User Panel
Posted: 10/28/2014 3:59:16 AM EDT
Is there a automotive grease that doesn't contain graphite? I recently learned about the corrosive affects of graphite. In the past I think I used marine grease (boat trailer wheel bearing grease).
|
|
Auto manufactures and mechanics use Anti seize to prevent / protect aluminum / steel threading surface since cars have been running aluminum cylinder heads with steel spark plugs. Anti seize is also used in high heat (up to 1600 deg F) areas such as O2 sensor fittings in the exhaust system.
The number one step to cure the massive Galvanic Plague of 2014 is hard anodizing. |
|
I've used Lubriplate 630 lithium grease, Dow Corning G-N high moly and the assembly grease that came with an Edelbrock cam kit. Never any problems.
I suppose it would be proper to use Parker Thread Lube though.
|
|
I am using Royal Purple Synthetic High Temp grease. Good to 600°
I haven't had any probs. It doesn't take much on the threads. I have 1 tube. After building 6 rifles I have a teaspoon less than 1 tube. Ha ha. I also use it on the BCG when I 1st build a rifle. After 100 rounds I clean up the grease and just run oil. I use Royal Purple 10W-40 oil on one of my rifles as an experience. I get bot at work. So far been super happy with Royal Purple products as gun lube! |
|
There are 100s of grease threads here, and they typically devolve into a pissing match over the merits of Aeroshell.
Nothing wrong with that marine wheel bearing grease you mentioned, in my opinion. I put together 5 or 6 with the Lucas blue marine wheel bearing grease. They didn't burst into flames, or have the barrel rot off. I bought the coveted Aeroshell 33MS, and some Valvoline Ford/Mercury moly grease, which is readily available at the local O'Reilly's Auto Parts. They are both moly fortified, and look exactly alike. Big difference is; the Valvoline doesn't smell like rotten ass. That Aeroshell will stink up everything it gets near The barrel nut Nazis will be along shortly to tell me that my barrel nut is now not properly torqued on those rifles that I chose to not use Aeroshell on. I can assure them that they are. I still may use some Aeroshell, simply because I might pack wheel bearings on one of my trailers with the Valvoline, who knows? I have some pretty nice uppers, and it doesn't bother me a damn bit to consciously go right past the Aeroshell, and pick the others so that I don't have to listen to my old lady bitching about bringing an AR into the house that is reeking like an old tierod. Flame on! |
|
Thank you for the Smell-O-Vision!! I never knew what the "stink" was about Aeroshell (pun intended!). I don't try not to use it, it's just that I have the Royal Purple products by the drawer full of tubes and oil by the 5 gallon buckets.
I figure if this grease is good to be used on a gas turbine and my industrial air compressors love the oil, then it's good enough for my AR15! |
|
White Lithium grease, $4 at home depot and it will last you a lifetime of builds.
|
|
I use a $1.99 pack of gray wheel bearing grease from AutoZone. Probably a lifetime supply for most people.
|
|
I use Aeroshell 33MS. It's one of several MIL-G 21164 greases that are available. I do not use automotive grease, and I don't use bacon grease either.
It's your gun, but why would you want to spend a good amount of money on a new upper and a new barrel, and then put them together with the cheapest grease you could find? As an old boss of mine would say, "when you say it out loud like that, you think about it differently." With shipping, a 14oz tube of Aeroshell 33MS runs around $22-$25, and it will last you a VERY long time, so it's not even a huge cost. |
|
So another question: has anyone ever actually seen a receiver corrode from wrong grease?
|
|
I used synthetic brake and caliper grease that I have at work. I didn't know about the graphite problem at the time of assembly. The container clearly says that it contains "nature graphite". So......when the barrel falls off of the upper receiver in 47.65 years from now, I'll just buy another one.
|
|
This works well and has been working well on my bolts, and slides on my 1911s, etc.
Lucus Red & Tacky |
|
Quoted:
So another question: has anyone ever actually seen a receiver corrode from wrong grease? View Quote Nobody has posted evidence of that here. I HAVE seen aluminum/steel galvanic corrosion in action, and it's fast. But preventing galvanic corrosion is only a tiny, incidental part of the purpose of using the specified grease. It is a time-tested medium for allowing high temperature and high pressure assemblies of steel and aluminum parts, it has a well established, very stable viscosity that is important when torquing the barrel nut, and it's pretty easy to find commercially. Anybody that says it's ONLY for corrosion prevention doesn't pay enough attention; it's really hard to get through hardcoat anodizing with corrosion, since the anodizing is already an aluminum oxide compound - and aluminum oxide is not electrochemically active. To me, using "the right grease" means paying attention to specs and following well established and proven instructions to get an AR built. |
|
|
|
Unfortunately I don't believe anything our Government says. So i like to go against the grain with the grease. I have the tech data sheet of the Aeroshell and I'm comparing it to the Royal Purple High Temp Sythetic. I will let report back what I find out as to which one has better "specs"
|
|
Quoted: it's really hard to get through hardcoat anodizing with corrosion, since the anodizing is already an aluminum oxide compound - and aluminum oxide is not electrochemically active. View Quote Doesn't that kind of make graphite in lube a moot point then? Graphite is suppose to promote conductivity of ions between aluminium and other dissimilar metals. So if the hard anodizing isn't conductive then there is no issue with graphite. |
|
Interesting point. I will have to ponder that one. Seems resonable
|
|
Quoted:
Doesn't that kind of make graphite in lube a moot point then? Graphite is suppose to promote conductivity of ions between aluminium and other dissimilar metals. So if the hard anodizing isn't conductive then there is no issue with graphite. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted: it's really hard to get through hardcoat anodizing with corrosion, since the anodizing is already an aluminum oxide compound - and aluminum oxide is not electrochemically active. Doesn't that kind of make graphite in lube a moot point then? Graphite is suppose to promote conductivity of ions between aluminium and other dissimilar metals. So if the hard anodizing isn't conductive then there is no issue with graphite. Graphite provides lubricity in a couple of ways. It forms "plates" of molecules that slide across each other, but it also draws water to it from the atmosphere, which allows its "plates" to slide even better. It also holds that water quite well, which makes it a great electrolyte. But here's another thing it does: it's mildly abrasive on a microscopic level, so it can dig into the hardcoat and break through it because of the tight fit between the upper and the barrel nut. Typical hard coat anodizing is around 0.0005" thick, and it's not so hard that graphite can't scrape through it. So while it's not the enormous bugaboo some people make it out to be, it's not a good idea to use graphite with anything aluminum, anodized or not. |
|
So, what if nothing is used? Just harder or impossible to take back apart?
|
|
|
Right, it keeps it from slipping or chattering making it possible to tighten it smoothly and accurately. Also if you tighten without grease you have to use a different torque value.
|
|
|
|
Any quality grease that doesn't contain graphite. Beyond that, It doesn't make the slightest bit of difference. I use white lithium grease, or ARP assembly lube simply because it is on my shelf.
|
|
Quoted:
There are 100s of grease threads here, and they typically devolve into a pissing match over the merits of Aeroshell. Nothing wrong with that marine wheel bearing grease you mentioned, in my opinion. I put together 5 or 6 with the Lucas blue marine wheel bearing grease. They didn't burst into flames, or have the barrel rot off. I bought the coveted Aeroshell 33MS, and some Valvoline Ford/Mercury moly grease, which is readily available at the local O'Reilly's Auto Parts. They are both moly fortified, and look exactly alike. Big difference is; the Valvoline doesn't smell like rotten ass. That Aeroshell will stink up everything it gets near The barrel nut Nazis will be along shortly to tell me that my barrel nut is now not properly torqued on those rifles that I chose to not use Aeroshell on. I can assure them that they are. I still may use some Aeroshell, simply because I might pack wheel bearings on one of my trailers with the Valvoline, who knows? I have some pretty nice uppers, and it doesn't bother me a damn bit to consciously go right past the Aeroshell, and pick the others so that I don't have to listen to my old lady bitching about bringing an AR into the house that is reeking like an old tierod. Flame on! +1 View Quote |
|
honda moly paste 60.
its $9 for a huge tube of it at your local honda dealership. made for steel > aluminum mating. |
|
Quoted:
honda moly paste 60. its $9 for a huge tube of it at your local honda dealership. made for steel > aluminum mating. View Quote Honda's Moly 60 has a lot more molybdenum disulfide than MIL G 21164 greases do. That's not a "bad thing," but it's something to note. If I didn't have my AeroShell 33MS, I'd use Moly 60. |
|
View Quote Me too. |
|
View Quote I use Loctite C5A Copper Anti seize |
|
Any moly EP from the parts store will work fine.
Aeroshell 33MS is what's called out, that doesn't mean that's the only grease that'll get the job done, it's the only one that can be used by a government contractor during assembly on military M16's. |
|
i had a tube of anti seize from autozone from the last engine i rebuilt, so i threw some of that on it. havent taken it apart to know if it's working or not though. lol. should be fine.
|
|
I'm no expert but this is what I use.
https://www.mystiklubes.com/do/product/665056002 Hi Temp NO graphite 3% moly 3 bucks a tube. |
|
|
|
|
|
Well I've never used Mobil 1 synthetic. I use high temp Royal Purple. Works great
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.