Posted: 1/23/2009 9:27:46 PM EDT
|
Bingo! We have a winner!
Yet another of the Great Unwashed who thinks a simple rivet makes the mag permanently restricted to low capacity. Wrong. Permanence in instances like this is required by 12020(c)(25)(A) PC: A feeding device that has been permanently altered so
that it cannot accommodate more than 10 rounds. Even though level of permanence is not defined, if it's easy to remove/recover capacity (rivets are easy to remove) it ain't permanent. If the mag, however, essentially has to be destroyed to recover capacity then you're in much better territory. Bill Wiese San Jose CA |
|
Quoted:
Bingo! We have a winner! Yet another of the Great Unwashed who thinks a simple rivet makes the mag permanently restricted to low capacity. Wrong. Permanence in instances like this is required by 12020(c)(25)(A) PC: A feeding device that has been permanently altered so
that it cannot accommodate more than 10 rounds. Even though level of permanence is not defined, if it's easy to remove/recover capacity (rivets are easy to remove) it ain't permanent. If the mag, however, essentially has to be destroyed to recover capacity then you're in much better territory. Bill Wiese San Jose CA Bingo, Bingo, Bingo! You just posted exactly what i was going to reply! Permanence is not defined . Your going to tell me that the 10/30 mags being sold with the only a small notch pushed into the mag to retain the follower is more "permanent then mine? Give me 60 seconds and a screwdriver and i could reverse that, but they are being sold everywhere. Anything that can be made can be taken back apart and made not permenent. It just depends how much time you want to spend.
Bobby |
|
Bingo, Bingo, Bingo! You just posted exactly what i was going to reply! Permanence is not defined . Your going to tell me that the 10/30 mags being sold with the only a small notch pushed into the mag to retain the follower is more "permanent then mine? Give me 60 seconds and a screwdriver and i could reverse that, but they are being sold everywhere. Anything that can be made can be taken back apart and made not permenent. It just depends how much time you want to spend.
1. Just because it's not formally defined doesn't mean you should not make a more-than-reasonable effort to achieve some level of permanence (i.e, destruction of major parts of mag to try to reverse capacity limitation). When something like this is undefined, it's the judge that gets to determine matters of law. And he may well not think pop rivets are permanent given they can be drilled out clawed out with some nippers etc. 2. Just because outta state idiots not understanding CA law are selling 10/30 mags into CA with bent tabs doesn't mean they'll stand up to a test. 3. I sure as hell wouldn't own one. You may be rich and can take risks. Remember, a screwup here risks leading to an AW charge on a rifle with a BB/Prince50 (as opposed to a 'featureless' rifle that can drop mags). Bill Wiese San Jose CA |
|
Quoted:
Bingo, Bingo, Bingo! You just posted exactly what i was going to reply! Permanence is not defined . Your going to tell me that the 10/30 mags being sold with the only a small notch pushed into the mag to retain the follower is more "permanent then mine? Give me 60 seconds and a screwdriver and i could reverse that, but they are being sold everywhere. Anything that can be made can be taken back apart and made not permenent. It just depends how much time you want to spend.
1. How much effort would you define as reasonable?? If I inserted a block to hold the follower and welded the bottom plate, you could just hacksaw the mag, rip it out and spot weld back together. All easy to do in my measly 1 car garage in no more then 30 minutes. So who is to define reasonable effort for me? Should I take the rivets, weld those, JB weld on top of that, weld the floorplate, insert a follower restricting rod, press in a holding tab into the side of the mag, and toss in a little duct tape in the mix just to make sure it all stays together? All of the things I just stated are used to make mags legal in CA and all are easy to revert. In the end, it is up to the judge, your right. 2. Well CA is letting these mags in, so I would assume that they are OK with them. Haven't heard of a case of anyone getting busted with these easy to revert mags. Don't think they have plates welded to their mags either. So how would these mags be any more permanent then my magazine mod? 3. do you run a featured build w/BB or prince50? If so, what mags are you using? 10 rounders? As stated in my tutorial, if you don't agree with the idea, then don't build one. Simple as that. I just posted it up because I know many people from CA do this to mags. Just thought I would put up some info on how it could be done. have not heard of a case of them getting busted for rivet modded mags either. Sure it could be different/better, if you want to fill the mag with cement just be safe, go ahead. |
|
I like that as a start but would glue a rod inside the well before sealing the bottom with JB Weld.
Actually I use a MonsterMan grip so I can use my pre-1999 magazines.
I do have some shorty magazines and don't mind them at all. Even with the MM grip I like the 20-round magazines as it allows me to get just that much closer to mother earth while shooting. |
|
A feeding device that has been permanently altered so that it cannot accommodate more than 10 rounds. The question becomes what is the definition of permanent. If the mag was made out of 1" steel plates and welded together, I could still disassemble the magazine. The Earth is not permanent. So doesn't the definition of permanent become a reasonable modification requiring the use of tools to modify? Nothing is permanent. |
|
I just don't understand why you are concerned about this, bweise.
You have to disassemble the magazine (which requires the use of tools) and then you need to use tools to remove the rivet. After removing the rivet, there's still a hole in the body as testimony to its having been a ten rounder. That hole is permanent. So is the rivet, unless it is intentionally removed. It isn't going to just vaporize after and presto!, you have a 20 round magazine. That speaks of a degree of permanence, at least it does to me. |


















. Your going to tell me that the 10/30 mags being sold with the only a small notch pushed into the mag to retain the follower is more "permanent then mine? Give me 60 seconds and a screwdriver and i could reverse that, but they are being sold everywhere. Anything that can be made can be taken back apart and made not permenent. It just depends how much time you want to spend.
nice work