Posted: 1/30/2006 6:35:05 PM EDT
|
I currently have an HK USP Compact in 9mm. Great piece that I plan on keeping a long time but too bulky for what I want in a consealed carry piece, especially in summertime clothing. I'm not necessarily looking for a pocket gun but I do want something noticeable smaller than my HK. My requirements in the order of importance are; 1) Reliability - I want a proven design that I can depend on 2) US produced round (9mm, .380, 32, etc). Not interested in the 9x18mak 3) Small size 3) External Safety 4) Light weight While I'm not looking to blow money I have no problems with saving for a top quality piece. Any suggestions? (edit to add) I would consider a wheel gun but I prefer auto pistols. |
I feel for you. The thing is too thick for sticking IWB. Have you tried a Hi Power? I have and I'll have to find yet another that conceals as well IWB and as comfortable.  So far, Glock is second best, Sig worst, USPc in between these two, as far as bulkiness goes.
|
|
that external safety is going to be a problem. otherwise i would have suggested a sig p232. i have a friend who conceals a cz75 compact. those come in various varieties including safety but it is likely as big as what you have now. oh ah ha i found one that might work very well--cz 2075 rami. |
|
Hmm, sounds like we have a few votes for the Kahr I can honestly say I knew nothing about these until this thread. Every review I have found thus far gives the Kahr really high marks. on them so far is all positive. Would I be a fool to chose the MK9 over the PM9? The Kahr is a front runner so far but I still want to entertain other suggestions. Also, like to see what my best choice would be that has an external safety. So far, only one I have heard is the CZ RAMI. Does it compare with the the Kahr PM9/MK9? On the SIG P232, is it much smaller than my USP Compact? On paper it does not seem so but it looks a lot more compact in the pictures. |
|
My new Kahr MK9 cracked the slide after just 50 rounds of +P for it's shakedown session.. Might have just been a fluke, but I didn't trust them after that. Brought it back and traded up to a Sig P239 in .40. It handles +P all day long with no problem. I don't shoot +P all the time for practice, but I feel a CCW should by able to handle at least 50 rounds of it. The Kahrs are built too lightweight for me, just my opinion. The P239 is slim enough for IWB, being single stack. It may seem big, but once IWB it is very comfy. |
+1 on that gun, its what I carry if I can't conceal a full size 1911 |
I have a Sig 232 stainless and the grip is the biggest thing on it. The slide and frame is slender which makes it easier to carry than most compact 9mms like the USP compact. Compact 9mms keep a lot of thickness in the slide to fit the trigger bar and breech lock that a .380 blowback design doesn't need. (Except for Kahr, which solved the slide thickness problem in breech lock pistols by using a patented sidestepped feed ramp) On the plus side, the grip on the 232 and pop-caliber .380 makes it very easy to point, shoot and control (quick and effortless follow up shots). I find the 232 to be a very accurate gun since blowback designs are fixed barrel and it's a thoroughbred Sig all the way. (Barrel is solid to the frame and not free-floating like in breech lock design (9mm on up) ) Much easier to shoot the Sig 232 accurately quickly than the Kahr PM9. Much easier to conceal the PM9 and there is the whole 9mm vs. .380 effectiveness issue. Just from backyard shooting, I find .380 hits a lot harder than people might think. But it's not quite 9mm. I also have a Glock 29 (10mm) for CCW. That one is brick, even though it's a "compact" pistol. I only wear it outside the waistband in a good holster and gun belt. |
I wonder how a good Hornady or Corbon +P .380 would work in the P232. |
|
If money is no object, check out the Rohrbaugh. The worlds smallest current production 9mm automatic (so they claim). Expensive, but those I have spoken to who have one swear by it. 
|
|
i'll tell you what, it may not be what your looking for, but I carry a kel-tec p32 with a ten round mag in the summer. I wear snug fitting tank tops and t's in the summer, and this gun will dissappear in your belt line. so far i've put only 80-100 .32 rounds thru it, both in holows and regular brass but absolutely no problems. I got a buddy with the .80 version who's very happy with his as well, and they're both virtually the same size. |
I have tried the Corbon 90 grain +P and Federal Hydra-Shoks .380 in the 232. Haven't tried the Hornady round, but I hear it's just as good. The Corbons really kick and make a flash. Feels almost like shooting 9mm. The Federal Hydra-Shoks shoot really nice. They're the "low recoil" ammo and feel like a soft push with very little muzzle flash. Also very accurate. Golden saber also makes a .380 but never tried that one either. But I hear it's as good as any of them. Just because they shoot so nicely, I prefer the Hydra Shoks as carry ammo, since good shot placement will be even more so critical with a .380. However, the Sig 232 has pretty much been replaced by the Kahr PM9 for my small CCW gun needs. With several hundred rounds of practice you can shoot the little PM9 about as good as a full sized gun. It's amazingly accurate once you get practiced with it. Put a Hogue Handall Jr. slip on grip on the PM9 and it'll handle even better. It's like it should have come with the Hogue grip. |
I may have to try the P232 for CCW. I have come to love all things Sig over the years. |
i had golden sabres in my p232. it isn't +p ammo but iirc there is no such thing as +p for the .380. but in general there was much more muzzle flip and recoil bite than with a full size 9mm. but that is due to the size and blowback function than a locked breach design. if you slap hogue grips on it then it will be much more comfortable to shoot. also i had the alloy slide version which is lighter than the stainless version and the extra weight for stainless might make it nicer as well. |
|
I have been carrying the Kahr PM9 for over a year now with no problems. Shoot about 100 rounds through it every other week or so for practice. Only gripe was when I first got it the magazine release was easy to accidentally hit, but Kahr has since made a change in the release design and they replaced the part quickly free of charge. Side note, I have a Tomcat too but don't care for it much. |
|
I recommend two models, because I own them, so that gives me first hand knowledge. First, I bought my wife a Model 60 J Frame S&W 357. She is not a fan of semi-autos, doesn't like the fact that she has to pull the slide back to load a round in the chamber, much prefers revolvers. She doesn't like shooting the 357 ammo, but really likes shooting 38's in it. It is small, and fits in her purse nicely. It would fit in a belly bag just fine. Second, for my small carry gun I got a PPK, made by S&W. It is small, reliable and accurate. Currently I have Remington Golden Sabers loaded in it, but I am going to try some Winchester Siver Tips and the Cor Bon DPX ammo to see if they are also reliable in feeding. Depending upon how they feed, I will probably pick the most accurate for carry purposes. Good luck with whatever you decide. |
|
1 vote for Kahr PM40. I love mine, but it was not without some growing problems during the break in. I called Dottie at Kakr for a new recoil spring and two broken magazines. Dottie was awsome and I had no trouble with Kahr customer service. After replacing the parts it's now 100% and I now trust my life to it. |
Because external safeties on a DAO gun are stupid and unnecessary. How many double action revolvers have external safeties? I know, a few odds ones do, but the overwhelming majority have none. |
Why not have DA/SA gun with external safety? The CZ 2075 RAMI is set up this way. However, I read one review that states its SA trigger pull is about 7lbs. 
|
|
A 1911 guy at my work asked about a CCW, he wanted something smaller for summer. I put him on to the Kahr PM9 and Sig 232 380, Kel-Tec P3AT as my choices for what he descibed as him needs. I dont own any of the three but I did stay at a holiday in express last night. He checked out some other pistols also, He did test firings on all three from friends or range employee's. He bought a blued P232. He put around 500rd trouble frre rounds thru it before he stuck it on his belt. He came in this morning and thanked me. I trust his opinion on many things so I thought I would pass it on. |