Posted: 2/13/2014 5:29:26 AM EDT
I'm thinking about getting a Commander before I get another full size 1911 like the TRP. I like the Colt because it is the right length, 4.25", and has a bushing barrel. Are there any issues with this particular model? What is the recoil like on a aluminum commander vs a full size steel model? Any things to look out for with the aluminum frame, like mags damaging feed ramps? I heard that mags with metal followers can damage the feed ramps of a aluminum framed gun. Thanks for responding.
Here is the gun, I would find one with the beavertail over the duckbill 
|
|
I have had one for a few years. The only issue I have had is the rear sight was not screwed down from the factory.
I run 99% handloads (200 grain ball and SWC) and a few test runs with Win Ranger. It has had no issues. Recoil is a tiny bit stouter than with a 5" steel version but I do not notice it unless I think about it. If you use a mag without a captured follower, it may ding the feedramp (under where the bullet hits it) but it should not impact function. I have run Wilson and Tripp in mine with zero issues. I will say that every edge on the gun is sharp. The front serrations will eat a leather holster. |
|
Quoted:
I have had one for a few years. The only issue I have had is the rear sight was not screwed down from the factory. I run 99% handloads (200 grain ball and SWC) and a few test runs with Win Ranger. It has had no issues. Recoil is a tiny bit stouter than with a 5" steel version but I do not notice it unless I think about it. If you use a mag without a captured follower, it may ding the feedramp (under where the bullet hits it) but it should not impact function. I have run Wilson and Tripp in mine with zero issues. I will say that every edge on the gun is sharp. The front serrations will eat a leather holster. I can send the Colt to SACS and get the carry bevel if it was too sharp. Anyone else have experience with the XSE? |
| I have one and love it for a carry weapon. Recoil is not bad (my wife shoots it like a champ). I have swapped out all of the internals for Wilson Combat Bullet Proof parts with the exception of the grip safety which is an Ed Brown and the hammer that is a Cylinder and Slide. I did find it EXTREMLY sharp before I had it dehorned. I also swapped the sights out for Novak's with tritium. |
|
long time owner of a CCO LW custom.
carried for many years with no problems. as a poster,said above,really can't tell about recoil. runs HP PD and my weak 230gr. LRN loads like the proverbial ''sewing machine''. i,run nothing,but wilson mags.(just my preference). no sign,of any,frame damage. just my $.02. 
clown |
|
Quoted: I can send the Colt to SACS and get the carry bevel if it was too sharp. Anyone else have experience with the XSE? Quoted: Quoted: I have had one for a few years. The only issue I have had is the rear sight was not screwed down from the factory. I run 99% handloads (200 grain ball and SWC) and a few test runs with Win Ranger. It has had no issues. Recoil is a tiny bit stouter than with a 5" steel version but I do not notice it unless I think about it. If you use a mag without a captured follower, it may ding the feedramp (under where the bullet hits it) but it should not impact function. I have run Wilson and Tripp in mine with zero issues. I will say that every edge on the gun is sharp. The front serrations will eat a leather holster. I can send the Colt to SACS and get the carry bevel if it was too sharp. Anyone else have experience with the XSE? Send it Where? I have one. it is my least favorite Pistol right now. |
|
Quoted:
Send it Where? I have one. it is my least favorite Pistol right now. Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I have had one for a few years. The only issue I have had is the rear sight was not screwed down from the factory. I run 99% handloads (200 grain ball and SWC) and a few test runs with Win Ranger. It has had no issues. Recoil is a tiny bit stouter than with a 5" steel version but I do not notice it unless I think about it. If you use a mag without a captured follower, it may ding the feedramp (under where the bullet hits it) but it should not impact function. I have run Wilson and Tripp in mine with zero issues. I will say that every edge on the gun is sharp. The front serrations will eat a leather holster. I can send the Colt to SACS and get the carry bevel if it was too sharp. Anyone else have experience with the XSE? Send it Where? I have one. it is my least favorite Pistol right now. Springfield Armory Custom Shop. Why don't you like it? What issues have you had with it? |
|
Quoted: Springfield Armory Custom Shop. Why don't you like it? What issues have you had with it? Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: I have had one for a few years. The only issue I have had is the rear sight was not screwed down from the factory. I run 99% handloads (200 grain ball and SWC) and a few test runs with Win Ranger. It has had no issues. Recoil is a tiny bit stouter than with a 5" steel version but I do not notice it unless I think about it. If you use a mag without a captured follower, it may ding the feedramp (under where the bullet hits it) but it should not impact function. I have run Wilson and Tripp in mine with zero issues. I will say that every edge on the gun is sharp. The front serrations will eat a leather holster. I can send the Colt to SACS and get the carry bevel if it was too sharp. Anyone else have experience with the XSE? Send it Where? I have one. it is my least favorite Pistol right now. Springfield Armory Custom Shop. Why don't you like it? What issues have you had with it? Ah, SA custom shop. I wonder what wait times are currently like. thanks for the suggestion! Cosmetic mostly. I had to send it back though. the thumb safety was gouging the frame. the sharp edges are really bad and I don't care for the finish on the frame. I've also noticed that some of the Wilson mags fit really tight. I think the trigger assembly might need some tweaking. Muzzle flip is very noticeable compared to my Steel framed guns. it does carry well though. For the price, I think I would have been happier with a springfield champion operator. |
|
Quoted:
The Commander has a FLGR, do Commanders use the same size plug and guide as a Government model? I will switch it out if I buy one. No, You will need a Commander plug and guide. I did the same to mine as well, But I carry an "Enhanced" Model from the early '90s now. http://i365.photobucket.com/albums/oo96/medic15al/003-2_zpscbabc612.jpg |