User Panel
Quoted:
Quoted:
... she did let me play the Imperial Death March in the delivery room when our son was being born... To be fair, she wasn't in much of a position to put up any resistance. And it did seem fitting that our boy would enter the world with appropriate musical accompaniment. For the first year of his life, that track always calmed him down and made him smile. Now he demands Hank Williams Jr.'s "Country Boy Can Survive" as bedtime music. At least he already knows the answer to 9mm vs. 45 ACP. |
|
Quoted:
Based on that theory Click To View Spoiler Yoda could have saved a ton of training time and effort by doing a force mind meld. . View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Based on that theory Click To View Spoiler Yoda could have saved a ton of training time and effort by doing a force mind meld. . Click To View Spoiler IIRC, in the old NPR radio dramatization, Ben did exactly that to jumpstart Luke's training. That was when they were aboard the Falcon heading to Alderaan. So, that isn't exactly a new concept.
|
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler IIRC, in the old NPR radio dramatization, Ben did exactly that to jumpstart Luke's training. That was when they were aboard the Falcon heading to Alderaan. So, that isn't exactly a new concept.
View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Based on that theory Click To View Spoiler Yoda could have saved a ton of training time and effort by doing a force mind meld. . Click To View Spoiler IIRC, in the old NPR radio dramatization, Ben did exactly that to jumpstart Luke's training. That was when they were aboard the Falcon heading to Alderaan. So, that isn't exactly a new concept.
If NPR had something to do with Luke's training, I suddenly understand why so many things went wrong in the original trilogy. Poor kid was from a backwoods world and didn't know better than to listen to the liberal radio propaganda network? |
|
|
Quoted:
Based on that theory Click To View Spoiler Yoda could have saved a ton of training time and effort by doing a force mind meld. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Based on that theory Click To View Spoiler Yoda could have saved a ton of training time and effort by doing a force mind meld. Click To View Spoiler New Force powers, new bad guys (read: not Sith clan)... new things afoot. Imho.
|
|
Quoted: Click To View Spoiler I don't think they're impossible coincidences. I think that Rey has some major force action going on, maybe even more powerful than Luke considering how quickly she's picking up on everything. I think that someone, maybe Luke, could see that she was special and hid her on Jakku after Kylo flipped his shit. I think that the coincidences are a puzzle laid out by Luke so someone strong with the force could find him. In her vision, we see her crying for her family as someone is dragging her away so maybe she was taken by the First Order and was rescued at some point. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Click To View Spoiler I don't think they're impossible coincidences. I think that Rey has some major force action going on, maybe even more powerful than Luke considering how quickly she's picking up on everything. I think that someone, maybe Luke, could see that she was special and hid her on Jakku after Kylo flipped his shit. I think that the coincidences are a puzzle laid out by Luke so someone strong with the force could find him. In her vision, we see her crying for her family as someone is dragging her away so maybe she was taken by the First Order and was rescued at some point. I just got out of the theater and heard the voice talking to the little girl in Kylo's voice. I was expecting her to be revealed as Kylo's cousin or sister or some such shit. I'm thinking she will be some sort of Skywalker. |
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" |
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" Hmmmmmmmmmm |
|
|
Quoted:
Makes sense considering the 'silver' storm trooper if ya follow my drift View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
My take, besides that I loved it Click To View Spoiler When it came to why Rey was on Jakku, I think that her family left her there when she was a child to protect her from the New Order. One of the New Order generals said that they target young kids for their storm trooper program, instead of using clones. When they pull up Fin's records after he defects you see a picture of him when he was a child, most likely when he was first taken from his family. So my guess is that his family didn't know that the First Order were taking children from families to build an army, but Rey's did.
my .02 Makes sense considering the 'silver' storm trooper if ya follow my drift There was another one on the star killer base that spoke to one of the officers. . |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Harrison Ford was paid 56 times more than the new people. 25 million while John Boyega got 450,000 I'd have taken 450k to do that gig. Hell, you can do 50 years worth of comic-cons and live comfortably. |
|
Quoted: Hell, you can do 50 years worth of comic-cons and live comfortably. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Harrison Ford was paid 56 times more than the new people. 25 million while John Boyega got 450,000 I'd have taken 450k to do that gig. Hell, you can do 50 years worth of comic-cons and live comfortably. |
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" Also in ESB. They had an entire mind conversation. |
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler My guess is, It awakened in Rey, and at the very end it was reawakening in Luke - he had hidden from it for years, but now was about to begin teaching again. It was also awakening on the dark side - a new dark apprentice, and a new dark lord, where for 30 years there had been none. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Just saw it and I have one question, Click To View Spoiler At what point in the movie did the force awaken? I remember Kylo saying he "felt it", but I can't remember if that was before or after Rey discovered the saber. For some odd reason I'm thinking he felt the shift prior to that. Click To View Spoiler My guess is, It awakened in Rey, and at the very end it was reawakening in Luke - he had hidden from it for years, but now was about to begin teaching again. It was also awakening on the dark side - a new dark apprentice, and a new dark lord, where for 30 years there had been none. I think your last part is the correct answer. |
|
Quoted: Click To View Spoiler The Force in Rey was awakening throughout the whole movie. She just kept getting lucky until she realized it wasn't just chance. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Just saw it and I have one question, Click To View Spoiler At what point in the movie did the force awaken? I remember Kylo saying he "felt it", but I can't remember if that was before or after Rey discovered the saber. For some odd reason I'm thinking he felt the shift prior to that. Click To View Spoiler The Force in Rey was awakening throughout the whole movie. She just kept getting lucky until she realized it wasn't just chance. Click To View Spoiler Other than getting lucky, and having glimpses into the Force (resisting Kylo Ren during the interrogation, snatching the light saber from Ren in the forest), I believe Rey *got it* when Her and Kylo locked sabers in the forest. She closed her eyes for a moment, then kicked his ass to a victory. Prior to that moment it was a fairly even saber brawl, but somewhat in Kylo's favor. That's what I got out of it, at least... |
|
Quoted:
I caught myself putting my hand up in front of my face when one of the explosions threw dirt toward the audience. I think I only noticed one or two "for the 3D" effects. One only because of how truly awesome it was. Tickets for Wednesday Imax are laying in front of me View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
It was even better watching it a second time. Saw it on a normal screen...friend is telling me I have to go see it in 3D because it was really good. I caught myself putting my hand up in front of my face when one of the explosions threw dirt toward the audience. I think I only noticed one or two "for the 3D" effects. One only because of how truly awesome it was. Tickets for Wednesday Imax are laying in front of me This was the best 3d movie I've seen. I saw both Avengers in 3d and to be honest, it felt like the 3d distracted you from seeing details other then what was being shoved in your face in 3d. I didn't get that feeling at all with TFA. |
|
Saw it with the mancub.
It was fun and had the feel of the original trilogy. Loved it |
|
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Harrison Ford was paid 56 times more than the new people. 25 million while John Boyega got 450,000 I'd have taken 450k to do that gig. I'd have done it for free Hell, I would have been a random Storm Trooper in a helmet in formation for free |
|
|
Quoted: Hell, I would have been a random Storm Trooper in a helmet in formation for free View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Harrison Ford was paid 56 times more than the new people. 25 million while John Boyega got 450,000 I'd have taken 450k to do that gig. I'd have done it for free Hell, I would have been a random Storm Trooper in a helmet in formation for free Same here. |
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler I don't think they're impossible coincidences. I think that Rey has some major force action going on, maybe even more powerful than Luke considering how quickly she's picking up on everything. I think that someone, maybe Luke, could see that she was special and hid her on Jakku after Kylo flipped his shit. I think that the coincidences are a puzzle laid out by Luke so someone strong with the force could find him. In her vision, we see her crying for her family as someone is dragging her away so maybe she was taken by the First Order and was rescued at some point.
View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Just saw it and I have one question, Click To View Spoiler At what point in the movie did the force awaken? I remember Kylo saying he "felt it", but I can't remember if that was before or after Rey discovered the saber. For some odd reason I'm thinking he felt the shift prior to that. Click To View Spoiler My guess is, It awakened in Rey, and at the very end it was reawakening in Luke - he had hidden from it for years, but now was about to begin teaching again. It was also awakening on the dark side - a new dark apprentice, and a new dark lord, where for 30 years there had been none. Click To View Spoiler I don't think Luke was hiding from it, I think Luke was studying it, perhaps even with the help of the force ghosts. My vision for episode 9 movie would be similar to the final act of Interstellar, with many of the impossible coincidences of this episode 7 being explained. Click To View Spoiler I don't think they're impossible coincidences. I think that Rey has some major force action going on, maybe even more powerful than Luke considering how quickly she's picking up on everything. I think that someone, maybe Luke, could see that she was special and hid her on Jakku after Kylo flipped his shit. I think that the coincidences are a puzzle laid out by Luke so someone strong with the force could find him. In her vision, we see her crying for her family as someone is dragging her away so maybe she was taken by the First Order and was rescued at some point.
Exactly. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
I liked the Daniel Craig storm trooper bit. Everyone knows Bond is weak minded. I've been avoiding most of the internet until seeing the movie today. I had no idea that was him when I watched it, but definitely thought the voice sounded familiar. |
|
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter.
The signs other than her force sensitivity: 1. Maz saying to Rey "that was Luke Skywalker's light saber and his fathers before him. Now it calls to you." 2. Luke looked like he was standing over a grave marked by a stone that blended in very well with the other rocks. Probably a spouse or lover's grave. Personally, I think Luke was getting it on with one of his students, had a kid, had to hide her, dropped her off on Jakku, then Kylo Ren massacred her and the rest of the Jedis in training. He blames himself for her death and Kylo Ren's fall to the dark side so he bails. |
|
|
Quoted:
That's my take. My brother-in-Law insists she has to be another of Han's. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. That's my take. My brother-in-Law insists she has to be another of Han's. Possible, but theres practically nothing that points to it. Wouldn't Han and Leia at least mention her when talking about their son? Why would they have her dumped on Jakku? |
|
Quoted:
Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Also, Click To View Spoiler Did it seem like this new "awakening" of the Force seem to include some new abilities? Freezing a blaster bolt seems new - they were always deflected before. And Rey's blinky-eyed Force Download that helped her beat Kylo seemed new too. Just overthinking it, like usual. Click To View Spoiler Perhaps the mind reading was always a force power, but jedis and sith with proper training knew better than to use it because its a two way street when used on someone with force sensitivity. i also think that scene is why the movie is called the force awakens, and explains why rey adapts to the force so quickly, she saw into kylo's mind and was able to skip a lot of the learning curve. Posted Via AR15.Com Mobile Click To View Spoiler Luke and Vader were reading each others' minds during the final light saber battle in ROTJ. "your thoughts betray you" "Sister. You have a sister. Your thoughts have now betrayed her too" |
|
Quoted:
Possible, but theres practically nothing that points to it. Wouldn't Han and Leia at least mention her when talking about their son? Why would they have her dumped on Jakku? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. That's my take. My brother-in-Law insists she has to be another of Han's. Possible, but theres practically nothing that points to it. Wouldn't Han and Leia at least mention her when talking about their son? Why would they have her dumped on Jakku? He keeps resorting to books and graphic novel references when we have this discussion. |
|
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. The signs other than her force sensitivity: 1. Maz saying to Rey "that was Luke Skywalker's light saber and his fathers before him. Now it calls to you." 2. Luke looked like he was standing over a grave marked by a stone that blended in very well with the other rocks. Probably a spouse or lover's grave. Personally, I think Luke was getting it on with one of his students, had a kid, had to hide her, dropped her off on Jakku, then Kylo Ren massacred her and the rest of the Jedis in training. He blames himself for her death and Kylo Ren's fall to the dark side so he bails. View Quote I called that the first time but I'm glad to watch it again, and watch for those specific things in the movie. I really would like to see the flashback again... kinda hoping that ends up on youtube sometime soon. |
|
Quoted:
He keeps resorting to books and graphic novel references when we have this discussion. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. That's my take. My brother-in-Law insists she has to be another of Han's. Possible, but theres practically nothing that points to it. Wouldn't Han and Leia at least mention her when talking about their son? Why would they have her dumped on Jakku? He keeps resorting to books and graphic novel references when we have this discussion. Discarded EU stuff or new stuff? If new material, what evidence is he supporting it with? |
|
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. The signs other than her force sensitivity: 1. Maz saying to Rey "that was Luke Skywalker's light saber and his fathers before him. Now it calls to you." 2. Luke looked like he was standing over a grave marked by a stone that blended in very well with the other rocks. Probably a spouse or lover's grave. Personally, I think Luke was getting it on with one of his students, had a kid, had to hide her, dropped her off on Jakku, then Kylo Ren massacred her and the rest of the Jedis in training. He blames himself for her death and Kylo Ren's fall to the dark side so he bails. View Quote That's what I came away with as well. |
|
Quoted:
I think a lot of people convinced themselves it sucked before they saw it. View Quote I was actually pumped for this movie, bought tickets when they became aavailable, was giddy like school girl when the title came up. Halfway through I realized this was a shitty movie dressed up as star wars. The acting was great, the writing and directing was shit. Jj Abrams was a terrible, unoriginal pick for director. |
|
Lots of entertaining reviews on IMDb.
Sad but true. When the opening credits filled the screen (Episode VII... blah blah) I was already grinding my teeth because the plot sounded idiotic. Then the huge star destroyer filled the screen. The fun bit is that the star destroyer had some sort of antenna or whatever at the front and it looked liked the ship was showing the middle finger towards the viewers. I have to congratulate the film makers as that was pretty much how the film worked from that point forward. 1) A droid has important information that must be delivered to the good guys (Episode IV, anyone?) 2) so the bad guys hunt for the droid on a desert planet (IV) 3) Storm troopers raid a village, killing everyone (IV) 4) A girl is captured by the bad guys and the good guys rush to the base to the rescue. (IV) 5) The girl and the boy have a friend zone relationship through the film (Ep IV, Luke & Leia, wouldn't be surprised to learn that they are siblings in Episode IX) 6) The stormtroopers, elite soldiers of the bad guys, still can't hit a barn door. On the other hand, the good guys always hit, even when they use a weapon for the first time in their life 7) Supreme Leader Snoke = Emperor with a silly name 8) The bad guys have a magnificent new weapon that can destroy planets (Ep IV) 9) They use it to destroy a planet loyal to the rebels (IV) 10) The weapon has shields that can be destroyed by going down on the planet and disabling the shield generator (VI) 11) The epic villain wears a mask that distorts his voice (IV) and sadly, looks better with the mask on than without it. 12) The good guys can only destroy the weapon with an attack by X-Wings on the exact target (IV) 13) The X-Wings have to fly in a tight trench in order to reach their target (IV) The screen writers had absolutely no new ideas to show for their money. A bunch of monkeys could have written better dialogue. A 1st grader could have made a plot that had less holes in it. The special effects were pretty much of the same quality as in the first Star Wars movie that was released 1977. I'd expect something way better in 2015. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2488496/reviews?start=10 |
|
Quoted:
You're stoned. Manos: the Hands of Fate couldn't make the prequels decent flicks. TFA is ten times the film any of the prequels were. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
The only one good thing in TFA is that it makes the prequels decent flicks. You're stoned. Manos: the Hands of Fate couldn't make the prequels decent flicks. TFA is ten times the film any of the prequels were. I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. It's going to be great to see the Lego remakes and the plinkett review though. |
|
Quoted:
I'm pretty sure there were TiEs running overwatch that were still in the air. Besides, the transport has armor and shields and guns too. Also, in respect to the TiEs, what the hell was up with the weird gunners position. And since when did TiEs have a gunners position? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Did the Command Shuttle leave the cantina before the X-Wings showed up? Because they should have shot on the shit out of this if it was on the ground: http://vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/starwars/images/d/d7/KyloRenCommandShuttle-Fathead.png/revision/latest?cb=20150908050616 I'm pretty sure there were TiEs running overwatch that were still in the air. Besides, the transport has armor and shields and guns too. Also, in respect to the TiEs, what the hell was up with the weird gunners position. And since when did TiEs have a gunners position? Had to make it cool and edgy. It was confusing as hell because we thought he was firing backwards, but he was just sitting backwards and firing forwards. Apparently tie pilots of today can't do both. And xwing pilots are also bombers now too. |
|
Quoted:
Lots of entertaining reviews on IMDb. Sad but true. When the opening credits filled the screen (EpisodeVII... blah blah) I was already grinding my teeth because the plotsounded idiotic. Then the huge star destroyer filled the screen. Thefun bit is that the star destroyer had some sort of antenna or whateverat the front and it looked liked the ship was showing the middle fingertowards the viewers. I have to congratulate the film makers as that was pretty much how thefilm worked from that point forward. 1) A droid has important information that must be delivered to the goodguys (Episode IV, anyone?) 2) so the bad guys hunt for the droid on a desert planet (IV) 3) Storm troopers raid a village, killing everyone (IV) 4) A girl is captured by the bad guys and the good guys rush to thebase to the rescue. (IV) 5) The girl and the boy have a friend zone relationship through thefilm (Ep IV, Luke & Leia, wouldn't be surprised to learn that they aresiblings in Episode IX) 6) The stormtroopers, elite soldiers of the bad guys, still can't hit abarn door. On the other hand, the good guys always hit, even when theyuse a weapon for the first time in their life 7) Supreme Leader Snoke = Emperor with a silly name 8) The bad guys have a magnificent new weapon that can destroy planets(Ep IV) 9) They use it to destroy a planet loyal to the rebels (IV) 10) The weapon has shields that can be destroyed by going down on theplanet and disabling the shield generator (VI) 11) The epic villain wears a mask that distorts his voice (IV) andsadly, looks better with the mask on than without it. 12) The good guys can only destroy the weapon with an attack by X-Wingson the exact target (IV) 13) The X-Wings have to fly in a tight trench in order to reach theirtarget (IV) The screen writers had absolutely no new ideas to show for their money.A bunch of monkeys could have written better dialogue. A 1st gradercould have made a plot that had less holes in it. The special effectswere pretty much of the same quality as in the first Star Wars moviethat was released 1977. I'd expect something way better in 2015. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2488496/reviews?start=10 View Quote While all that stuff is true, similar arguments could be made about a lot of other movies and other things. All war movies: Some people disagreed so they fought. Weapons were used. People died. Someone won. Point I'm making is those similarities don't bother me. The films take place in the same universe, a lot of the same characters, so naturally similarities will exist. |
|
Quoted:
I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
The only one good thing in TFA is that it makes the prequels decent flicks. You're stoned. Manos: the Hands of Fate couldn't make the prequels decent flicks. TFA is ten times the film any of the prequels were. I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. Yeah, I'm thinking you're off your nut. It wasn't Oscar worthy, but it was well made, well acted and incredible visually. The critics were just as positive about it as the fans and they aren't generally ga-ga about SFX. |
|
Quoted:
I was actually pumped for this movie, bought tickets when they became aavailable, was giddy like school girl when the title came up. Halfway through I realized this was a shitty movie dressed up as star wars. The acting was great, the writing and directing was shit. Jj Abrams was a terrible, unoriginal pick for director. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
I think a lot of people convinced themselves it sucked before they saw it. I was actually pumped for this movie, bought tickets when they became aavailable, was giddy like school girl when the title came up. Halfway through I realized this was a shitty movie dressed up as star wars. The acting was great, the writing and directing was shit. Jj Abrams was a terrible, unoriginal pick for director. Still better than the last director. Granted, the movie was not Schindler's List but as a Star Wars movie it was damn good. I place it in the top 3 of all the Star Wars movies. |
|
Quoted:
I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. It's going to be great to see the Lego remakes and the plinkett review though. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
The only one good thing in TFA is that it makes the prequels decent flicks. You're stoned. Manos: the Hands of Fate couldn't make the prequels decent flicks. TFA is ten times the film any of the prequels were. I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. It's going to be great to see the Lego remakes and the plinkett review though. Lets be fair though, when you look at the Star Wars movies as actual movies and not just Star Wars movies they are actually not very good. The acting was always bad and the stories were always shallow. That being said though, this is Star Wars and they get judged by a different standard. |
|
Quoted:
Still better than the last director. Granted, the movie was not Schindler's List but as a Star Wars movie it was damn good. I place it in the top 3 of all the Star Wars movies. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I think a lot of people convinced themselves it sucked before they saw it. I was actually pumped for this movie, bought tickets when they became aavailable, was giddy like school girl when the title came up. Halfway through I realized this was a shitty movie dressed up as star wars. The acting was great, the writing and directing was shit. Jj Abrams was a terrible, unoriginal pick for director. Still better than the last director. Granted, the movie was not Schindler's List but as a Star Wars movie it was damn good. I place it in the top 3 of all the Star Wars movies. So do you compare all movies to Schindler's list? |
|
Quoted:
So do you compare all movies to Schindler's list? View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I think a lot of people convinced themselves it sucked before they saw it. I was actually pumped for this movie, bought tickets when they became aavailable, was giddy like school girl when the title came up. Halfway through I realized this was a shitty movie dressed up as star wars. The acting was great, the writing and directing was shit. Jj Abrams was a terrible, unoriginal pick for director. Still better than the last director. Granted, the movie was not Schindler's List but as a Star Wars movie it was damn good. I place it in the top 3 of all the Star Wars movies. So do you compare all movies to Schindler's list? I was trying to point out that there are movies and then there is Star Wars. The only good way to judge a Star Wars movie is by comparing it to another Star Wars movie. |
|
Quoted:
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. The signs other than her force sensitivity: 1. Maz saying to Rey "that was Luke Skywalker's light saber and his fathers before him. Now it calls to you." 2. Luke looked like he was standing over a grave marked by a stone that blended in very well with the other rocks. Probably a spouse or lover's grave. Personally, I think Luke was getting it on with one of his students, had a kid, had to hide her, dropped her off on Jakku, then Kylo Ren massacred her and the rest of the Jedis in training. He blames himself for her death and Kylo Ren's fall to the dark side so he bails. That's what I came away with as well. Same here. And I personally think that Snoke is actually Darth Plagueis. |
|
Quoted:
I was trying to point out that there are movies and then there is Star Wars. The only good way to judge a Star Wars movie is by comparing it to another Star Wars movie. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
I think a lot of people convinced themselves it sucked before they saw it. I was actually pumped for this movie, bought tickets when they became aavailable, was giddy like school girl when the title came up. Halfway through I realized this was a shitty movie dressed up as star wars. The acting was great, the writing and directing was shit. Jj Abrams was a terrible, unoriginal pick for director. Still better than the last director. Granted, the movie was not Schindler's List but as a Star Wars movie it was damn good. I place it in the top 3 of all the Star Wars movies. So do you compare all movies to Schindler's list? I was trying to point out that there are movies and then there is Star Wars. The only good way to judge a Star Wars movie is by comparing it to another Star Wars movie. I get your point but I disagree. Lots of scifi movies to compare it to. |
|
Quoted:
I was trying to point out that there are movies and then there is Star Wars. The only good way to judge a Star Wars movie is by comparing it to another Star Wars movie. View Quote This. You can't compare it to, say, Ben-Hur, or The Seven Samurai, or North By Northwest. You have to compare it to how well it measures up to TESB (Which is widely regarded as the pinnacle of Star Wars films) |
|
Quoted:
Same here. And I personally think that Snoke is actually Darth Plagueis. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:
Quoted:
After seeing the movie a second time, I'm calling it: Rey is Luke's daughter. The signs other than her force sensitivity: 1. Maz saying to Rey "that was Luke Skywalker's light saber and his fathers before him. Now it calls to you." 2. Luke looked like he was standing over a grave marked by a stone that blended in very well with the other rocks. Probably a spouse or lover's grave. Personally, I think Luke was getting it on with one of his students, had a kid, had to hide her, dropped her off on Jakku, then Kylo Ren massacred her and the rest of the Jedis in training. He blames himself for her death and Kylo Ren's fall to the dark side so he bails. That's what I came away with as well. Same here. And I personally think that Snoke is actually Darth Plagueis. I suspect that as well but I am not familiar enough with how Plagueis was (not) killed. Snoke did appear to have a big scar on his head. Did Sidious slash him with his saber to do him in? |
|
It felt like Star wars, but didn't. I kind of lean toward it was a mistake to use the originals after such a long gap. In Starlog or something during the original trilogy, Lucas' original plan was prequel trilogy and sequal trilogy.
|
|
Quoted:
While all that stuff is true, similar arguments could be made about a lot of other movies and other things. All war movies: Some people disagreed so they fought. Weapons were used. People died. Someone won. Point I'm making is those similarities don't bother me. The films take place in the same universe, a lot of the same characters, so naturally similarities will exist. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted:
Quoted:snip While all that stuff is true, similar arguments could be made about a lot of other movies and other things. All war movies: Some people disagreed so they fought. Weapons were used. People died. Someone won. Point I'm making is those similarities don't bother me. The films take place in the same universe, a lot of the same characters, so naturally similarities will exist. Will you still be saying that when the next movie (VIII) features the following? ~Kylo hunts down the Resistance and puts the Resistance on the run (aka Battle of Endor) ~Rey trains with Luke (aka Luke goes to Dagobah to train under Yoda) ~Somebody gets captured by Kylo and is used as a lure for Rey (aka Leia and Han getting captured and Luke coming to the rescue at Cloud City) ~Rey loses the fight with Kylo but survives and escapes (Vader vs Luke at Cloud City) I actually really liked Episode VII, but while watching it (today), it definitely felt like a rehashed IV. |
|
Quoted: I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. It's going to be great to see the Lego remakes and the plinkett review though. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: The only one good thing in TFA is that it makes the prequels decent flicks. You're stoned. Manos: the Hands of Fate couldn't make the prequels decent flicks. TFA is ten times the film any of the prequels were. I think as the months and years go on, people are going to realize how shallow and terrible this movie is, once the "omg graphics!" Wears off and folks really watch it. It's going to be great to see the Lego remakes and the plinkett review though. I think as the months and years go on, people will continue to like it and you'll realize that your opinion is in a very small minority. |
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.