User Panel
Ned does a great job. He's also a member of the American Pistolsmith's Guild and makes some fancy 1911's. He use to shoot highpower at my local club and went to Camp Perry National Championships with us one year. Stand up guy who knows his machining.
|
|
Not to hijack, but I have an RRA coming and I've just now starting hearing/reading about the staking the BCG. Can someone give a quick summary of what this is and why it needs to be done?
|
|
Am sure it's a super great tool. But unless someone was staking thousands of AR bolt carrier key Allen head bolts it's really unneeded as a few good hard wacks with a sharp tool will get the job done for the average putter together builder.
|
|
I prefer the Pocket Moaks for price and ability to counter stake. It is also cheaper and fits nicely in my AR tool/parts bins. The only issue that I have had is a little over staking, but everyone says you can't really over stake.
|
|
Overkill in tools is good. In rifles. In fly reels. In staking tools. I like it. Thanks for posting the pics.
|
|
I have the original MOACKS. Love it!
The carrier carbon scraper is also the best I've tried so far; I've had large flakes of carbon fall out after scraping the back of the carrier where the bolt tail goes. |
|
Quoted:
Not to hijack, but I have an RRA coming and I've just now starting hearing/reading about the staking the BCG. Can someone give a quick summary of what this is and why it needs to be done? 'Staking' is a process where fore is used to deform a metal part - in other words, metal from one part is pushed out of its original shape, so that it pushes against another part. AR parts that can be staked include the carrier key and the castle nut on a carbine buffer tube. For the carrier key, staking is the only way to ensure that the screws will never come loose. Simply, you push metal from the key onto the screw heads, making a mechanical lock that won't be broken by normal shooting, but can still be broken with a wrench if needed. If the carrier key is not staked, the screws (which are put under lots of heat and pressure) can work loose, causing gas leaks that will stop your AR from cycling. |
|
Quoted: Quoted: Not to hijack, but I have an RRA coming and I've just now starting hearing/reading about the staking the BCG. Can someone give a quick summary of what this is and why it needs to be done? 'Staking' is a process where fore is used to deform a metal part - in other words, metal from one part is pushed out of its original shape, so that it pushes against another part. AR parts that can be staked include the carrier key and the castle nut on a carbine buffer tube. For the carrier key, staking is the only way to ensure that the screws will never come loose. Simply, you push metal from the key onto the screw heads, making a mechanical lock that won't be broken by normal shooting, but can still be broken with a wrench if needed. If the carrier key is not staked, the screws (which are put under lots of heat and pressure) can work loose, causing gas leaks that will stop your AR from cycling. Great info. Thanks for the concise reply. |
|
That original stake job would have worked just fine. It had displaced enough material to not allow the bolts to loosen. Some people think you have to get material over the bolt head, which is not the case..
However, better safe than sorry. Very nice pics. and write up. |
|
Nice write up. That thing looks like it does a great job, I just balk at the price. For a guy with only a few ARs, there isn't much point in it.
However, if I were going to be doing armorer work on ARs, I wouldn't hesitate to pick one up. |
|
Yeah the tool is a little on the expensive side but I had the extra money so I thought what the heck. I'm not disappointed at all with the purchase and I'm sure it will last me the rest of my life. With all the extra features it has, it was worth it. I'm sure a few people will come a long that needs a staking job and I won't hesitate to help them out. Thanks guys for reading my thread.
|
|
I just don't understand why the Mfg. have not made the change to the space age threading systems that lock tight without the deforming process of staking. This space age system has been around for over 20 years it's not something brand new.
|
|
Excellent tool! Hammer and chisel work great until you snap a screw head off...
|
|
Quoted:
I just don't understand why the Mfg. have not made the change to the space age threading systems that lock tight without the deforming process of staking. This space age system has been around for over 20 years it's not something brand new. They're doing us a favor by not doing that. What are we going to do if we can't sit around and gripe about gas key staking? Parkerizing under the FSB doesn't seem like a subject that will give us as much time wasting glee. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
I just don't understand why the Mfg. have not made the change to the space age threading systems that lock tight without the deforming process of staking. This space age system has been around for over 20 years it's not something brand new. They're doing us a favor by not doing that. What are we going to do if we can't sit around and gripe about gas key staking? Parkerizing under the FSB doesn't seem like a subject that will give us as much time wasting glee. But we always have MPI testing.... Seriously though, I used to work in a machine shop (5 yrs.) buiding tooling. All we did or needed to do was make a couple divits near the bolt with a center punch. They withstood several thousand strokes every day with 10's of thousands pounds of pressure put on them. It doesn't take a whole lot to achive a "locking" stake. |
|
Quoted:
That original stake job would have worked just fine. It had displaced enough material to not allow the bolts to loosen. Some people think you have to get material over the bolt head, which is not the case.. However, better safe than sorry. Very nice pics. and write up. Actually it was a poor attempt at a staking job and from the looks of that piss poor job I'm sure it would have shot loose. I have seen other BCG staked a little more than that come loose. I know this from the couple of hundred or so that I have staked that were loose. YMMV..... |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
That original stake job would have worked just fine. It had displaced enough material to not allow the bolts to loosen. Some people think you have to get material over the bolt head, which is not the case.. However, better safe than sorry. Very nice pics. and write up. Actually it was a poor attempt at a staking job and from the looks of that piss poor job I'm sure it would have shot loose. I have seen other BCG staked a little more than that come loose. I know this from the couple of hundred or so that I have staked that were loose. YMMV..... You have bumped your head... |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
That original stake job would have worked just fine. It had displaced enough material to not allow the bolts to loosen. Some people think you have to get material over the bolt head, which is not the case.. However, better safe than sorry. Very nice pics. and write up. Actually it was a poor attempt at a staking job and from the looks of that piss poor job I'm sure it would have shot loose. I have seen other BCG staked a little more than that come loose. I know this from the couple of hundred or so that I have staked that were loose. YMMV..... You have bumped your head... No actually I have not..... |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
That original stake job would have worked just fine. It had displaced enough material to not allow the bolts to loosen. Some people think you have to get material over the bolt head, which is not the case.. However, better safe than sorry. Very nice pics. and write up. Actually it was a poor attempt at a staking job and from the looks of that piss poor job I'm sure it would have shot loose. I have seen other BCG staked a little more than that come loose. I know this from the couple of hundred or so that I have staked that were loose. YMMV..... You have bumped your head... No actually I have not..... Maybe you should then........Just to be a sport, I will take my 100% new RRA BCG that has lighter staking than that and run it throough the grinder..I will get pics up shortly, and then post after a few thousand.. Are you willing to bet money? |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
That original stake job would have worked just fine. It had displaced enough material to not allow the bolts to loosen. Some people think you have to get material over the bolt head, which is not the case.. However, better safe than sorry. Very nice pics. and write up. Actually it was a poor attempt at a staking job and from the looks of that piss poor job I'm sure it would have shot loose. I have seen other BCG staked a little more than that come loose. I know this from the couple of hundred or so that I have staked that were loose. YMMV..... You have bumped your head... No actually I have not..... Maybe you should then...... Why because a full time gun plumber disagrees with you. |
|
Has nothing to do with disagreeing, only experience...I do not take the word of a self professed "gun plumber" worth a toss.
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
I prefer the Pocket Moacks for price and ability to counter stake. It is also cheaper and fits nicely in my AR tool/parts bins. The only issue that I have had is a little over staking, but everyone says you can't really over stake. +1 for Pocket Moaks tool. If you use 1 turn instead of the 1&1/4 turn you will displace more than enough metal to secure the gas key. If all you are looking to do is stake your gas key, the Pocket Moacks tool does a great job at a much lower cost. http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x266/k9-bob/14884602911.jpg It's $85.00 shipped and worth every penny. Hammer that I have = $0 Punch that I have = $0 Perfect stake job = $0 I know which I prefer. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I prefer the Pocket Moacks for price and ability to counter stake. It is also cheaper and fits nicely in my AR tool/parts bins. The only issue that I have had is a little over staking, but everyone says you can't really over stake. +1 for Pocket Moaks tool. If you use 1 turn instead of the 1&1/4 turn you will displace more than enough metal to secure the gas key. If all you are looking to do is stake your gas key, the Pocket Moacks tool does a great job at a much lower cost. http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x266/k9-bob/14884602911.jpg It's $85.00 shipped and worth every penny. Hammer that I have = $0 Punch that I have = $0 Perfect stake job = $0 I know which I prefer. Please post a pic of your perfection so we can compare. |
|
Quoted:
Hammer that I have = $0 Punch that I have = $0 Perfect stake job = $0 I know which I prefer. |
|
|
Quoted:
Has nothing to do with disagreeing, only experience...I do not take the word of a self professed "gun plumber" worth a toss. Not self professed gun plumber. Actually I'm a full time armorer/chief firearms instructor for a very large LE agency which has patrol rifles. The gas key bolts on those rifles were poorly staked from the factory, some very similiar to the OP's picture. Most of them came loose during training, so there comes my experience. So I have seen what it takes to keep these bolts from moving on a gas key not on a piece of machinery in a shop. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I prefer the Pocket Moacks for price and ability to counter stake. It is also cheaper and fits nicely in my AR tool/parts bins. The only issue that I have had is a little over staking, but everyone says you can't really over stake. +1 for Pocket Moaks tool. If you use 1 turn instead of the 1&1/4 turn you will displace more than enough metal to secure the gas key. If all you are looking to do is stake your gas key, the Pocket Moacks tool does a great job at a much lower cost. http://i185.photobucket.com/albums/x266/k9-bob/14884602911.jpg It's $85.00 shipped and worth every penny. Hammer that I have = $0 Punch that I have = $0 Perfect stake job = $0 I know which I prefer. Please post a pic of your perfection so we can compare. Quib has posted it in this thread already. See 2 posts above.... Good enough for you? |
|
Quoted:
Quib has posted it twice in this thread already. Did I? I loose track.............. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quib has posted it twice in this thread already. Did I? I loose track.............. No, I was wrong...You posted it in another thread tonight. Only once here....... |
|
Quoted:
No, I was wrong...You posted it in another thread tonight. Only once here....... Ok, I’m glad you “got the controls”. I’m one of those guys who at lunch, forgot what he ate for breakfast. I blame it on Gulf War Syndrome. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
No, I was wrong...You posted it in another thread tonight. Only once here....... Ok, I’m glad you “got the controls”. I’m one of those guys who at lunch, forgot what he ate for breakfast. I blame it on Gulf War Syndrome. I'm givin her all she's got captain......Oh crap, we hit the ground.......DO NOT GIVE ME THE CONTROLS.......... |
|
I got the pocket MOACKS and let me just say how simple it was to steak my 2 bolt keys..... this is sweet. worth the $85 and took all of 5 mins to do
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.