Moved the family to Pocatello in '95 for work. Moved back to Oregon in 2019 for work and to be closer to my Mom and Mother-in-law as they were getting into their 80's.
It was a good place to raise our four kids. Much more conservative than Oregon. Oldest son was 5th grade and had a difficult his first year in school because we are not LDS. I don't know that not being LDS is a big a deal now. Crime rates have certainly increased over the years.
Cost of housing when we moved was great, now not so much. Shopping has improved with Costco being in town. Restaurants are much, much more diverse than they used to be, and there are good micro breweries now. Idaho Falls has more shopping and more restaurants and is an easy 45 minute drive (non-winter).
Pretty good gun range very close to town, you can shoot out to 380 yards. Also a lot of shooting disciplines there.
Oregon Trail Gun RangeYou really want to consider the weather, especially if your have not been through cold winters. Snow staying on the ground would start about Thanksgiving and melt off by late February through mid March. Saw it snow as early as September and as late as June. Winter snow doesn't normally get real deep but it sure does blow around. Always one to three weeks of 10 to 20 below zero weather in the winter. Spring seems to last a couple of weeks and then it is summer. Highs in the upper 80s, low 90s are normal but the humidity is really low. Fall can come really quick or be late and seems to transition quickly to winter. If you like wind, lots of wind year round, Pocatello is a great place to be.
For outdoor activities, there is a lot to do around the area (near by and within a day's drive) year round. You would really want to find a winter activity to help you get through it, skiing, snow machines or ice fishing all help.
Not a bad place to live but it helps to check it out in person and doing so in the winter could be a real eye opener for you.