User Panel
|
Quoted: another thing I really don't understand is why air cooled 911 engines are so expensive to make big power? the only thing I can see is taking the heat out the engine, and if that's the biggest issue...fuck...just add giant oil coolers and extra oil capacity. View Quote NA Air cooled HP is the most expensive horsepower there is. My little 3 liter already takes 12+ qts of oil and has two oil coolers. |
|
|
Quoted: All cars are too big now. The price you pay for safety and technology. https://www.topgear.com/sites/default/files/news-listicle/image/2015/09/p13_0019_a4_rgb.jpg View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: The 911 has grown too large. The cayman is closer to the size a 911 should be. That is a good point. The modern 911 is huge compared to old-school models. All cars are too big now. The price you pay for safety and technology. https://www.topgear.com/sites/default/files/news-listicle/image/2015/09/p13_0019_a4_rgb.jpg Attached File This is what I wanted back in the 80s: Attached File Attached File However as mentioned, the 911 has turned more into a touring car vs. a sports car. Attached File So, I got a 2021 Cayman GTS 4.0 instead of the 911. Attached File |
|
Quoted: For the experts here: if I wanted a 911 to buy used for a short work commute (approx 10 miles each way) and weekends- what years to look for and not spend a ton. I have a great independent shop for German car maintenance. Thanks. View Quote For an air cooled anything from 1978 to 1986 for a water cooled I’d go with a 1999-2004 for the best value. |
|
Quoted: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_4920_jpeg-2938464.JPG This is what I wanted back in the 80s: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3527_jpeg-2938468.JPG https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3526_jpeg-2938465.JPG However as mentioned, the 911 has turned more into a touring car vs. a sports car. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3851_jpeg-2938469.JPG So, I got a 2021 Cayman GTS 4.0 instead of the 911. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/NEW_8354_jpeg-2938473.JPG View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: The 911 has grown too large. The cayman is closer to the size a 911 should be. That is a good point. The modern 911 is huge compared to old-school models. All cars are too big now. The price you pay for safety and technology. https://www.topgear.com/sites/default/files/news-listicle/image/2015/09/p13_0019_a4_rgb.jpg https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_4920_jpeg-2938464.JPG This is what I wanted back in the 80s: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3527_jpeg-2938468.JPG https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3526_jpeg-2938465.JPG However as mentioned, the 911 has turned more into a touring car vs. a sports car. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3851_jpeg-2938469.JPG So, I got a 2021 Cayman GTS 4.0 instead of the 911. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/NEW_8354_jpeg-2938473.JPG I love your Cayman and think the 4.0 will go down as one of the all time great sports cars. Some day you’ll want to scratch that air cooled itch and IMO the SC is a great way to do it. That 2750lb number seems way too high for the SC. Mine is just over 2400 and I haven’t done much to add lightness. |
|
Quoted: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_4920_jpeg-2938464.JPG This is what I wanted back in the 80s: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3527_jpeg-2938468.JPG https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3526_jpeg-2938465.JPG However as mentioned, the 911 has turned more into a touring car vs. a sports car. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3851_jpeg-2938469.JPG So, I got a 2021 Cayman GTS 4.0 instead of the 911. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/NEW_8354_jpeg-2938473.JPG View Quote Manual or PDK? ETA I see manual in the chart, I take it to mean you got a manual? Would you mind discussing why you chose what you did? |
|
Quoted: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_4920_jpeg-2938464.JPG This is what I wanted back in the 80s: https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3527_jpeg-2938468.JPG https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3526_jpeg-2938465.JPG However as mentioned, the 911 has turned more into a touring car vs. a sports car. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_3851_jpeg-2938469.JPG So, I got a 2021 Cayman GTS 4.0 instead of the 911. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/NEW_8354_jpeg-2938473.JPG View Quote Nice. I think the GTS is the right place to be with the Cayman. The flat 6 is just special. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
Quoted: When you are a young single guy some things are worth eating soup beans and selling plasma for. Most young guys waste their money on the wrong thing that starts with the letter P. View Quote Yup! Luckily I wasn't so foolish. Spent all mine on neat guns, but it's time to waste money on a neat car. |
|
Quoted: Yup! Luckily I wasn't so foolish. Spent all mine on neat guns, but it's time to waste money on a neat car. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: When you are a young single guy some things are worth eating soup beans and selling plasma for. Most young guys waste their money on the wrong thing that starts with the letter P. Yup! Luckily I wasn't so foolish. Spent all mine on neat guns, but it's time to waste money on a neat car. I'll accept Pistols as a correct answer to the question of, "What thing that starts with the letter P should I spend my money on?' |
|
|
Quoted: I don’t think a Midcap sized woman could fit in a 911 to be perfectly honest. It’s a moot point. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Quoted: Porsche has always kneecapped the Cayman/Boxster so the 911 would remain King. The mid engine design is more balanced, and is a better sports car design. If they put a bigger engine in the Cayman it would outperform the 911. But because they have never done that, and will never do that, the 911 is arguably "better". However, the rear engine design is flawed in a high performance sports car, especially for novice driver's who may panic and hit the brakes in high speed turns and throw the 911 into a spin. But they are both great cars, it's subjective. Personally, I'd rather have an air cooled 911 Targa. Initially they hamstrung the Cayman but the GTS 4.0 and GT4 changed that. I’m going to disagree about the rear engine design being flawed and point back to the fact the 911 is the winningest sports car of all time and has won across far more racing disciplines than anything else. There are some real advantages to the rear engine layout, braking and traction out of corners for example. You are right about the danger with a novice behind the wheel but a good driver can use that pendulum effect to his advantage Here’s a great video of a really good driver showing you how to drive a 911. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_q_YDSgRa1U I like how everyone thinks that a car with terrible handling characteristics makes it a good car. I like how you think the most prolific sports car of all time that’s been winning all kinds of races for almost 60 years has “terrible handling characteristics”. Yeah, but also You think Fat chicks have good handling characteristics.. sooo, I’m not sure your opinion on “handling characteristics” has a lot of validity? I don’t think a Midcap sized woman could fit in a 911 to be perfectly honest. It’s a moot point. 911...yes...coxster and boxster...no |
|
Quoted: NA Air cooled HP is the most expensive horsepower there is. My little 3 liter already takes 12+ qts of oil and has two oil coolers. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: another thing I really don't understand is why air cooled 911 engines are so expensive to make big power? the only thing I can see is taking the heat out the engine, and if that's the biggest issue...fuck...just add giant oil coolers and extra oil capacity. NA Air cooled HP is the most expensive horsepower there is. My little 3 liter already takes 12+ qts of oil and has two oil coolers. but why? makes no sense to me...just keep adding coolers...the part of the engine that is going to have the most heat applied to it is going to be the pistons...and there are a myriad of coatings and material tech already out there. Which goes back to keeping the oil cool, IMO it's just a bunch of mark up they charge because they can. It's not like the material sciences are adding that much more money to the build. Now, if you are running somthing like a inconel 3d printed exhasut manifold...yeah that's pricey. |
|
Quoted: but why? makes no sense to me...just keep adding coolers...the part of the engine that is going to have the most heat applied to it is going to be the pistons...and there are a myriad of coatings and material tech already out there. Which goes back to keeping the oil cool, IMO it's just a bunch of mark up they charge because they can. It's not like the material sciences are adding that much more money to the build. Now, if you are running somthing like a inconel 3d printed exhasut manifold...yeah that's pricey. View Quote No, it's insane markup on an otherwise very simple engine. For example, I want to go from 3.0 to 3.2 which is commonly referred to as a "short stroke 3.2", the pistons/cylinders are over $6k, then new cams would be a good idea and those are $1500-2000k then upgrading the fuel injection from CIS to ITBs are fucking crazy money, hell, PMO carbs are $6k and that doesn't including upgrading the fuel lines/pump then tuning. I'm a little bitter because to build the 3.2 SS I want is around $20-22k in parts and I'll go from 180hp to maybe 250hp. It'll rip though, they're very light and geared kinda short. Oh, and that's only doing the top end, not even splitting the case. |
|
Quoted: Yeah, wrong guy, you're thinking of Midcap. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Yeah, but also You think Fat chicks have good handling characteristics.. sooo, I’m not sure your opinion on “handling characteristics” has a lot of validity? Yeah, wrong guy, you're thinking of Midcap. Lolz, somehow I quoted the guy that was already roasting him. Fixed. |
|
Quoted: No, it's insane markup on an otherwise very simple engine. For example, I want to go from 3.0 to 3.2 which is commonly referred to as a "short stroke 3.2", the pistons/cylinders are over $6k, then new cams would be a good idea and those are $1500-2000k then upgrading the fuel injection from CIS to ITBs are fucking crazy money, hell, PMO carbs are $6k and that doesn't including upgrading the fuel lines/pump then tuning. I'm a little bitter because to build the 3.2 SS I want is around $20-22k in parts and I'll go from 180hp to maybe 250hp. It'll rip though, they're very light and geared kinda short. Oh, and that's only doing the top end, not even splitting the case. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: but why? makes no sense to me...just keep adding coolers...the part of the engine that is going to have the most heat applied to it is going to be the pistons...and there are a myriad of coatings and material tech already out there. Which goes back to keeping the oil cool, IMO it's just a bunch of mark up they charge because they can. It's not like the material sciences are adding that much more money to the build. Now, if you are running somthing like a inconel 3d printed exhasut manifold...yeah that's pricey. No, it's insane markup on an otherwise very simple engine. For example, I want to go from 3.0 to 3.2 which is commonly referred to as a "short stroke 3.2", the pistons/cylinders are over $6k, then new cams would be a good idea and those are $1500-2000k then upgrading the fuel injection from CIS to ITBs are fucking crazy money, hell, PMO carbs are $6k and that doesn't including upgrading the fuel lines/pump then tuning. I'm a little bitter because to build the 3.2 SS I want is around $20-22k in parts and I'll go from 180hp to maybe 250hp. It'll rip though, they're very light and geared kinda short. Oh, and that's only doing the top end, not even splitting the case. that literally makes no sense on those prices. you can get fully custom pistons from carillo for waaaaaaaaaaay less. as far as cams....there are a myriad of companies than can custom make cams. as far as the carbs....that's even more retarded....you can get a EFI controller for like $400 that will control all 6 injectors and you would just need a fuel rail and a tach signal after that then tune the engine. |
|
Quoted: I believe there is a 5% of net worth rule, $3M in NW means you get to spend $150K on a car. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: How much do you Porsche aficionado’s earn? Arfcom has a way of making me feel poor. I believe there is a 5% of net worth rule, $3M in NW means you get to spend $150K on a car. What it I’m providing cars for the whole family? Would that buck fiddy, need to be divided by 4? Or, do I get $150k for myself, and 10-20k for the others? |
|
Why Matt's New 565HP, Naturally-Aspirated 4.5L DeMan 718 Spyder is the Perfect Sports Car Custom 4.5 L engine. |
|
Cayman and 911 are close, but Cayman is more Miata like and 911 more Sedan DeVille like.
Am I wrong? |
|
Quoted: I don’t think a Midcap sized woman could fit in a 911 to be perfectly honest. It’s a moot point. View Quote Actually, the 911 has the roomiest cabin of the cars mentioned here. R8…..nope. GTR….gonna be tight. Cayman……nope. Ferrari or Lambo…….nope. McLaren….uh no. C8…..gonna be tight. |
|
|
Quoted: For the experts here: if I wanted a 911 to buy used for a short work commute (approx 10 miles each way) and weekends- what years to look for and not spend a ton. I have a great independent shop for German car maintenance. Thanks. View Quote I think limiting a Porsche to 20 miles a day would be a terrible idea. They need to be driven and driven hard once warmed up. 10 miles each way won’t allow for that. |
|
I'm going to pick up one of these this evening. Who wants to guess which?
|
|
|
I’m on my third 911 4S AWD as a daily when not hauling all the kids. Cayman has a great use case as a dedicated track fun car
|
|
Quoted: that literally makes no sense on those prices. you can get fully custom pistons from carillo for waaaaaaaaaaay less. as far as cams....there are a myriad of companies than can custom make cams. as far as the carbs....that's even more retarded....you can get a EFI controller for like $400 that will control all 6 injectors and you would just need a fuel rail and a tach signal after that then tune the engine. View Quote It's pistons AND cylinders, only two options for carbs PMO or used Webers, and Porsche cams are expensive, possible to get the stock cams reground but not sure. Also, the EFI kit for an old 911 are big bucks, it's not the controller but the manifolds and wiring, etc. I agree though, way overpriced. Hell, I contacted a guy about rebuilding my heads for twin plugs and it was around $4k, but that's a complete rebuild with replacing exhaust valves/springs and heli-coiling everything due to age and that just what happens on air cooled engines. It's ridiculous, luckily my engine is in great shape and doesn't need anything. Now I'm getting angry. |
|
Here is what my choice will be.
981 Cayman GTS (used 2014-2016) 718 Cayman GTS 4.0 (new 2024) Any comments? Recommendations? |
|
Quoted: Manual or PDK? ETA I see manual in the chart, I take it to mean you got a manual? Would you mind discussing why you chose what you did? View Quote Of course I went manual. Would have been blasphemy to do otherwise in light of what the Cayman is soon to become. Same thought with the leather interior. Attached File |
|
Quoted: Of course I went manual. Would have been blasphemy to do otherwise in light of what the Cayman is soon to become. Same thought with the leather interior. https://www.ar15.com/media/mediaFiles/64530/IMG_2533_jpeg-2938678.JPG View Quote Ah, like BMW M, they must be killing off ICE and manuals. Enjoy it in good health! |
|
Quoted: I’m on my third 911 4S AWD as a daily when not hauling all the kids. Cayman has a great use case as a dedicated track fun car View Quote I use mine as a camper: Attached File Attached File Attached File Attached File Attached File |
|
Quoted: Here is what my choice will be. 981 Cayman GTS (used 2014-2016) 718 Cayman GTS 4.0 (new 2024) Any comments? Recommendations? View Quote If you can get an allocation and spec it how you want I would do that. Only suggestion would be not to do any crazy colors or options. Otherwise watch for the people that don’t have a garage for winter selling theirs. |
|
Quoted: If you can get an allocation and spec it how you want I would do that. Only suggestion would be not to do any crazy colors or options. Otherwise watch for the people that don’t have a garage for winter selling theirs. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: Here is what my choice will be. 981 Cayman GTS (used 2014-2016) 718 Cayman GTS 4.0 (new 2024) Any comments? Recommendations? If you can get an allocation and spec it how you want I would do that. Only suggestion would be not to do any crazy colors or options. Otherwise watch for the people that don’t have a garage for winter selling theirs. This is my first rough cut. Will have to refine it with the wife. She's all in! https://configurator.porsche.com/en-US/model/982160?options=030.085.121.153.196.1G8.220.340.342.439.444.446.454.480.482.534.567.573.594.607.638.657.714.810.970.9VK.9WT.BM.EKG.I8L.M1R.P07.QR5.U2.UI2.UX7.XAT.XEW.XHW.XLM.XLW.XXP.Z1S#section-summary |
|
Quoted: but why? makes no sense to me...just keep adding coolers...the part of the engine that is going to have the most heat applied to it is going to be the pistons...and there are a myriad of coatings and material tech already out there. Which goes back to keeping the oil cool, IMO it's just a bunch of mark up they charge because they can. It's not like the material sciences are adding that much more money to the build. Now, if you are running somthing like a inconel 3d printed exhasut manifold...yeah that's pricey. View Quote Emissions regulations is another reason they run hot. Also, there really isn’t any extra room to mount additional oil coolers. You’d have to get really creative. The SC’s have a “trombone” in the forward section of the passenger wheel well. The 3.2 Carreras have a finned oil cooler there which is right behind the passenger side headlight. Starting in ‘87 for the 3.2’s, they had an electric fan that helped pull the air through the oil cooler. To make cooling issues worse, one of the two factory AC condensers is located just above the motor. . . The other is located down low just behind the front valance. There’s over 20 feet of AC hoses. |
|
Quoted: It's pistons AND cylinders, only two options for carbs PMO or used Webers, and Porsche cams are expensive, possible to get the stock cams reground but not sure. Also, the EFI kit for an old 911 are big bucks, it's not the controller but the manifolds and wiring, etc. I agree though, way overpriced. Hell, I contacted a guy about rebuilding my heads for twin plugs and it was around $4k, but that's a complete rebuild with replacing exhaust valves/springs and heli-coiling everything due to age and that just what happens on air cooled engines. It's ridiculous, luckily my engine is in great shape and doesn't need anything. Now I'm getting angry. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Quoted: Quoted: that literally makes no sense on those prices. you can get fully custom pistons from carillo for waaaaaaaaaaay less. as far as cams....there are a myriad of companies than can custom make cams. as far as the carbs....that's even more retarded....you can get a EFI controller for like $400 that will control all 6 injectors and you would just need a fuel rail and a tach signal after that then tune the engine. It's pistons AND cylinders, only two options for carbs PMO or used Webers, and Porsche cams are expensive, possible to get the stock cams reground but not sure. Also, the EFI kit for an old 911 are big bucks, it's not the controller but the manifolds and wiring, etc. I agree though, way overpriced. Hell, I contacted a guy about rebuilding my heads for twin plugs and it was around $4k, but that's a complete rebuild with replacing exhaust valves/springs and heli-coiling everything due to age and that just what happens on air cooled engines. It's ridiculous, luckily my engine is in great shape and doesn't need anything. Now I'm getting angry. It's all basic machine work man...those guys are just ass raping everyone because they can |
|
|
|
Quoted: I'm going to have to drive both. Thank you. View Quote View All Quotes View All Quotes Do you drive your car for the enjoyment of driving? For the connection to the car? The road? If yes, you’ll love the 6MT. Do you prefer to drive with your Starbucks in your left hand, or you plan to commute/drive in traffic a lot, or plan to chase lap times? If yes, you need the PDK. Otherwise, either will do fine for you. |
|
|
At 6'4 " both are hero cars. The Cayman is the true sportsman's car, the 911is pure sex! I've experienced similar in a Mercedes 500 and a Maserati Spyder, the Maserati was faster, the Mercedes was smoother and more controlled.
|
|
Sign up for the ARFCOM weekly newsletter and be entered to win a free ARFCOM membership. One new winner* is announced every week!
You will receive an email every Friday morning featuring the latest chatter from the hottest topics, breaking news surrounding legislation, as well as exclusive deals only available to ARFCOM email subscribers.
AR15.COM is the world's largest firearm community and is a gathering place for firearm enthusiasts of all types.
From hunters and military members, to competition shooters and general firearm enthusiasts, we welcome anyone who values and respects the way of the firearm.
Subscribe to our monthly Newsletter to receive firearm news, product discounts from your favorite Industry Partners, and more.
Copyright © 1996-2024 AR15.COM LLC. All Rights Reserved.
Any use of this content without express written consent is prohibited.
AR15.Com reserves the right to overwrite or replace any affiliate, commercial, or monetizable links, posted by users, with our own.