User Panel
Quoted:
I've always envisioned Roland's pistols as being Colt Walkers. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I don't think the revolvers design has to be based on anything from our universe. Actually I think I'd like it better if it was a bit different. I know the sandalwood grips aren't from this planet, anyway. http://m9.i.pbase.com/g1/64/521964/2/126358509.RGTVCGDl.jpg Oily, sticky, resinous wood known and prized almost exclusively for its aromatic qualities. Due to it's demand in the ME for religious reasons (incense), almost impossible to acquire in large enough quantity to make grips from...(as a huge dork, I tried several years ago to craft my own Big Guns using Vaqueros). I've always envisioned Roland's pistols as being Colt Walkers. LOL...me too, but I don't have Walkers, or Walker money. |
|
|
|
|
what the hell is dark tower? is that a remake of that movie from the 80s with muppets? what kind of muppet is idris going to play the main character?
|
|
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book?
|
|
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? View Quote Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. |
|
|
Quoted:
Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. I guess as I've assessed TDT movie possibilities, it never occurred to me that Detta Walker's racist rants would make it into the film. Just like I never once considered the 12 year old gang-bang in IT would get buttoned into the film. There's stuff that you can't do in film (and I'm not sure the kiddos fuckin' ought to have made it into the IT book anyway, ewwww). There's nothing wrong with casting a man of a different race here, it seems to me. Remember that "Red" in Shawshank Redemption was supposed to be an Irishman and the movie turned out amazing in part because of the change to Morgan Freeman. What's more disappointing to me is casting a hot blonde actress for an obese low woman rat character that has appearances on two pages of book 6 and maybe one page of book 7 as a "lead" in this film. Stephen King was a lot better when he was a wet brain. Its a thing with writers, sometimes they're better on the sauce. Now King is all political, and wants to be anti-gun even though he INVENTED school shootings. (Ref: Rage, 1977). The last incarnation of the "lets do the dark tower" idea was killed and he decided he could get it made by turning it into something different. I hope this one winds up in development hell, and that they go back to the drawing board and come back and use MY idea here as a mix of HBO miniseries and two movies (movies: the flashback to mejis, the wolves of the calla and the battle of Blue Heaven and final push to the tower). https://www.ar15.com/archive/topic.html?b=1&f=5&t=1364109 |
|
Quoted:
http://www.ew.com/article/2016/02/29/dark-tower-rises-stephen-king-idris-elba-and-matthew-mcconaughey Now I'm going to have to reread a few of them picturing Idris as Roland. I always had a young Clint Eastwood in my mind. I would have never pictured Matthew McConaughey as the man in black. Two great actors, I'm betting it's going to be awesome. What revolver do you picture in your mind with you think of Roland? View Quote I pictured a break top like the Schofield or a Webley in .45. |
|
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? View Quote because King described Roland as a white guy with blue eyes, and one of the main characters tried to kill him because he was white.. I mean there were black Gunslingers in the books. Roland was a white guy. I dont think it really matters tho. the books sucked past the first one. |
|
|
Quoted:
Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. I had actually forgotten about all of the racial Detta Walker stuff. Honestly that could all be left out without hurting my feelings. |
|
Quoted: because King described Roland as a white guy with blue eyes, and one of the main characters tried to kill him because he was white.. I mean there were black Gunslingers in the books. Roland was a white guy. I dont think it really matters tho. the books sucked past the first one. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? because King described Roland as a white guy with blue eyes, and one of the main characters tried to kill him because he was white.. I mean there were black Gunslingers in the books. Roland was a white guy. I dont think it really matters tho. the books sucked past the first one. I liked them until the third. After that it was basically King sucking himself off. |
|
|
Quoted:
I guess as I've assessed TDT movie possibilities, it never occurred to me that Detta Walker's racist rants would make it into the film. Just like I never once considered the 12 year old gang-bang in IT would get buttoned into the film. There's stuff that you can't do in film (and I'm not sure the kiddos fuckin' ought to have made it into the IT book anyway, ewwww). There's nothing wrong with casting a man of a different race here, it seems to me. Remember that "Red" in Shawshank Redemption was supposed to be an Irishman and the movie turned out amazing in part because of the change to Morgan Freeman. What's more disappointing to me is casting a hot blonde actress for an obese low woman rat character that has appearances on two pages of book 6 and maybe one page of book 7 as a "lead" in this film. Stephen King was a lot better when he was a wet brain. Its a thing with writers, sometimes they're better on the sauce. Now King is all political, and wants to be anti-gun even though he INVENTED school shootings. (Ref: Rage, 1977). The last incarnation of the "lets do the dark tower" idea was killed and he decided he could get it made by turning it into something different. I hope this one winds up in development hell, and that they go back to the drawing board and come back and use MY idea here as a mix of HBO miniseries and two movies (movies: the flashback to mejis, the wolves of the calla and the battle of Blue Heaven and final push to the tower). https://www.ar15.com/archive/topic.html?b=1&f=5&t=1364109 View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. I guess as I've assessed TDT movie possibilities, it never occurred to me that Detta Walker's racist rants would make it into the film. Just like I never once considered the 12 year old gang-bang in IT would get buttoned into the film. There's stuff that you can't do in film (and I'm not sure the kiddos fuckin' ought to have made it into the IT book anyway, ewwww). There's nothing wrong with casting a man of a different race here, it seems to me. Remember that "Red" in Shawshank Redemption was supposed to be an Irishman and the movie turned out amazing in part because of the change to Morgan Freeman. What's more disappointing to me is casting a hot blonde actress for an obese low woman rat character that has appearances on two pages of book 6 and maybe one page of book 7 as a "lead" in this film. Stephen King was a lot better when he was a wet brain. Its a thing with writers, sometimes they're better on the sauce. Now King is all political, and wants to be anti-gun even though he INVENTED school shootings. (Ref: Rage, 1977). The last incarnation of the "lets do the dark tower" idea was killed and he decided he could get it made by turning it into something different. I hope this one winds up in development hell, and that they go back to the drawing board and come back and use MY idea here as a mix of HBO miniseries and two movies (movies: the flashback to mejis, the wolves of the calla and the battle of Blue Heaven and final push to the tower). https://www.ar15.com/archive/topic.html?b=1&f=5&t=1364109 For what it is worth, I did the same as you, outlined the same books, with the horn. |
|
Quoted:
I hadn't thought about Josh Brolin - at 5'10" he seems too short to me though. One thing that gets me is King always wrote about roland's blue eyes faded by the desert. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
There are only two actors I know of that would play a good Roland. Josh Brolin and Benicio Del Toro. I hadn't thought about Josh Brolin - at 5'10" he seems too short to me though. One thing that gets me is King always wrote about roland's blue eyes faded by the desert. You know, you could still do that! A black guy with blue or grey eyes would be kinda cool. Isn't he the last of a whole different world? |
|
Quoted:
I liked them until the third. After that it was basically King sucking himself off. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? because King described Roland as a white guy with blue eyes, and one of the main characters tried to kill him because he was white.. I mean there were black Gunslingers in the books. Roland was a white guy. I dont think it really matters tho. the books sucked past the first one. I liked them until the third. After that it was basically King sucking himself off. you read the first book that came out in the 1970s. It is dark and brilliant. It had some soul and depth and a unique ethos, pathos and logos that is jarring and compelling. The second book just doesn't have the same essence of raw surrealism, or the same depth. I mean by the fourth book he is just ripping off the wizard of Oz for half his plot line, and then he writes himself into it so he can sell his career catalog, in a shitty and shallow way. just my opinion. |
|
Quoted: you read the first book that came out in the 1970s. It is dark and brilliant. It had some soul. The second book just doesn't have the same essence of raw surrealism. I mean by the fourth book he is just ripping off the wizard of Oz for half his plot line, and then he writes himself into it so he can sell his career catalog, in a shitty and shallow way. just my opinion. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? because King described Roland as a white guy with blue eyes, and one of the main characters tried to kill him because he was white.. I mean there were black Gunslingers in the books. Roland was a white guy. I dont think it really matters tho. the books sucked past the first one. I liked them until the third. After that it was basically King sucking himself off. you read the first book that came out in the 1970s. It is dark and brilliant. It had some soul. The second book just doesn't have the same essence of raw surrealism. I mean by the fourth book he is just ripping off the wizard of Oz for half his plot line, and then he writes himself into it so he can sell his career catalog, in a shitty and shallow way. just my opinion. Oh yeah, I read the first book in its unaltered form. Probably the best thing he has ever written and definitely different, almost poetic. The 2nd and third were still good IMO, but more like a standard sifi/fantasy in tone. I hate how he tried to tie all of his other works into for no fucking reason, and how he wrote himself in (it would have been 100 times better if he had just written it as himself in a wink wink way with a different name and not a "hey this is like literally me you faggots".) |
|
Quoted:
I had actually forgotten about all of the racial Detta Walker stuff. Honestly that could all be left out without hurting my feelings. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. I had actually forgotten about all of the racial Detta Walker stuff. Honestly that could all be left out without hurting my feelings. Well, of course it could! No need for all that nastiness! |
|
Quoted:
Oh yeah, I read the first book in its unaltered form. Probably the best thing he has ever written and definitely different, almost poetic. The 2nd and third were still good IMO, but more like a standard sifi/fantasy in tone. I hate how he tried to tie all of his other works into for no fucking reason, and how he wrote himself in (it would have been 100 times better if he had just written it as himself in a wink wink way with a different name and not a "hey this is like literally me you faggots".) View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? because King described Roland as a white guy with blue eyes, and one of the main characters tried to kill him because he was white.. I mean there were black Gunslingers in the books. Roland was a white guy. I dont think it really matters tho. the books sucked past the first one. I liked them until the third. After that it was basically King sucking himself off. you read the first book that came out in the 1970s. It is dark and brilliant. It had some soul. The second book just doesn't have the same essence of raw surrealism. I mean by the fourth book he is just ripping off the wizard of Oz for half his plot line, and then he writes himself into it so he can sell his career catalog, in a shitty and shallow way. just my opinion. Oh yeah, I read the first book in its unaltered form. Probably the best thing he has ever written and definitely different, almost poetic. The 2nd and third were still good IMO, but more like a standard sifi/fantasy in tone. I hate how he tried to tie all of his other works into for no fucking reason, and how he wrote himself in (it would have been 100 times better if he had just written it as himself in a wink wink way with a different name and not a "hey this is like literally me you faggots".) I agree with everything you have said. Reading the first book, you can see that King poured his own spirit into the creation. He made a personal investment into what he was writing. |
|
|
Quoted:
Well, of course it could! No need for all that nastiness! View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. I had actually forgotten about all of the racial Detta Walker stuff. Honestly that could all be left out without hurting my feelings. Well, of course it could! No need for all that nastiness! It has nothing to do with it being "nasty". I just don't think it would take anything away from the story if they removed it. You know they're going to leave shit out in order to cram 8 rather long books into 3 movies, and I'd rather them leave that out than something that actually matters. |
|
|
Quoted:
It has nothing to do with it being "nasty". I just don't think it would take anything away from the story if they removed it. You know they're going to leave shit out in order to cram 8 rather long books into 3 movies, and I'd rather them leave that out than something that actually matters. View Quote IMO, it would. The creation of their ka-tet is almost the entire story. The difficulties Susannah (detta) had becoming a part of their ka-tet (and who she was as a person growing up during the civil rights movement) is not something you should just leave out, so you can have a black actor. I've got no issue with Elba. He is a good actor and will probably make a good Roland. It just won't be the Roland that was on a quest for the dark tower. It will be some other Roland from some other world. |
|
Quoted:
http://www.sitemason.com/files/ks8pQ4/VMP3bxl.jpg ...... Or maybe this one: http://www.cartertown.com/Guns/Remington1875Army.jpg View Quote Bingo. Straight out of my mind's eye. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
http://www.sitemason.com/files/ks8pQ4/VMP3bxl.jpg ...... Or maybe this one: http://www.cartertown.com/Guns/Remington1875Army.jpg Bingo. Straight out of my mind's eye. except Rolands guns had swinging cylinders. |
|
Quoted:
except Rolands guns had swinging cylinders. View Quote In one book, and then loading gates in the next. And I think in Book 4 (or 5??) they actually have BOTH and get reloaded using BOTH methods at different points. It's obvious that King isn't a gun expert, and hasn't watched enough Westerns either. |
|
Quoted:
In one book, and then loading gates in the next. And I think in Book 4 (or 5??) they actually have BOTH and get reloaded using BOTH methods at different points. It's obvious that King isn't a gun expert, and hasn't watched enough Westerns either. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
except Rolands guns had swinging cylinders. In one book, and then loading gates in the next. And I think in Book 4 (or 5??) they actually have BOTH and get reloaded using BOTH methods at different points. It's obvious that King isn't a gun expert, and hasn't watched enough Westerns either. He also talks about "thumbing the triggers" or something like that at one point IIRC. A lot of his firearms terminology was screwed up, but I enjoyed the story enough that I didn't care. |
|
Quoted:
Sorry, as much as I like Idris Elba as an actor having him play Roland is horrible. I also don't believe they can do the story justice in a single movie, a trilogy would even be pushing it. The Dark Tower series was one of my favorite series of all time, the ending was pretty retarded though. View Quote The ending was shit. |
|
|
Quoted:
I was picturing Whoopi as a double amputee and giggling my ass off. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Damn it, they're going to turn it into Blazing Saddles I saw it as a season of TV per 2 books. It's going to take a dedicated actor for the Lobstrosity scene losing the fingers. Hell, Daniel Craig could pull it off. He's a little short maybe, but he's got the eyes. Complaining about casting a black guy as Roland isn't racist, not in the slightest. Major, as in multiple books, dealt with the fact that Roland was white. If you make Roland black, you have to make Eddie black, Jake black, and Susannah into a white woman that hates black people. Essentially, you need to make nearly every character into the book black, except Susannah. Nothing else would even make sense. I was picturing Whoopi as a double amputee and giggling my ass off. I actually think she would nail that role |
|
|
|
Quoted:
I had actually forgotten about all of the racial Detta Walker stuff. Honestly that could all be left out without hurting my feelings. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It's been along time since I've read any of the Dark Tower books but I don't recall King ever saying saying that Roland was a certain race/color. So why does it matter the color of the actor playing a made up character from a book? Again, Detta Walker refers to him as white when he comes into her mind. She senses a white presence inside her head. On the beach she refers to Roland and Eddie as "Honky Mahfahs". A black man is not a honky. I had actually forgotten about all of the racial Detta Walker stuff. Honestly that could all be left out without hurting my feelings. I'm sure 90% of everything will be left out. As is par for the course in every one of his film adaptations. Also why all but one or two have been utter crap. |
|
Quoted:
You know, you could still do that! A black guy with blue or grey eyes would be kinda cool. Isn't he the last of a whole different world? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
There are only two actors I know of that would play a good Roland. Josh Brolin and Benicio Del Toro. I hadn't thought about Josh Brolin - at 5'10" he seems too short to me though. One thing that gets me is King always wrote about roland's blue eyes faded by the desert. You know, you could still do that! A black guy with blue or grey eyes would be kinda cool. Isn't he the last of a whole different world? He's worn color contacts in roles before, I believe. Was it the second Ghost Rider? |
|
Quoted: Whats wrong with Idris Elba, dude is a badass actor? Are you limpdicks really that butthurt that a black guy is cast in a movie based on a book where the character was white? It has no bearing on the plot whatsoever, it literally doesn't matter what color the dudes skin is. The guy that wrote the fucking story had a hand in the casting for fucks sake. View Quote It makes as much sense as casting a red headed Irish guy to play Alladin. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.