Warning

 

Close

Confirm Action

Are you sure you wish to do this?

Confirm Cancel
BCM
User Panel

Page / 6
You Must Be Logged In To Vote

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 5:53:11 PM EDT
[#1]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Deadtired:
1911, because it was the first to bring together all the elements of a modern pistol in an effective, ergonomic package.  
View Quote


Wouldn’t that be the 1911A1?
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 5:59:45 PM EDT
[#2]
S&W Sigma > Glock 17
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:24:51 PM EDT
[#3]
1911. It is the template that nearly all modern pistol designs are based on, and still possesses the best trigger of any handgun in history.

I would give my left nut to see what John Browning could do with modern design, material, and manufacturing technology.

The man hand-crafted prototype firearms in the 1800’s out of iron and wood with simple hand tools, and he still had a ludicrous number of design patents.

What could he do with CAD, CHF barrels, CNC machined 7075 aluminum, 3D printed polymers, and 3D laser sintered titanium?
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:26:17 PM EDT
[#4]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By DK-Prof:
I feel like a bunch of you are misunderstanding the question.  

There are only two choices.  
View Quote


We understand, understand that your pole has aids.





Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:27:15 PM EDT
[#5]
Of those two, the hi-power.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:28:05 PM EDT
[#6]
The one that is in your hand when you desperately need it.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:29:15 PM EDT
[#7]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By wakeboarder:
P210
View Quote



Actually FPNI.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:31:07 PM EDT
[#8]
Everybody knows the answer to this question, even if they don’t want to admit it.  

The 1911 isn’t perfect, but it’s pretty damn close.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:31:59 PM EDT
[#9]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History

I am having a very difficult time disagreeing with this.

But I am also enamored with my G35.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:32:01 PM EDT
[#10]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Herewego:
Which one of those had a design so perfect it has not been changed in over 100 years.
View Quote



You do know it was changed when they created the A1 model right? So it was in service from 1924-1985.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:35:50 PM EDT
[#11]
The 1911 made its mark in history no doubt about it. It may be the greatest but not the best. That goes to the Sig P-210 and its lineage.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:36:13 PM EDT
[#12]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By DK-Prof:
I feel like a bunch of you are misunderstanding the question.  

There are only two choices.  
View Quote

I post without reading.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:38:34 PM EDT
[#13]
1911 enough said.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:38:57 PM EDT
[#14]
The 1911 is a cult.

JMB's magnum opus is the Hi-Power.

The proof is in how every pistol today is a doublestack 9.

Not a single stack 45.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:39:57 PM EDT
[#15]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Mike_314:
It's an automatic AND a revolver!

Ha!  Beat that!
https://www.shootingillustrated.com/media/py2fwamv/webly.jpg
View Quote


And most importantly it looks cool as fuck.

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:43:40 PM EDT
[#16]
1. 1911
2. Walther p38
3. Glock
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:47:18 PM EDT
[#17]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By warkittens:
I could have been the Hi Power if it had the 1911 trigger. I like the feel of the BHP in hand but the 1911 trigger is the tits.
View Quote



For Me, the BHP was the most naturally pointing pistol I've ever owned.

But I HATED the safety.  You had to have fingers like a chipmunk to actuate it - what a shitty design.

Perfect you ask???  The Hi Power with the 1911 slide cut and safety, in 9mm - OMG.. Pertfect Pistol.  All that I could ever ask for.  

The "upgraded" BHP, with the same funky safety and an extended lever is still worthless in my eyes.

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:48:27 PM EDT
[#18]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By TheRealBluedog:


Both of the choices were great handguns.
View Quote


Both choices were adequate for the time they were designed.

They live on under the glow of their fanboys' rose colored glasses now.

There are far better choices today.  If the High Power and 1911 ceased to exist, I'd say "huh" and go about my day.

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:50:47 PM EDT
[#19]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Notcalifornialegal:
The 1911 is a cult.

JMB's magnum opus is the Hi-Power.

The proof is in how every pistol today is a doublestack 9.

Not a single stack 45.
View Quote


That wasn’t really his choice. The doublestack magazine was already created, and the requirements he was given pretty much required it

My hi power is neat, but my 1911s are way better
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:55:06 PM EDT
[#20]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Happy_Hour_Hero:


That wasn’t really his choice. The doublestack magazine was already created, and the requirements he was given pretty much required it

My hi power is neat, but my 1911s are way better
View Quote


If you knew you were about to get into a gunfight, but didn't know what kind and you were offered a hipower and a 1911, which one would you take?
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:56:12 PM EDT
[#21]
Colt 2000
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 6:57:22 PM EDT
[#22]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History

Do want.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:00:08 PM EDT
[#23]
It's both. JMB beget the 1911 and began work on the Hi Power with it's double-stack magazine.

Despite this allegedly being the "era of the striker-fired, semi-automatic handgun" we are almost daily seeing new versions of double-stack 1911-style guns.

Attachment Attached File




Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:00:58 PM EDT
[#24]
CZ75
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:02:43 PM EDT
[Last Edit: Kingdead] [#25]
The Hi-Power is cool, but on ratted out older guns, the trigger transfer bar being in the slide makes for a lot of wobble. When you take up the slack and the slide visibly moves, I don't like the design. I know it was done to get around Browning's patents with Colt, but I don't like it. I think he was handicapped because of it.

I've never seen the transfer bar itself be rattily, but the slide to frame fit can be a little lose. It just makes for a poor trigger feel and when you can watch the slide move upwards as you pull the trigger...


Also not a big fan of the press fit of the trigger pin. You have to be careful not to mar the frame when removing it.

Attachment Attached File

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:07:30 PM EDT
[#26]
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:08:23 PM EDT
[#27]
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:11:22 PM EDT
[#28]
Both were game changers but I’d say the 1911 had the bigger impact on pistol technology.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:14:25 PM EDT
[#29]
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:14:33 PM EDT
[#30]
Grande Puissance
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:15:19 PM EDT
[#31]
BHP
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:15:33 PM EDT
[#32]
1911. As it's action is the most copied.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:32:17 PM EDT
[#33]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By RocketmanOU:


@Sputnik556

First off, let's talk heritage. The 1911 is the battle-hardened granddaddy of all modern handguns. It’s been around longer than most of us have been alive, and it doesn’t need flashy new tricks or Italian aesthetics to make an impression. The Beretta 92? Sure, it's sleek, it's shiny, it’s the pistol your rich uncle brags about at Thanksgiving. But the 1911? That’s the pistol that your great-grandfather carried through two world wars and probably used to crack a Nazi’s skull when he ran out of ammo.

Speaking of ammo, can we please talk about the .45 ACP? The 1911 doesn’t mess around with those dainty 9mm rounds like the Beretta 92 does. If you want to scare someone with the sound of your weapon alone, rack that 1911 slide and let the .45 speak for itself. It’s like a sledgehammer compared to a butter knife. With the 1911, you don’t have to double-tap—because that sucker isn’t getting back up.

Reliability? The 1911 is like that old pickup truck that’s never been washed, but it’ll start every time and get the job done, no questions asked. The Beretta 92? Look, it might work fine at the range when it’s freshly cleaned and lubed, but good luck when it’s dirty, wet, or when you’ve got a little dust in the chamber. The 1911? It'll keep firing, come rain, mud, or Armageddon.

And let’s not even get started on the trigger. The 1911’s trigger pull is as smooth as a Sinatra ballad, while the Beretta 92’s double-action feels like pulling a piano up a hill. If you want precision, accuracy, and a trigger you’ll dream about at night, you go 1911. The Beretta’s trigger is decent, sure—if you enjoy second place.

Look, I get it, the Beretta has 15+ rounds in the mag, but that’s because you’re gonna need 15 rounds with that anemic 9mm. Meanwhile, with the 1911, you’ve got seven rounds of "I don't have time for your nonsense." Less is more when each shot feels like you’re firing mini-cannonballs.

In the end, the 1911 is the Clint Eastwood of pistols—old, grizzled, and not here for your modern excuses. The Beretta 92 is the equivalent of a Euro sports car: flashy, fancy, and a little too proud of itself. Sure, it’s nice on a Sunday drive, but when the chips are down and you need something dependable, you’ll be reaching for that good ol’ slab of American steel every time.

View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By RocketmanOU:
Originally Posted By Sputnik556:
92

Fight me


@Sputnik556

First off, let's talk heritage. The 1911 is the battle-hardened granddaddy of all modern handguns. It’s been around longer than most of us have been alive, and it doesn’t need flashy new tricks or Italian aesthetics to make an impression. The Beretta 92? Sure, it's sleek, it's shiny, it’s the pistol your rich uncle brags about at Thanksgiving. But the 1911? That’s the pistol that your great-grandfather carried through two world wars and probably used to crack a Nazi’s skull when he ran out of ammo.

Speaking of ammo, can we please talk about the .45 ACP? The 1911 doesn’t mess around with those dainty 9mm rounds like the Beretta 92 does. If you want to scare someone with the sound of your weapon alone, rack that 1911 slide and let the .45 speak for itself. It’s like a sledgehammer compared to a butter knife. With the 1911, you don’t have to double-tap—because that sucker isn’t getting back up.

Reliability? The 1911 is like that old pickup truck that’s never been washed, but it’ll start every time and get the job done, no questions asked. The Beretta 92? Look, it might work fine at the range when it’s freshly cleaned and lubed, but good luck when it’s dirty, wet, or when you’ve got a little dust in the chamber. The 1911? It'll keep firing, come rain, mud, or Armageddon.

And let’s not even get started on the trigger. The 1911’s trigger pull is as smooth as a Sinatra ballad, while the Beretta 92’s double-action feels like pulling a piano up a hill. If you want precision, accuracy, and a trigger you’ll dream about at night, you go 1911. The Beretta’s trigger is decent, sure—if you enjoy second place.

Look, I get it, the Beretta has 15+ rounds in the mag, but that’s because you’re gonna need 15 rounds with that anemic 9mm. Meanwhile, with the 1911, you’ve got seven rounds of "I don't have time for your nonsense." Less is more when each shot feels like you’re firing mini-cannonballs.

In the end, the 1911 is the Clint Eastwood of pistols—old, grizzled, and not here for your modern excuses. The Beretta 92 is the equivalent of a Euro sports car: flashy, fancy, and a little too proud of itself. Sure, it’s nice on a Sunday drive, but when the chips are down and you need something dependable, you’ll be reaching for that good ol’ slab of American steel every time.


Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:35:57 PM EDT
[#34]
Glock 17/19 is the greatest ever designed.

Not only did they create the game, it hasn't been or can be topped.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:36:39 PM EDT
[Last Edit: BisonWorld] [#35]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By TheRealBluedog:
Here we go again. Whenever you post a thread like this all you’re going to do is get a bunch of people nominating their favorite pistol.

Before we can even have this discussion, we have to agree on what “greatest” means. Greatest does not necessarily mean best. To me, greatest means the handgun design had the largest overall impact on subsequent handgun designs.  

Both of the choices were great handguns. There’s no doubt about that. But when it comes to great-est, there can only be one. That is the Glock 17. No I do not own one anymore, no it is not my favorite, and no it is not the best. But it is the greatest. Here’s why.

When the Glock 17 appeared on the market, there was nothing else like it. You HK fanboys can shut the fuck up. There was nothing like the Glock 17 when it appeared.

Within a few years, every single MAJOR manufacturer had introduced or was working on a compact polymer framed high capacity 9 mm semi automatic that was striker fired, with no external safeties. In other words, literally every major manufacturer came out with their version of the Glock. You can’t say that about the 1911, you can’t say that about the high-power, you can’t say that about any other handgun of modern times. One handgun came along and completely changed the handgun market. That was the Glock 17.
View Quote


About the only accuracy in this statement is every major manufacturer makes a composite framed striker fired pistol. Neither category  was novel on the release of the Glock 17 and if a detailed review is conducted mechanisms used in a Glock are some of the least copied in the industry outside of legitimate gen 3 compatible clone guns (which are typically only made by companies without the engineering bandwidth to develop a new product and instead slap lipstick on loosely “reverse engineered” pigs with new branding).

The only thing Glock really did was execute one of the greatest marketing and lobbying campaigns in the history of firearms which hasn’t been topped until very recently with sig. (who at least does attempt to push development at least somewhat in addition to their marketing and lobbying)

It’s a solid firearm which followed the principles of simple = best, and there are some actual novel systems in it that people rarely give credit to, but it’s a bit disingenuous to give it claim over polymer framed striker fired pistols wholesale.

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:43:02 PM EDT
[#36]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By maxima2:
This.

Serious.


View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By maxima2:
Originally Posted By Firestarter123:
Dan Wesson DWX

It combines the best attributes of the 1911 with the best attributes of the CZ75.

https://nextcloud.fstech.ltd/s/ZLqbsbF3EbGLNz3/preview
This.

Serious.




I’m sure as hell no Gaston or browning, but I do appreciate a fan.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 7:56:56 PM EDT
[#37]
A lot of historical inaccuracies in this thread…

Browning is only partially responsible for the hi power. The original browning designed gun is very much different than what we know today as a Hi Power.

Yes he had to avoid patent infringement on the hi power prototypes (which again are totally unlike a production
Hi Power). He died in 1926 and the 1911 patents expired in the late ‘20s.

Dieudonné Saive (of FAL fame), picked up the project and incorporated many of the (now expired) 1911 patents into the design. Saive is much more responsible for the BHP than browning.

The Browning nomenclature was tacked onto it because it sold extremely well (for obvious reasons).



I voted 1911 because it was the first handgun to set the standard for which every successful design has followed. The BHP is probably my favorite pistol of all time but the 1911 is truly the more influential gun. The fact that the 1911 patents had to expire to even finish the BHP design successfully is testament to this
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:03:07 PM EDT
[#38]
This is... difficult. I like them both. I own two of each, a vintage example and a modern one.

I like the Hi Power better as an actual handgun, but realize the 1911 is probably more historically significant.

Also the P210 is just an oversized/overbuilt PA Mle 1935A.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:10:05 PM EDT
[#39]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Kingdead:
The Hi-Power is cool, but on ratted out older guns, the trigger transfer bar being in the slide makes for a lot of wobble. When you take up the slack and the slide visibly moves, I don't like the design. I know it was done to get around Browning's patents with Colt, but I don't like it. I think he was handicapped because of it.

I've never seen the transfer bar itself be rattily, but the slide to frame fit can be a little lose. It just makes for a poor trigger feel and when you can watch the slide move upwards as you pull the trigger...


Also not a big fan of the press fit of the trigger pin. You have to be careful not to mar the frame when removing it.

https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/346870/hpppp_jpg-3319645.JPG
View Quote


…and it’s still 1000000000 times better than the Glock

LOL
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:21:32 PM EDT
[#40]
hurr durr still beating Hi-Power
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:21:59 PM EDT
[#41]
Any design that last over a 100 years and still produced by dozens of manufacturers, has to be pretty solid.

Small, medium and  large in single and double stack. 9mm, 45 acp, 10mm, 38 super and a couple others.

The 1911 has stood the test of time. It is the greatest handgun design ever.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:25:59 PM EDT
[#42]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By Useafortyfive:
II voted 1911 but It’s hard to argue with the simplicity of what Gaston Glock did.
View Quote

This is one of the biggest things, but only known to those who can and do take things completely apart, and put them back together.

GG really pared things down to the minimum and kept it simple, which is probably one of the biggest factors in their reliability.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:27:24 PM EDT
[#43]
How about a soulless Glock 17

Or a Kimber 1911?
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:29:18 PM EDT
[#44]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By TheRealBluedog:

Maybe you’re trying to be funny, but this overrated pistol sucked so bad, hardly anywhere made, it’s no longer in production, and even though the patents have long since expired, not even the turks will copy it. If it’s so great, why isn’t it in production? Pretty much every other gun being disgusting this thread is still in production.
View Quote View All Quotes
View All Quotes
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By TheRealBluedog:
Originally Posted By 1Bigdog:
P7M13

Maybe you’re trying to be funny, but this overrated pistol sucked so bad, hardly anywhere made, it’s no longer in production, and even though the patents have long since expired, not even the turks will copy it. If it’s so great, why isn’t it in production? Pretty much every other gun being disgusting this thread is still in production.

Talk-to-text really has a tough time if you speak too fast, and your words run together
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:34:05 PM EDT
[#45]
That cool one with the 4 barrels in .357.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:36:34 PM EDT
[#46]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By 47Under:
Glock 17
View Quote


Yes.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:37:55 PM EDT
[#47]
Hmmm, I'd say put me in the CZ75 camp.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:50:38 PM EDT
[#48]
Discussion ForumsJump to Quoted PostQuote History
Originally Posted By warkittens:
I could have been the Hi Power if it had the 1911 trigger. I like the feel of the BHP in hand but the 1911 trigger is the tits.
View Quote


Yea, a 1911 trigger on a Belgium high-power would have been something to behold! I'd go for that in a heartbeat.
Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:54:32 PM EDT
[#49]
For auto pistols, that argument could be made, since they've only been improved upon by capacity and materials.

The smokeless powder revolver would be my pick.

Link Posted: 9/11/2024 8:59:17 PM EDT
[#50]
Neither of those trash guns, Gaston Glock made the perfect handgun.
Page / 6
Close Join Our Mail List to Stay Up To Date! Win a FREE Membership!

Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!

You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.


By signing up you agree to our User Agreement. *Must have a registered ARFCOM account to win.
Top Top