Quote History Quoted:
Dark cabinets with what color counter? Dark, or more towards tan?
How would that look with the hardwood floor being such a light color?
Thanks for the info!
View Quote
Try to grab some samples of counter and cabinet colors. Take your initial ideas of 'colors' and grab a few samples and bring them home. Lowes is great for offering stone samples from their kitchen dept. I was thinking about a Silestone countertop and picked 2 colors. The one that looked better than the other one at Lowes didn't look as good once I came home. The other sample was absolutely perfect for the kitchen.
When I saw pictures of your kitchen, I could tell it was functional, but the color of the cabinetry just doesn't look right to me. Sometimes a little paint needs to be brought into the scope of work as well. It looks like you have maple floors, so my initial recommendation would be to go with maple cabinetry or something dark. A counter with a lighter tone would be a great step forward from there.
As I stroll through the pictures on page 1, I also thought of recommending tile work that resembles the stone work on the front corners of your garage. Another observation is that I really like the white trim on your windows and that would look really good on your kitchen window behind the sink. I think the dining area to the right of your pantry cabinet needs matching paint to the rest of the house but that's just a quick observation.
I would also look for a door panel for your cabinetry that resembles your garage doors. They look nice and bringing that design cue inside would be one of my suggestions.
Also, from a distance, I like the style of faucet you have on your kitchen sink. A nice undermount sink would look really good with it during your countertop replacement if you chose that direction.