Posted: 2/19/2012 3:37:35 AM EDT
|
I am sure this topic has been done to death however I didn't find a previous topics that I thought adequately convinced me so...
I am looking getting my 1st 357 not looking for ccw gun as I have plenty that fill that role, so I am thinking either a 4" or 6" I don't plan on competition shooting with it, I will probably carry it as a back up when I go hunting, as well as target shooting, and I would like it to serve as a good work hoarse combat revolver as well. basically just a good, accurate, reliable workhorse 357 I also cannot spend $1000 plus on it, my price range is looking around $500-$650 my initial feeling was to get a ruger gp100, I like that it is supposedly a tank of a revolver and owners of it seem to think very highly of its performance, its also a current production weapon so if it ever has issues parts shouldn't be a problem. however there is a gun show coming up soon and with it the opportunity to eyeball some various used s&w and colt 357s I have been looking into different S&w 357 such as the 686 and so on. supposedly they have a much better trigger than the ruger but are not as robust and rugged, and with the issues with the locking mechanism as well the diversity of all the different models I am a bit confused as to a particular model I should look out for. lastly in years past I have also seen a number of used colt troopers and trooper mark III revolvers for sale a decent price, I have always had an affinity for colts and I have been told that the trooper is a tank of a 357 similar in ruggedness to the ruger but with a better trigger. it is however an orphan gun and parts could be an issue later down the road. so my question is this, should I just take the plunge and get a new gp100 now, or should I wait and see what used colts and s&w revolvers will be at this gun show. and if I should wait, what models should I stay away from and what models should I look for. |
|
If you can find a pre-lock L-frame S&W 586 or 686 (shouldn't be too difficult) go for that. Probably the best all-around workhorse .357 out there. Nice trigger and action, very accurate and built to withstand constant use with heavy magnum loads. Stuff one with .38s and it's like shooting a .22. The GP100 is nice too, but it's trigger and action are not as smooth as the S&W and both weapons are as rugged as they need to be.
The only issues I can think of with the S&W L-frames were with a very few early production 586s. No-dash and -1 models IIRC. There's still a S&W recall out on them to replace the firing pin and a couple other small bits. If they've already had the recall done there will be a "M" stamped in the yoke of the frame and you're good to go. The newer guns are all good to go. |
| I own two 686+ models, one 3" and one 5". They are by far my favorite wheel guns and I even have a Python sitting in the safe (and it stays there more often than not). They are both pre-lock versions, so there is no issue there. I would say if you can find a 686 without the lock go for it. Otherwise, swoop up a Ruger and call it good. Its really going to come down to preference on which of the Big Three you are going to enjoy most. |
|
my initial feeling was to get a ruger gp100, I like that it is supposedly a tank of a revolver and owners of it seem to think very highly of its performance, its also a current production weapon so if it ever has issues parts shouldn't be a problem.
I love my GP. I can ring gongs at 100 yards with it! Stay the course... especially with the numbers of "lawyer-locked" guns coming out. |
|
Quoted:,...
I have been looking into different S&w 357 such as the 686 and so on. supposedly they have a much better trigger than the ruger but are not as robust and rugged, and with the issues with the locking mechanism as well the diversity of all the different models I am a bit confused as to a particular model I should look out for. . The S&W 686/586 are PLENTY strong. They are made of FORGED Steel Rugers are investment cast, and may look beefier, but not necessarily stronger the S&W's are smoother, especially after a tune up and Wolff spring kit. 
|
|
Good advice all, and I laughed at the "thicker" ad- haven't seen that for a while.
OP, Colt, DW, Ruger all make or made fine guns. I am a fan of S&W myself. If you find a nice M27 in your price range, buy it: 
If you find a nice M28 in your price range, seriously consider buying it: 
Or, and more likely, you may find a nice L frame- either the 586/686 or the 581/681's: 
Or, M13, M19, M66, if you like the K frames. They are nice handling guns, but I (regrettably, now) got rid of my last K magnum, a M66 snub, a decade ago and just decided I could make the adjustment to the L frames. Still got Dad's old M15, though ;) Read the Revolver Checkout by Jim March, and happy hunting! |
J&G currently has 4" Smith 66's for just over $400. I can promise you..... you'll never see "trade in" 66's again (I'm actually rather shocked that they found these!). While not quite as beefy as an L frame (586/686), they're still one of my favorates. I've got 2! 
|
|
Quoted: J&G currently has 4" Smith 66's for just over $400. I can promise you..... you'll never see "trade in" 66's again (I'm actually rather shocked that they found these!). While not quite as beefy as an L frame (586/686), they're still one of my favorates. I've got 2! $469 is a little over "just over" $400.  |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
J&G currently has 4" Smith 66's for just over $400. I can promise you..... you'll never see "trade in" 66's again (I'm actually rather shocked that they found these!). While not quite as beefy as an L frame (586/686), they're still one of my favorates. I've got 2! $469 is a little over "just over" $400.
I could've sworn I saw 'em at $449...... whoops! 
Still not a bad deal at $469....... though not quite as good as the $200 retail I bought my 66-1 for about 15 years ago. 
|
My first issue was a Colt Trooper 4in .357, then a S&W model 19 4in, 66 4in, 686 4in. The 686 was the most accurate of any revolver I had ever used and as the range officer and armorer tough enough to last. I have a couple but my favorite is my 686 RB 4in. You can’t go wrong with a 686 in 4 or 6 in depending on your size.
|
|
exellent, I am deffenately leaning toward the S&W now. and thanks for the line on the model 66 that jg sale has, I will be looking into that.
some great options so far, but what should I look out for, what models that may look like a deal should I run from? I know to check for the obvious, timing, lock-up, nicks on the crown, ect... but any real models to stay away from? aside from ones with the hammer lock? |
|
Good thread. I was in the same boat as you ,OP. I wanted stainless or nickel 357 from Colt, S&W or Ruger. I didn't care which one just whatever I found and liked first.
I found a nice S&W 66-2 with a 2 1/2" bbl from a guy at work. It was a ex Sheriff Dept. gun,and the next week at the fun show I found a 66 no dash with a 4" bbl. It was also an ex trooper gun. So...I got both, and am very pleased. Here's a crappy pic. 
|
|
Quoted:
A good but used N frame - 27 or 28. Here's a picture of a couple of old 28's. http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii228/Schemer2/Mod282011001.jpg and a 27; http://i265.photobucket.com/albums/ii228/Schemer2/SW27-2007.jpg This times 1000, also, how do you like that TR-3? Been thinking about picking one up. |
Win a FREE Membership!
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.