Warning

 

Close
Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Cancel Confirm
AR15.COM
AR Sponsor
3/9/2013 4:57:52 PM EDT
That is the question.

I have a 20" WOA SS barrel on one of my ARs and it has some weight issues. I'm looking to take some weight off but not sure how much I'm really going to gain in weight savings versus the cost of having the work done.

Now I could have it cut down to 18" or 16" inches and be done with it. Or I can leave the length alone and have it fluted. Or I can cut it down and flute it anyway.

I'm curious if anyone else out there has had something similar done and if they felt it was worth it.

Stand by for poll.


FYI: I'm planning on have ADCO do the work. Just the fluting is $120. Just the cutting crowning and rethreading is $65.
3/9/2013 6:03:22 PM EDT
[#1]
Quoted:
That is the question.

I have a 20" WOA SS barrel on one of my ARs and it has some weight issues. I'm looking to take some weight off but not sure how much I'm really going to gain in weight savings versus the cost of having the work done.

Now I could have it cut down to 18" or 16" inches and be done with it. Or I can leave the length alone and have it fluted. Or I can cut it down and flute it anyway.

I'm curious if anyone else out there has had something similar done and if they felt it was worth it.

Stand by for poll.


FYI: I'm planning on have ADCO do the work. Just the fluting is $120. Just the cutting crowning and rethreading is $65.


I assume it has rifle-length gas, so cutting to 16" isn't really an option, and even 18" may not work. That pretty much leaves fluting. What's the profile? Is turning it down an option?
3/9/2013 7:28:50 PM EDT
[#2]
Quoted:
Quoted:
That is the question.

I have a 20" WOA SS barrel on one of my ARs and it has some weight issues. I'm looking to take some weight off but not sure how much I'm really going to gain in weight savings versus the cost of having the work done.

Now I could have it cut down to 18" or 16" inches and be done with it. Or I can leave the length alone and have it fluted. Or I can cut it down and flute it anyway.

I'm curious if anyone else out there has had something similar done and if they felt it was worth it.

Stand by for poll.


FYI: I'm planning on have ADCO do the work. Just the fluting is $120. Just the cutting crowning and rethreading is $65.


I assume it has rifle-length gas, so cutting to 16" isn't really an option, and even 18" may not work. That pretty much leaves fluting. What's the profile? Is turning it down an option?


It is a rifle length. Is there any reason why the gas port can just be drilled in a new location?
3/9/2013 7:30:47 PM EDT
[#3]
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
That is the question.

I have a 20" WOA SS barrel on one of my ARs and it has some weight issues. I'm looking to take some weight off but not sure how much I'm really going to gain in weight savings versus the cost of having the work done.

Now I could have it cut down to 18" or 16" inches and be done with it. Or I can leave the length alone and have it fluted. Or I can cut it down and flute it anyway.

I'm curious if anyone else out there has had something similar done and if they felt it was worth it.

Stand by for poll.


FYI: I'm planning on have ADCO do the work. Just the fluting is $120. Just the cutting crowning and rethreading is $65.




I assume it has rifle-length gas, so cutting to 16" isn't really an option, and even 18" may not work. That pretty much leaves fluting. What's the profile? Is turning it down an option?


It is a rifle length. Is there any reason why the gas port can just be drilled in a new location?


Are you sure you can put your gas block in another location?
3/9/2013 7:53:56 PM EDT
[#4]
Anything but a dremel
3/9/2013 8:29:37 PM EDT
[#5]
Well,

Keep as is...

I grab my 20" with my vortex on top and it's not a big deal...it's that type of weapon...

I have a cqb weapon, and others...

I just a couple days ago heard my gf say a build was heavy...

If its under 10# leave it alone...unless there is an issue with the performance of it...

Ymmv
Bret
3/9/2013 9:11:43 PM EDT
[#6]
There's other ways to lose weight.

That said I cut my own 20" H-bar to 16." Some port work is required. If it's a rifle buffer system they tend to run fine. If it's a carbine buffer an H or H2 may be needed. Mine was done because I wanted a shorter rifle, not for weight issues (though it does balance and swing marginally better).

If a weight loss is really what's desired have the barrel re-profiled instead.
3/9/2013 9:28:35 PM EDT
[#7]
How much more is the barrel you want over the $185 you are going to spend to try and make the one you have into it?  If it is less then $250 I would buy another barrel and hold on to the 20".  

MAHA
3/10/2013 4:46:29 AM EDT
[#8]
Here's the  famous dremmel flute that everyone has come to love and adore.


AR Sponsor