the bed and rarely needs to be done. Even quicker/less often and can do it by eye/feel after about 2 wks. The poor guy that bought the autolevel because it says "auto" has to 1st learn how to setup and use the autolevel. This is way, way, waayy more fkn difficult than just leveling the bed manually and getting to actually learn wtf is going on. I'd say the slicers would be the toughest part. So many knobs and switches in there to fk up View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Originally Posted By oetkbyetdia:
Originally Posted By mp9fan:
I use 3D printers professionally. While I agree it's not exactly a plug and play situation yet, it's getting there quickly. The Airwolf3D Axiom series is affordable and fairly automated. The difficulty is still in the design process. $4k is pretty crazy when you could prob build that same thing easily for ~$500 if you started at the bottom and learned your way up. And that guy is going to be pulling his hair out and done (put a fork in it, done) when the offset for the autolevel changes. Autolevel is the devil as far as I am concerned. I see so many people buy that shit thinking its gonna be push button easy. It takes 30sec to level the bed and rarely needs to be done. Even quicker/less often and can do it by eye/feel after about 2 wks. The poor guy that bought the autolevel because it says "auto" has to 1st learn how to setup and use the autolevel. This is way, way, waayy more fkn difficult than just leveling the bed manually and getting to actually learn wtf is going on. I'd say the slicers would be the toughest part. So many knobs and switches in there to fk up It's a minor learning curve to understand the concept of what elements of the slicer affect different aspects of the print. Also the printer companies help with this as well. Their engineers are learning too and share the info. I went through a couple manual leveling printers. After the machine is broken in with 100 or so hours of print time, it becomes a pain in the ass to get the bed juuuust right each time. And it doesn't always work. Plus the process of eyeballing it manually isn't precise. The auto leveling feature works and works really well. I put 100s of print hours through my first Axiom and the auto leveler worked and continues to work flawlessly. What broke first was the heat bed supports ETA: yes I'll grant you that 4K is a lot for a hobby toy when you can build one for $300 or whatever. But 4K is an awesome price for a professional machine, with warranty and engineer support, and a proven record for specific resolutions and speeds , etc |
|
John_Wayne777:
If this shit keeps up it might contain so many massive egos in one place that the sheer density of self importance might collapse in on itself and end all of humanity. |
Originally Posted By oetkbyetdia:
They are fkn awesome and a ton of fun, for the right person. For the wrong person, they can be your worst fkn nightmare Here is a quick test. You buy ar15 and it short strokes when you take it out. Do you fix the thing, or send it back? If you answered fix the thing, awesome and a ton of fun. If you answered send it back, your worst fkn nightmare. View Quote I have assembled all of my ARs except for the first one I purchased and mill my own 80% lowers. |
|
|
Originally Posted By mp9fan:
It's a minor learning curve to understand the concept of what elements of the slicer affect different aspects of the print. Also the printer companies help with this as well. Their engineers are learning too and share the info. I went through a couple manual leveling printers. After the machine is broken in with 100 or so hours of print time, it becomes a pain in the ass to get the bed juuuust right each time. And it doesn't always work. Plus the process of eyeballing it manually isn't precise. The auto leveling feature works and works really well. I put 100s of print hours through my first Axiom and the auto leveler worked and continues to work flawlessly. What broke first was the heat bed supports ETA: yes I'll grant you that 4K is a lot for a hobby toy when you can build one for $300 or whatever. But 4K is an awesome price for a professional machine, with warranty and engineer support, and a proven record for specific resolutions and speeds , etc View Quote For sure Different set of needs for hobbyist vs pro. Time vs money thing I'd say. When people ask, I tell them autolevel is to speed things up for those who already know wtf they are doing. It most definitely is not to make things easier for the guys that don't know wtf they are doing. Nobody listens though, and they usually end up beating their head against the wall for ~2wks trying to figure out how to setup the autolevel, instead of the ~5min it will take you to level it the 1st time manually As a homegamer, I enjoyed all the deficiancies of the $250 el cheapo that I got. Every one of them was a chance to learn more about this witchcraft. The thing printed ok out of the box, but after tuning things up, it does pretty damn good. Hell, drawing the parts to stiffen things up was how learned to draw I just looked at the ones I uploaded for others to use, over 7,000 downloads |
|
|
Originally Posted By Fidel_Cashflow:
I have assembled all of my ARs except for the first one I purchased and mill my own 80% lowers. View Quote You absolutely need one of these in your life then I'd say don't shell out the big bucks on a fancy one and go with the erector set ones like I got. Half the fun is making it better yourself (just like ARs), and lots of projects to practice drawing along the way. |
|
|
These things selling for $40 at the LGS is what we'd see if NFA went away for silencers, IMO.
|
|
|
Originally Posted By SWODaddy:
These things selling for $40 at the LGS is what we'd see if NFA went away for silencers, IMO. View Quote My shit would be running 24/7 if that happened. $40 would be making decent money, $20 on the friends and family discount would still prob make out good ETA you could hit the button, go to sleep, and have 16 of the things waiting for you in the morning (put the printer somewhere it can't burn the fkn place down or gas you out if you leave it unattended) |
|
|
U.S. Army Warrant Officer, 920B & 915E, CW4(P)
MT, USA
|
|
KF7WNX This election, Its like "Mad Max Fury Road" future Vs. "The Road" future. Trump's apocalypse has a flaming guitar. Hillary's is gray and depressing.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.